Abstract: The grey literature highlights the potential of remote SRHS to improve access and equity while also identifying risks in implementation and outcomes. There is an ongoing requirement for detailed, evidence-informed guidance that incorporates service user perspectives.
Introduction: The Shift to Remote SRHS
The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a rapid transition to remote consultations across healthcare, but sexual and reproductive health services (SRHS) faced unique challenges. These services—encompassing STI testing, contraception, and abortion care—often involve high levels of stigma, complex safeguarding requirements (such as identifying domestic violence), and physical procedures like long-acting reversible contraception (LARC) that cannot be replicated digitally. While generic telehealth guidance exists, it often fails to address the specific nuances of SRHS, such as the "no-test" medical abortion pathway or sensitive disclosures regarding sexual assault.
Methodology and Data Sources
To understand the landscape of existing guidance, researchers conducted a narrative synthesis of "grey literature" published between 2018 and 2024. This approach targeted unpublished reports, policy briefs, clinical standards, and position statements from professional bodies like the British HIV Association (BHIVA), the British Association for Sexual Health and HIV (BASHH), and the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).
The search strategy utilized iterative Google searches and the Healthcare Management Information Consortium (HMIC) database to capture both immediate pandemic responses and the subsequent transition to a "new normal."
Key Insights: Evidence Gaps and Safeguarding
The review identified several critical themes and gaps in the current literature:
- The Evidence Vacuum: Much of the current guidance is modest in scope and draws on a sparse evidence base. Many recommendations rely on stakeholder surveys or expert opinion rather than rigorous clinical evaluations.
- The Safeguarding Paradox: Remote consultations offer a discreet lifeline for some but remove the non-verbal cues clinicians use to detect coercion. While "safe words" and level 3 safeguarding training are recommended, implementation remains inconsistent.
- Digital Equity: While documents acknowledge that digital exclusion (lack of hardware, data, or private space) disproportionately affects underserved populations, there is a lack of clear "triggers" for when a provider should mandate a shift from remote to in-person care.
- Early Medical Abortion (EMA): This area features the most robust guidance. The "no-test" model (using ultrasound only when clinically necessary) is widely supported as safe, though in-person care is still prioritized for minors to ensure proper safeguarding.
Synthesized Recommendations for Practice
The review culminated in a set of generic recommendations designed to guide the delivery of remote healthcare. These emphasize the need for co-design with staff and patients, investment in secure infrastructure, and maintaining a choice of consultation modalities.
Notably, the review found a significant lack of data regarding the cost-effectiveness of these remote models, highlighting a major area for future financial and operational research.
Conclusion and Future Directions
Current guidance for remote SRHS is often "stuck" in the pandemic era, focusing on emergency adaptation rather than long-term optimization. Future research must prioritize:
- Service User Perspectives: Incorporating how patients actually experience these digital interfaces.
- Intersectionality: Understanding how race, age, and socioeconomic status intersect to create unique barriers to remote care.
- Hybrid Optimization: Determining the optimal configuration of remote and in-person services to maximize both quality and access.
By moving beyond "remote vs. in-person" binaries, services can better meet the diverse needs of the populations they serve.
Summary updated