Who Funds Misinformation? A Systematic Analysis of the Ad-related Profit Routines of Fake News Sites

Emmanouil Papadogiannakis, Panagiotis Papadopoulos, Evangelos P. Markatos, Nicolas Kourtellis

TL;DR

This paper systematically analyzes the financial incentives behind fake news websites by auditing their ad revenue streams. It reveals that major ad networks directly partner with a significant portion of these sites, and that fake news operations are often part of broader, diversified business ventures, not isolated entities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the spread of misinformation is a well-documented problem, the economic drivers that sustain fake news operations have remained largely opaque. Despite efforts to curb their influence, unreliable news sites continue to gain traction. This paper aims to shed light on the "who" and "how" of fake news monetization, specifically focusing on the advertising ecosystem that provides the financial fuel for these platforms. Understanding these profit routines is crucial for developing effective countermeasures.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged methodology:

  • Website Crawling and Data Extraction: They developed a custom crawler to collect HTML content, cookies, ads.txt files, screenshots, and network traffic from a large corpus of news websites.
  • Fake and Real News Website Identification: They compiled lists of fake and real news websites by merging and filtering data from several reputable sources (e.g., Media Bias/Fact Check, Columbia Journalism Review).
  • Ad Detection: A novel ad detection methodology was developed, combining external blocking lists (like EasyList) with network traffic monitoring to identify ad URLs and their associated advertisers.
  • Business Relationship Analysis: They analyzed ads.txt and sellers.json files to identify direct and reseller relationships between websites and ad networks, and to understand the entities involved in selling ad space.
  • Website Ownership and Clustering: Using publisher-specific IDs (like Google Analytics and AdSense IDs) embedded in websites, they constructed a "Metagraph" to identify clusters of websites likely operated by the same entity. The Louvain community detection algorithm was used to analyze these clusters.
  • Advertiser Categorization: They used Cyren's classification engine to categorize the types of advertisers appearing on fake and real news sites.

Datasets

  • Fake News Website Lists: Compiled from sources like Media Bias/Fact Check, Columbia Journalism Review, Golbeck et al., and Zhou et al.
  • Real News Website Lists: Curated from Media Bias/Fact Check, focusing on highly credible sources.
  • Combined Dataset: A list of 1,044 unique fake news and 1,368 unique real news websites.
  • Crawled Data: HTML content, cookies, ads.txt files, screenshots, and network traffic from approximately 3,311 websites.
  • Publisher-Specific IDs: Extracted from websites to build the Metagraph, including Google Analytics, AdSense, and other tracking IDs.
  • 1MT crawl dataset: Used to augment the Metagraph with publisher-specific IDs from the top 1 million most popular websites.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fake news is a business, not just propaganda: The study strongly suggests that economic incentives are a primary driver for the existence and proliferation of fake news sites.
  • Major ad networks are complicit: Contrary to the idea that legitimate ad platforms avoid fake news, this research shows direct partnerships between well-known ad networks (like Google, IndexExchange) and a substantial percentage of fake news websites.
  • Fake news operations are diversified: Owners of fake news sites are not solely focused on misinformation; they often operate a portfolio of websites across various categories, including entertainment and business, suggesting a broader business strategy.
  • Click-bait fuels the fire: Advertisers in the "Entertainment" category, often employing captivating or click-bait tactics, are disproportionately represented on fake news sites, directly contributing to their revenue.
  • The "Metagraph" approach is powerful: Using shared publisher-specific IDs to link websites provides a novel way to uncover hidden ownership structures and business relationships.

Key Results

  • Ad Network Partnerships: Over 40% of fake news websites have a direct advertising relationship with major ad networks like Google and IndexExchange.
  • Advertiser Categories: While "Business" is the top category for advertisers on both fake and real news sites, "Entertainment" ads are significantly more prevalent on fake news sites (around 40% of ads).
  • Website Ownership: Analysis of publisher-specific IDs revealed that entities owning fake news sites also operate other types of websites, indicating a diversified business model.
  • Cluster Homogeneity: Real news clusters tend to be more homogeneous, with owners focusing on a narrower range of businesses, while fake news clusters exhibit higher diversity.
  • Ad Detection Accuracy: The authors' ad detection methodology achieved high precision (92%) and recall (87%) on a test set of popular websites.

Limitations and Future Work

  • ads.txt Limitations: The study acknowledges that ads.txt files can be incomplete, syntactically incorrect, or outdated, which may affect the completeness of the business relationship analysis.
  • Ad Detection Nuances: While the ad detection methodology is robust, it may miss fragmented ad URLs or ads that appear only after user interaction (e.g., clicking on an article).
  • External Funding: The paper notes that many fake news sites receive funding from sources other than direct advertising (e.g., online stores, book sales, donations, paid webinars), which were not the primary focus of this study.
  • Domain Classification: Reliance on third-party domain classification services introduces potential for classification errors.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest developing content-agnostic classifiers for fake news detection by leveraging advertising and analytics service information. They also plan to further investigate external funding sources for fake news websites.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fake news is an age-old phenomenon, widely assumed to be associated with political propaganda published to sway public opinion. Yet, with the growth of social media, it has become a lucrative business for Web publishers. Despite many studies performed and countermeasures proposed, unreliable news sites have increased in the last years their share of engagement among the top performing news sources. Stifling fake news impact depends on our efforts in limiting the (economic) incentives of fake news producers. In this paper, we aim at enhancing the transparency around these exact incentives, and explore: Who supports the existence of fake news websites via paid ads, either as an advertiser or an ad seller? Who owns these websites and what other Web business are they into? We are the first to systematize the auditing process of fake news revenue flows. We identify the companies that advertise in fake news websites and the intermediary companies responsible for facilitating those ad revenues. We study more than 2,400 popular news websites and show that well-known ad networks, such as Google and IndexExchange, have a direct advertising relation with more than 40% of fake news websites. Using a graph clustering approach on 114.5K sites, we show that entities who own fake news sites, also operate other types of websites pointing to the fact that owning a fake news website is part of a broader business operation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{papadogiannakis2023who,
  author = {Emmanouil Papadogiannakis and Panagiotis Papadopoulos and Evangelos P. Markatos and Nicolas Kourtellis},
  title = {{Who Funds Misinformation? A Systematic Analysis of the Ad-related Profit Routines of Fake News Sites}},
  booktitle = {The Web Conference},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=oeT1If8ndw},
}
Figure