What have we missed when studying the impact of aerosols on surface ozone via changing photolysis rates?

Jinhui Gao, Ying Li, Bin Zhu, Bo Hu, Lili Wang, Fangwen Bao

TL;DR

This study investigates how aerosols impact surface ozone in Central East China by altering photolysis rates. It reveals that while aerosols weaken ozone production through reduced photochemistry, this effect is partially offset by increased vertical mixing of ozone from higher altitudes. The findings highlight the importance of considering these complex physical processes and suggest that controlling local ozone precursors is crucial for mitigating rising surface ozone levels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Previous research has largely focused on the direct impact of aerosols on surface ozone by reducing photolysis rates, which in turn weakens ozone photochemistry and lowers ozone production. However, quantitative studies have observed that the reduction in ozone net chemical production is often much larger than the observed reduction in surface ozone. This discrepancy suggests that other physical processes, beyond just photochemistry, are at play and haven't been fully accounted for. The paper aims to bridge this gap by comprehensively investigating the mechanisms through which aerosols influence surface ozone, particularly in the context of China's complex air pollution landscape where both aerosols and ozone are significant issues.

Methods

The researchers employed the Weather Research and Forecasting with Chemistry (WRF-Chem) model, a fully coupled online 3-D Eulerian meteorological and chemical transport model. To isolate the impact of aerosols on photolysis rates, they conducted two parallel simulations:

  1. Exp1 (Control): Photolysis rate calculation without considering aerosol optical properties.
  2. Exp2 (Sensitivity): Photolysis rate calculation including aerosol optical properties.

By comparing the outputs of these two experiments, they could quantify the direct impact of aerosols on photolysis rates and subsequent ozone chemistry and physical processes.

Additionally, they integrated an ozone source apportionment method into WRF-Chem. This technique, which accounts for both NOx-limited and VOC-limited conditions, helps identify the contributions of different geographic source regions to ozone concentrations within the model domain. This allowed them to assess the spatial origins of ozone affected by aerosols.

Datasets

  • Meteorological and Chemical Conditions: Initial and boundary conditions were provided by the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NECP) final (FNL) operational global analysis data and outputs from the Community Atmosphere Model with Chemistry (CAM-chem).
  • Emissions Data: Anthropogenic emissions were sourced from the Multi-resolution Emission Inventory for China (MEIC), covering industry, power plants, transportation, and residential combustion. Biogenic emissions were generated using the Model of Emissions of Gas and Aerosols from Nature (MEGAN).
  • Observational Data for Model Validation:
    • Hourly meteorological data (temperature, wind speed and direction) from 110 national surface observation stations.
  • Hourly air pollutant concentrations (ozone, NO2, PM2.5) from 110 stations.
  • Observed time series of photolysis rates (J(NO2) and J(OD)) from a comprehensive observation station in Xianghe, Hebei province.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ozone Reduction is More Than Just Chemistry: The study confirms that aerosols reduce surface ozone by decreasing photolysis rates, which weakens ozone production. However, it highlights that this chemical effect is counteracted by physical processes.
  • Vertical Mixing Plays a Crucial Role: A significant finding is that aerosols create a larger vertical ozone gradient. This leads to increased entrainment of ozone-rich air from higher altitudes into the lower planetary boundary layer (PBL), partially offsetting the ozone reduction caused by weakened photochemistry.
  • Weakened Ozone Sink: The reduction in surface ozone also leads to a weakened dry deposition sink for ozone, further slowing down the rate of surface ozone decrease.
  • Impact Extends Throughout the PBL: The influence of aerosols on ozone is not confined to the surface but affects the entire PBL during the daytime.
  • Local Sources Dominate: The ozone source apportionment analysis reveals that a substantial portion (41.4%-66.3%) of the surface ozone reduction attributed to aerosols originates from local and adjacent regions. This suggests that long-range transport plays a less significant role in this specific impact.

Key Results

  • Photolysis Rate Reduction: Aerosols significantly reduce J(NO2) and J(OD), particularly during polluted days, both at the surface and throughout the PBL.
  • Surface Ozone Reduction: During high PM2.5 episodes, surface ozone reduction in representative cities (BJ, TJ, SJZ, ZZ) ranged from 4.2 to 10.6 ppb, representing 7.9% to 19.4% of the mean ozone concentrations.
  • Process Contributions: At 14:00 LT, the reduction in CHEM (chemical production/loss) was -44.3 ppb, while VMIX (vertical mixing) increased by 12.0 ppb and DRY (dry deposition) increased by 19.6 ppb. These increases in VMIX and DRY partially offset the CHEM reduction.
  • Source Apportionment: Local and adjacent source regions contributed significantly to the ozone reduction. For example, in Beijing (BJ), local contributions accounted for -3.8 ppb (36.5%) of the total ozone reduction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Specificity: The study was conducted for a specific month (October 2018) and region (Central East China). While the WRF-Chem model is robust, its performance can vary, and results might differ in other regions or seasons.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest that controlling ozone precursors from local and adjacent regions is a more effective strategy for suppressing the increase in surface ozone, especially given the current trend of decreasing aerosols and increasing ozone in China. This implies a need for targeted emission control policies. They also note that while the study focused on the direct impact of aerosols via photolysis rates, indirect impacts (e.g., on PBL development) were not the primary focus but are acknowledged as important factors in other research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies have emphasized that the decrease in photolysis rate at the surface induced by the light extinction of aerosols could weaken ozone photochemistry and then reduce surface ozone. However, quantitative studies have shown that weakened photochemistry leads to a much greater reduction in the net chemical production of ozone, which does not match the reduction in surface ozone. This suggests that in addition to photochemistry, some other physical processes related to the variation of ozone should also be considered. In this study, the Weather Research and Forecasting with Chemistry (WRF-Chem) model coupled with the ozone source apportionment method was applied to determine the mechanism of ozone reduction induced by aerosols over central East China (CEC). Our results showed that weakened ozone photochemistry led to a significant reduction in ozone net chemical production, which occurred not only at the surface but also within the lowest several hundred meters in the planetary boundary layer (PBL). Meanwhile, a larger ozone gradient was formed in the vertical direction, which led to the high concentrations of ozone aloft being entrained by turbulence from the top of the PBL to the surface and partly counteracting the reduction in surface ozone. In addition, contribution from dry deposition was weakened due to the decrease in surface ozone concentration. The reduction in the ozone's sink also slowed down the rate of the decrease in surface ozone. Ozone in the upper layer of the PBL was also reduced, which was induced by much ozone aloft being entrained downward. Therefore, by affecting the photolysis rate, the impact of aerosols was a reduction in ozone not only at the surface but also throughout the entire PBL during the daytime over CEC in this study. The ozone source apportionment results showed that 41.4 %–66.3 % of the reduction in surface ozone came from local and adjacent source regions, which suggested that the impact of aerosols on ozone from local and adjacent regions was more significant than that from long-distance regions. The results also suggested that while controlling the concentration of aerosols, simultaneously controlling ozone precursors from local and adjacent source regions is an effective way to suppress the increase in surface ozone over CEC at present.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2020what,
  author = {Jinhui Gao and Ying Li and Bin Zhu and Bo Hu and Lili Wang and Fangwen Bao},
  title = {{What have we missed when studying the impact of aerosols on surface ozone via changing photolysis rates?}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-20-10831-2020},
}
Figure