Abstract: Hadron decay chains constitute one of the main sources of information on the QCD spectrum. We discuss the differences between several partial wave analysis formalisms used in the literature to build the amplitudes. We match the helicity amplitudes to the covariant tensor basis. Hereby, we pay attention to the analytical properties of the amplitudes and separate singularities of kinematical and dynamical nature. We study the analytical properties of the spin-orbit (LS) formalism, and some of the covariant tensor approaches. In particular, we explicitly build the amplitudes for the $B \to \psi \pi K$ and $B \to \bar{D} \pi \pi$ decays, and show that the energy dependence of the covariant approach is model dependent. We also show that the usual recursive construction of covariant tensors explicitly violates crossing symmetry, which would lead to different resonance parameters extracted from scattering and decay processes.
Introduction
In the search for new physics, experiments like LHCb and Belle II generate vast amounts of data on hadron decays. Identifying "resonances"—short-lived intermediate states—requires Partial Wave Analysis (PWA), which builds mathematical amplitudes to describe decay probabilities. However, several competing formalisms exist, including Helicity, LS (Spin-Orbit), and Covariant Projection Methods (CPM). This paper by the Joint Physics Analysis Center (JPAC) collaboration investigates whether these different mathematical languages lead to inconsistent physical conclusions, particularly regarding exotic "XYZ" states.
Methodology and Formalisms
The authors rigorously compare these formalisms by applying them to three-body decays such as $B \to \psi \pi K$ and $B \to \bar{D} \pi \pi$. A central part of their method involves matching helicity amplitudes to a covariant tensor basis. This allows for the isolation of kinematical singularities (artifacts of coordinate choice) from dynamical ones (the actual physics of the resonance).
By defining the scattering angle $\theta_s$ and other kinematic variables carefully, the researchers can test how different formalisms handle the transition between reference frames and energy scales.
Crossing Symmetry and Analyticity
A critical requirement for any physical amplitude is crossing symmetry: the mathematical description of a decay process (e.g., $A \to B+C+D$) must be consistent with the related scattering process (e.g., $A+B \to C+D$).
The study reveals that the Covariant Projection Method (CPM), often favored for its apparent relativistic nature, explicitly violates crossing symmetry. Because CPM builds amplitudes recursively, it introduces unphysical energy dependencies that would result in different resonance parameters (mass and width) being extracted from decay data versus scattering data.
Key Insights
- The "Relativistic" Myth: The LS formalism is often incorrectly labeled as non-relativistic. The authors show it is a valid relativistic framework if energy dependence is parameterized correctly.
- Model Dependence: Many "relativistic corrections" in PWA are arbitrary choices within a formalism rather than fundamental requirements of Lorentz invariance.
- Analyticity Constraints: Amplitudes must be analytic (smooth in the complex plane). The researchers found that LS and CPM methods often fail this test unless specifically modified to respect threshold behaviors.
Results and Conclusion
The comparison of predicted lineshapes for $K^*$ resonances shows that JPAC, CPM, and LS formalisms produce visibly different results even with identical input physics. Specifically, the CPM approach introduces a $1/s$ factor that shifts the weight of data points across the energy spectrum.
Ultimately, this work serves as a guide for the community, emphasizing that formalisms must respect analyticity and crossing symmetry. Without these safeguards, the extraction of resonance parameters from experimental data remains model-dependent and potentially inconsistent across different physical processes. Future work will extend these checks to broader resonances and more complex baryon decays.
Summary updated