Abstract
Ever since social activity on the Internet began migrating from the wilds of the open web to the walled gardens erected by so-called platforms, debates have raged about the responsibilities that these platforms ought to bear. And yet, despite intense scrutiny from the news media and grassroots movements of outraged users, platforms continue to operate, from a legal standpoint, on the friendliest terms. Under the current regulatory framework, platforms simultaneously benefit from: (1) broad discretion to organize (and censor) content however they choose; (2) powerful algorithms for curating a practically limitless supply of user-posted microcontent according to whatever ends they wish; and (3) absolution from the sorts of liability born by creators of the underlying content. In this paper, we contest the very validity of the platform-creator distinction, arguing that it is ill-adapted to the modern social media landscape where, in a real sense, platforms are creating derivative media products. We argue that any coherent regulatory framework must adapt to this reality, recognizing the subtle continuum of activities that span the curation-creation spectrum, providing a finer system of categorization and clearer guidance for precisely when platforms assume the responsibilities associated with content creation.
Introduction: The Erosion of the Neutral Intermediary
The legal framework governing the modern internet is largely built upon a foundation laid in the mid-1990s. Specifically, Section 230 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 was designed to protect "pipes"—Internet Service Providers and early bulletin boards that merely facilitated the passage of data. By shielding these intermediaries from liability for the content posted by their users, the law encouraged the growth of the digital commons.
However, this paper argues that the "have your cake and eat it too" reality of modern social media has rendered this distinction obsolete. Today’s platforms are no longer neutral conduits; they are sophisticated editors using advanced machine learning to curate a practically limitless supply of user-generated "microcontent." When a platform decides exactly what a user sees, in what order, and for what purpose, it exerts an "expressive power" that is functionally indistinguishable from editorial creation.
The Curation-Creation Spectrum
To understand this shift, we must move away from binary legal definitions and toward a conceptual model of a curation-creation spectrum. The authors employ several analogies from the arts to illustrate how the act of selection and arrangement becomes an act of creation:
- The DJ and the Sampler: Much like a DJ who creates a new experience by sequencing existing tracks, or the Beastie Boys who recontextualized snippets of sound into entirely new compositions, platforms use algorithmic sequencing to create a unique media product.
- The Collage Artist: Referencing the work of Jasper Johns, the authors suggest that when enough "atomic" elements are assembled into a new whole, the resulting work belongs to the assembler as much as the original creators.
This spectrum ranges from simple aggregators (like the Drudge Report) to journalists who curate tweets into a narrative, and finally to the algorithmic "Explore" pages of modern social media. As a platform moves along this gradient, its role shifts from hosting to fashioning.
The Power of Microcontent and Algorithmic Agency
A critical driver of this evolution is the shift from long-form content to "microcontent." Unlike traditional platforms that shared links to full articles, modern feeds consist of isolated snippets of text, photos, and short videos. Because these fragments are disconnected from their original context, the platform gains immense power to "fashion" a new narrative through their assembly.
This is facilitated by "black-box" algorithmic systems. These systems do not merely determine what can be seen, but actively dictate what will be seen to maximize specific business metrics. This active shaping of the digital zeitgeist represents a form of algorithmic agency. We often consider a human blogger who synthesizes others' work to be a "creator," yet we treat a platform doing the same thing on a massive, automated scale as a mere "intermediary." This double standard is the core of the current regulatory crisis.
Regulatory Realism and Future Directions
The paper concludes that any coherent regulatory framework must move away from simplistic, binary systems of categorization. Instead, we must embrace "regulatory realism" that recognizes the gray-scale nature of the curation-creation spectrum.
Recent legislative proposals, such as amendments seeking to reclassify platforms based on their use of algorithmic promotion, suggest a growing awareness of this issue. However, the authors acknowledge the difficulty in finding a definitive legal formula for when Section 230 protections should lapse.
As emerging technologies—such as automated translation, AI-driven paraphrasing, and synthetic image generation—continue to blur these lines, the technical and policy communities must collaborate. The goal is to define a system of responsibility that balances corporate accountability with economic vibrancy and free speech rights in an increasingly algorithmic world.
Summary updated