What's Psychology Worth? A Field Experiment in the Consumer Credit Market

Marianne Bertrand, Dean Karlin, Sendhil Mullainathan, Eldar Shafir, Jonathan Zinman2005 · DOI

Abstract

Numerous laboratory studies find that minor nuances of presentation and description change behavior in ways that are inconsistent with standard economic models. How much do these context effects matter in natural settings, when consumers make large, real decisions and have the opportunity to learn from experience? We report on a field experiment designed to address this question. A South African lender sent letters offering incumbent clients large, short-term loans at randomly chosen interest rates. The letters also contained independently randomized psychological "features" that were motivated by specific types of frames and cues shown to be powerful in the lab, but which, from a normative perspective, ought to have no impact. Consistent with standard economics, the interest rate significantly affected loan take-up. Inconsistent with standard economics, some of the psychological features also significantly affected take-up. The average effect of a psychological manipulation was equivalent to a one-half percentage point change in the monthly interest rate. Interestingly, the psychological features appear to have greater impact in the context of less advantageous offers and persist across different income and education levels. In short, even in a market setting with large stakes and experienced customers, subtle psychological features appear to be powerful drivers of behavior. The findings pose a challenge for the social sciences: they suggest that psychological nuance matters but may be inherently difficult to predict given the impact of context. Successful incorporation of psychological features into field studies is likely to prove a vital, but nontrivial, addition to the formation of more general theories on when, why, and how frames and cues influence important decisions.

Introduction

Standard neoclassical economics assumes that humans are rational actors who make decisions based on stable preferences and the inherent value of a choice, such as the interest rate of a loan. Laboratory psychology, however, has long demonstrated that "frames" and "cues"—the specific way information is presented—can radically alter behavior.

The central challenge addressed in this research is external validity. Skeptics often argue that laboratory findings may not apply to the "real world" because lab subjects are often inexperienced, the stakes are low, and the environments are artificial. This paper investigates whether these psychological nuances still matter when experienced customers are making large, high-stakes financial decisions and attempts to quantify the economic "price" of these effects.

Methods

The researchers partnered with a large South African lender to execute a natural field experiment, sending direct mail solicitations to 53,194 former clients. The experimental design utilized two independent layers of randomization:

  1. Economic Variation: Interest rates were randomized (ranging from 3.25% to 11.75% per month) to establish a baseline for price sensitivity.
  2. Psychological Variation: Letters contained independently randomized "features" motivated by laboratory research, including:
  3. Simplicity: Showing one example loan versus a complex table of multiple options.
  4. Framing: Comparing the rate to a competitor’s as either a "gain" (save money) or a "loss" (don't lose money).
  5. Demographics: Including a small photo of a person (varying race and gender) in the corner of the letter.
  6. Giveaways: Mentioning a promotional lottery for a cellphone.
  7. Suggestion Effects: Using specific phrases suggesting what the loan could be used for (e.g., "pay for school fees").

By measuring the impact of both price and psychology simultaneously, the authors calculated the interest rate equivalent of a nudge—essentially determining how much the interest rate would need to be reduced to achieve the same increase in demand as a specific psychological tweak.

Data and Context

The study utilizes a proprietary dataset from a major South African micro-lender. The sample included 53,194 individuals who had borrowed from the lender in the past 24 months. This population represents the "working poor," for whom these are high-stakes decisions; the median loan size was approximately one-third of the borrower's monthly gross income. Additionally, the authors analyzed credit bureau data to determine if these nudges caused "crowd-out" (borrowing from one lender instead of another) or led to higher default rates.

Key Insights: The Price of a Nudge

  • Simplicity is Profitable: Showing a single example loan instead of a complex table of options increased demand by 9%. This was equivalent to dropping the monthly interest rate by a staggering 2.3 percentage points.
  • The "Female Photo" Effect: For male customers, replacing a photo of a man with a photo of a woman on the letter increased loan take-up as much as a 4.5 percentage point interest rate cut.
  • Psychology Dulls Price Sensitivity: Psychological nudges were more effective when the interest rate was higher, suggesting that effective marketing can mitigate the negative impact of less attractive pricing.
  • No "Stupidity Tax": Surprisingly, the effects of these psychological features did not vary significantly across different income or education levels. Even sophisticated or experienced borrowers were susceptible to these cues.
  • Contextual Specificity: Not every nudge worked. For example, race-matching (matching the photo race to the client race) had no significant effect. This highlights that while psychology matters, its impact is highly sensitive to specific cultural and situational contexts.

Key Results

  • Take-up: Both interest rates and psychological features significantly affected loan take-up.
  • Economic Magnitude: The average effect of a successful psychological manipulation was equivalent to a 0.5 percentage point change in the monthly interest rate.
  • Repayment and Selection: Crucially, the borrowers attracted by psychological nudges were not higher risks. There was no evidence of adverse selection; these borrowers repaid their loans at the same rates as those motivated by price.
  • Market Equilibrium: The findings suggest firms can raise demand without lowering prices or suffering from higher default rates by competing on psychological factors.

Limitations and Future Work

While psychology is powerful, the authors note it is "inherently difficult to predict." Why some nudges worked and others did not remains a challenge for future theory. Additionally, the results are specific to the South African credit market; cultural salience varies globally, and similar experiments in different cultures might yield different "prices" for the same nudges.

Finally, the study identifies that these cues work, but it cannot fully isolate the underlying mechanisms (e.g., whether a female photo signals a "friendlier" lender or acts as a simple affective trigger). The authors suggest that public policy and socially oriented programs could benefit from these insights to increase participation without relying solely on expensive financial incentives.

Summary updated

Abstract

Numerous laboratory studies find that minor nuances of presentation and description change behavior in ways that are inconsistent with standard economic models.How much do these context effect matter in natural settings, when consumers make large, real decisions and have the opportunity to learn from experience?We report on a field experiment designed to address this question.A South African lender sent letters offering incumbent clients large, short-term loans at randomly chosen interest rates.The letters also contained independently randomized psychological "features" that were motivated by specific types of frames and cues shown to be powerful in the lab, but which, from a normative perspective, ought to have no impact.Consistent with standard economics, the interest rate significantly affected loan take-up.Inconsistent with standard economics, some of the psychological features also significantly affected take-up.The average effect of a psychological manipulation was equivalent to a one half percentage point change in the monthly interest rate.Interestingly, the psychological features appear to have greater impact in the context of less advantageous offers and persist across different income and education levels.In short, even in a market setting with large stakes and experienced customers, subtle psychological features appear to be powerful drivers of behavior.The findings pose a challenge for the social sciences: they suggest that psychological nuance matters but may be inherently difficult to predict given the impact of context.Successful incorporation of psychological features into field studies is likely to prove a vital, but nontrivial, addition to the formation of more general theories on when, why, and how frames and cues influence important decisions.
BibTeX
@misc{bertrand2005what,
  author = {Marianne Bertrand and Dean Karlin and Sendhil Mullainathan and Eldar Shafir and Jonathan Zinman},
  title = {{What's Psychology Worth? A Field Experiment in the Consumer Credit Market}},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.3386/w11892},
}
Figure