Remote consultations in sexual and reproductive health services: a systematic review of evidence on effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, experiences, access and equity

Charlotte Spurway, Iestyn Williams, Oluseyi Ayinde, Christian Böhm, Fiona Burns, Jo Gibbs, Jo Josh, Helen Munro, Melvina Woode Owusu, Danielle Solomon, Jonathan Ross, Louise JacksonSexually 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Overall, the review shows that a range of studies have investigated remote consultations in SRHS, but there remains limited evidence on the impact on health inequalities and sexual health outcomes. The surge in post-2020 research, spurred by COVID-19, indicates the necessity for further high-quality research into equitable SRHS delivery in the post-COVID era, particularly in addressing technological and communication barriers. There is a need to further optimise access and the delivery of remote consultations in SRHS, considering the needs of service users, and minimising inequality (observed differences) and inequity (unfair differences). CRD42023397288.

Introduction

Sexual and reproductive health services (SRHS)—including STI screening, contraception, and HIV care—are vital components of public health. However, substantial funding reductions and the exigencies of the COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid, often unplanned transition from traditional in-person visits to remote modalities such as phone, video, and online platforms.

The core challenge is that this transition occurred faster than the research could keep up. While remote care might seem efficient, it remains unclear if it maintains the same level of clinical effectiveness or if it inadvertently creates a "digital divide." For vulnerable groups—those with low digital literacy, limited access to private spaces, or from lower socioeconomic backgrounds—remote consultations might create new barriers to care. This paper systematically reviews the existing literature to assess the impact of remote SRHS on effectiveness, cost, user experience, and equity.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, searching 18 electronic databases (including MEDLINE, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library) for studies published in OECD countries between January 2011 and August 2023.

The selection process followed the PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcomes) framework. To ensure a rigorous evaluation of the diverse study types identified (quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods), the authors used the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) to assess study quality. The selection process is illustrated in the PRISMA flow diagram below:

PRISMA flow diagram showing the study selection process.

Results and Synthesis

The review identified and analyzed 48 peer-reviewed studies that met the inclusion criteria from an initial pool of 11,261 records. These studies were conducted across several OECD countries, primarily the USA (n=27), the UK (n=10), and Australia (n=6). The table below summarizes the characteristics and scope of several included studies.

Summary characteristics of studies on remote consultations in SRHS.

Key Insights

  • The Convenience-Quality Trade-off: Remote consultations are highly valued for their convenience and anonymity. However, this often comes at the cost of reduced provider-patient rapport and the inability to perform physical examinations or procedures (like LARC placement).
  • The Privacy Paradox: While remote care can enhance anonymity for some, it introduces new privacy risks for those who lack a safe, private space at home to conduct a sensitive consultation.
  • Digital Exclusion: Inequities in SRHS access are frequently tied to "digital exclusion"—lack of hardware, reliable internet, or digital literacy. These barriers disproportionately affect groups already at higher risk for poor sexual health outcomes.

Key Outcomes

  • Acceptability: User satisfaction is generally high; one study reported a 97.1% satisfaction rate for receiving HIV results via telephone.
  • Clinical Effectiveness: Most studies investigating clinical outcomes (such as CD4 counts for HIV patients) found no significant difference between remote and in-person care in the short term.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The evidence is thin and contradictory. One UK-based HIV clinic study reported a decrease in annual costs per patient-year, while a similar study in Spain reported an increase.
  • Quantifying Inequity: Quantitative data highlighted specific disparities; for instance, Black/African American ethnicity and older age were negatively associated with the successful completion of video telehealth appointments.

Limitations and Future Work

The current body of research suffers from several limitations, including a lack of long-term data on sexual health outcomes and sustained cost-effectiveness. Many included studies were of medium to low quality and lacked direct comparators (e.g., randomized controlled trials).

Future Directions: The review calls for high-quality, comparative, and longitudinal research that prioritizes equity. There is an urgent need to update national SRHS guidelines to provide evidence-based frameworks for when and how remote consultations should be utilized to ensure they supplement, rather than undermine, equitable access to care.

Summary updated

Abstract

Overall, the review shows that a range of studies have investigated remote consultations in SRHS, but there remains limited evidence on the impact on health inequalities and sexual health outcomes. The surge in post-2020 research, spurred by COVID-19, indicates the necessity for further high-quality research into equitable SRHS delivery in the post-COVID era, particularly in addressing technological and communication barriers. There is a need to further optimise access and the delivery of remote consultations in SRHS, considering the needs of service users, and minimising inequality (observed differences) and inequity (unfair differences).CRD42023397288.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{spurway2025remote,
  author = {Charlotte Spurway and Iestyn Williams and Oluseyi Ayinde and Christian Böhm and Fiona Burns and Jo Gibbs and Jo Josh and Helen Munro and Melvina Woode Owusu and Danielle Solomon and Jonathan Ross and Louise Jackson},
  title = {{Remote consultations in sexual and reproductive health services: a systematic review of evidence on effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, experiences, access and equity}},
  booktitle = {Sexually},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1136/sextrans-2024-056458},
}
Figure