Whole‐Genome Analyses Reveal the Distinct Taxonomic Status of the Hainan Population of Endangered Rucervus eldii and Its Conservation Implications

Chenqing Zheng, Qing Chen, Michelle Wong, Nick Marx, Thananh Khotpathoom, Hesheng Wang, Feng Yang, Xiaodong Rao, Bosco Pui Lok Chan, Yang LiuEvolutionary 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses whole-genome analysis to confirm that the Eld's deer population on Hainan Island, China, is a distinct subspecies (Rucervus eldii hainanus), separate from its mainland relatives. The research reveals critically low genetic diversity and high inbreeding in the Hainan population, likely due to past population bottlenecks and suboptimal translocation efforts, highlighting an urgent need for science-based conservation management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The taxonomic status of Eld's deer (Rucervus eldii) on Hainan Island has been debated for over a century: is it a unique island subspecies (R. e. hainanus) or simply an isolated population of the mainland subspecies (R. e. siamensis)? This distinction is crucial for conservation, as it dictates management strategies and legal protections. Furthermore, the Hainan population has suffered severe population declines and undergone multiple translocations, raising concerns about its genetic health, including reduced genetic diversity and increased inbreeding. This paper aims to resolve the taxonomic debate and assess the genetic consequences of these historical events to inform effective conservation.

Methods

The researchers employed conservation genomics, a powerful approach for understanding the genetic makeup of endangered species. They performed whole-genome sequencing on Eld's deer from Hainan (three subpopulations) and Cambodia (representing R. e. siamensis). Key methods included:

  • DNA Extraction and Sequencing: DNA was extracted from blood and skin samples, followed by library preparation and whole-genome sequencing using Illumina technology.
  • Data Processing: Raw sequencing reads were filtered, aligned to a reference genome (red deer), and single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified. Stringent filtering criteria were applied to ensure data quality.
  • Population Differentiation Analysis: To assess genetic structure, the team used phylogenetic tree construction, Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and admixture analysis (ADMIXTURE) on autosomal SNPs.
  • Demographic History Reconstruction: Methods like Stairway plot2 and GONE were used to infer historical population size changes and divergence times between the Hainan and Cambodia populations. Gene flow was also investigated using fastsimcoal.
  • Genetic Diversity and Inbreeding Assessment: Heterozygosity and nucleotide diversity were calculated. Runs of Homozygosity (ROH) were analyzed to quantify inbreeding levels (FROH).
  • Mutation Load Analysis: The study investigated the accumulation of deleterious mutations (missense and loss-of-function) using a method called RA/B, comparing heterozygous and homozygous variants between populations.

Datasets

The study utilized genomic data from:

  • Cambodia: 10 blood samples from the Phnom Tamao Zoological Park and Wildlife Rescue Centre.
  • Hainan Island, China: 20 blood samples from three isolated areas: Hainan Datian National Nature Reserve, Wenchang Eld's deer Management Station, and Bangxi Provincial Nature Reserve.
  • Laos: 4 skin samples from wild individuals.

One previously published dataset from Cambodia (CAM003) was excluded due to low sequencing depth. The study also referenced published heterozygosity data for 32 threatened mammalian species for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Subspecies Confirmed: The genomic data strongly supports the classification of the Hainan Eld's deer as a distinct subspecies, Rucervus eldii hainanus. This is a significant finding for its conservation status and management.
  • Genetic Bottleneck and Inbreeding: The Hainan population exhibits significantly reduced genetic diversity and increased inbreeding compared to the Cambodian population. This is a direct consequence of past population crashes and isolation.
  • Suboptimal Translocation: Differences in genetic diversity and inbreeding levels among the three Hainan subpopulations suggest that past translocation strategies may have been suboptimal, leading to further isolation and genetic issues.
  • Differential Mutation Load: While the Hainan population shows an accumulation of deleterious missense mutations, loss-of-function mutations appear to be more effectively purged, possibly due to strong purifying selection during bottleneck events.
  • Urgent Conservation Need: The findings underscore the critical need for immediate, coordinated, and science-based genetic management to ensure the long-term survival of this unique subspecies.

Key Results

  • Taxonomic Status: Phylogenetic, PCA, and admixture analyses clearly separated the Hainan population from the Cambodian population, supporting its status as a distinct subspecies.
  • Divergence Time: The China and Cambodia populations are estimated to have diverged approximately 27,288 years ago, with some gene flow occurring early in their divergence.
  • Genetic Diversity: Mean heterozygosity in the China population (2.78×10⁻⁴) was significantly lower than in the Cambodia population (3.92×10⁻⁴).
  • Inbreeding: The China population showed higher numbers and lengths of Runs of Homozygosity (ROH) and a significantly higher genomic inbreeding coefficient (FROH) compared to the Cambodia population, indicating more recent inbreeding events.
  • Mutation Load: The Hainan subpopulations showed an excess of heterozygous deleterious missense and LoF mutations compared to Cambodia, but fewer homozygous LoF mutations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's sample size and sequencing depth were limited, a decision made for cost-effectiveness. While they argue their methods are robust for inferring diversity and demography, they suggest that future work should include:

  • Larger Sample Sizes and Deeper Sequencing: To further investigate local adaptation and genetic load.
  • Monitoring Exchanged Individuals: For any signs of outbreeding depression, especially if individuals are exchanged between subpopulations.
  • Field Evidence: The authors caution that interpreting inbreeding and outbreeding depression requires extensive field evidence.

Overall, the study provides a strong foundation for the conservation of Rucervus eldii hainanus, emphasizing the need for careful genetic management to prevent further decline.

Summary updated

Abstract

Eld's deer <i>Rucervus eldii</i> (McClelland, 1842) is an ungulate that lives in tropical lowland forests in several countries of Indochina and Hainan Island of China. Its remaining population is small and scattered, and the species is listed as an Endangered species on the IUCN Red List. The debate over the taxonomic status of the Hainan population has persisted for over a century-as an island-endemic subspecies <i>R. e. hainanus</i>, or an insular population of the subspecies <i>R. e. siamensis</i>, would have significant conservation implications. And, given the Hainan population had experienced both population bottleneck and multiple translocations in the past, conservation genomics would be a powerful tool to evaluate the genetic impacts of these events. In this study, we used conservation genomics assessment to study population differentiation and genetic diversity of <i>R. e. siamensis</i> in Cambodia and three Eld's deer subpopulations on Hainan Island. Based on the unique genetic profile and demographic analysis, this study corroborated previous studies using genetic markers that the Hainan Eld's deer warrants the taxonomic status of a distinct subspecies. The Hainan population exhibits a reduction in genetic diversity and an increase in the level of inbreeding when compared to the population of Cambodia. The signs of purifying selection were found against homozygous loss-of-function mutations to decrease the deleterious burden in the Hainan population. However, there was an accumulation of more deleterious missense mutations. Furthermore, significant differences in genetic diversity and level of inbreeding found among the three Hainan subpopulations indicated population isolation and suboptimal translocation strategies, which calls for urgent, coordinated, and science-based genetic management to ensure the long-term viability of the endemic subspecies <i>hainanus</i>. This study provides guidance for the conservation and management of Eld's deer.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2024wholegenome,
  author = {Chenqing Zheng and Qing Chen and Michelle Wong and Nick Marx and Thananh Khotpathoom and Hesheng Wang and Feng Yang and Xiaodong Rao and Bosco Pui Lok Chan and Yang Liu},
  title = {{Whole‐Genome Analyses Reveal the Distinct Taxonomic Status of the Hainan Population of Endangered <i>Rucervus eldii</i> and Its Conservation Implications}},
  booktitle = {Evolutionary},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1111/eva.70010},
}
Figure