Abstract
Consumers conducting comparison shopping, researchers making sense of competitive space, and developers looking for code snippets online all face the challenge of capturing the information they find for later use without interrupting their current flow. In addition, during many learning and exploration tasks, people need to externalize their mental context, such as estimating how urgent a topic is to follow up on, or rating a piece of evidence as a "pro" or "con," which helps scaffold subsequent deeper exploration. However, current approaches incur a high cost, often requiring users to select, copy, context switch, paste, and annotate information in a separate document without offering specific affordances that capture their mental context. In this work, we explore a new interaction technique called "wiggling," which can be used to fluidly collect, organize, and rate information during early sensemaking stages with a single gesture. Wiggling involves rapid back-and-forth movements of a pointer or up-and-down scrolling on a smartphone, which can indicate the information to be collected and its valence, using a single, light-weight gesture that does not interfere with other interactions that are already available. Through implementation and user evaluation, we found that wiggling helped participants accurately collect information and encode their mental context with a 58% reduction in operational cost while being 24% faster compared to a common baseline.
Introduction
Online sensemaking—whether researching a medical diagnosis, comparison shopping, or hunting for code snippets—is a cognitively demanding process. It traditionally involves two distinct phases: foraging (finding information) and sensemaking (organizing and understanding it).
Existing tools for the foraging phase often impose a high "interaction tax." Standard workflows require users to precisely select text, copy it, switch to a different tab or application, paste the content, and manually annotate why that specific information was relevant. This friction frequently leads users to keep mental judgments in their heads, where they are easily forgotten, or to skip collecting useful information altogether to avoid breaking their reading flow. Mobile devices exacerbate these issues due to finicky selection handles and limited screen real estate. Wigglite addresses these challenges by introducing "wiggling"—a rapid back-and-forth gesture—as a low-friction method for collecting and triaging web content.
The Wiggle Interaction
The core innovation of Wigglite is the wiggle gesture, designed to be fluid and non-disruptive:
- Desktop: A user moves the mouse pointer rapidly left and right over a piece of content.
- Mobile: A user performs a rapid up-and-down "micro-scroll" with their finger.
Wigglite utilizes a lightweight, heuristic-based recognizer that counts direction reversals in real-time. This allows for "eager recognition," providing immediate visual feedback—such as a "tail" following the cursor or a dotted border around the content—without the latency associated with complex machine-learning models.
System Implementation
Built as a Chrome extension and a mobile browser app on top of the Skeema task management system, Wigglite includes several key features:
- Target Snapping: The system automatically identifies logical "information blocks" (paragraphs, images, or divs) based on the scale of the wiggle, aligning with how users naturally perceive units of information.
- Chained Metadata: If a user concludes a wiggle with a directional swipe, they can encode metadata instantly. For instance, swiping right marks a "pro," swiping left marks a "con," and swiping up or down assigns priority levels or creates new topics.
- The Holding Tank: Collected clips are automatically sent to a sidebar where they can be filtered by valence (rating) or priority during later organization phases.
Evaluation
To evaluate the efficacy of wiggling, the authors conducted a within-subjects lab study with 12 participants. Participants performed two sensemaking tasks: researching digital cameras and shopping for vacuum cleaners. The study compared Wigglite against a baseline version of Skeema that utilized traditional text selection and screenshot clipping.
Key Results
The study yielded significant quantitative and qualitative improvements:
- 58% Reduction in Operational Overhead: Users spent significantly less time managing the tool and more time comprehending content.
- 24% Faster Task Completion: Despite collecting nearly double the number of clips compared to the baseline, users finished their research tasks faster.
- High Accuracy: The heuristic recognizer was robust, with only 1.5% of wiggles being accidental or requiring an undo.
- In-Situ Externalization: By capturing "valence" (is this good or bad?) at the moment of discovery, users prevented the loss of mental context that typically occurs when moving between foraging and organization.
Participants described the interaction as "fun" and "organic," noting that it felt as though they "didn't do anything" to successfully capture snippets into the system.
Discussion and Future Work
While Wigglite significantly lowers the cost of information capture, several areas for future exploration remain. The rapid motion required for wiggling may present challenges for users with motor impairments; future iterations could incorporate smoothing algorithms to improve accessibility. Additionally, while low-cost capture is efficient, some research suggests that the "desirable difficulty" of manual note-taking can aid long-term memory. Future studies will investigate whether such a low-friction system affects long-term learning and decision quality.
Finally, the authors envision expanding the gesture language, mapping dimensions such as wiggle speed, duration, or intensity to different types of metadata, such as a user's confidence level in the information being collected.
Summary updated