What drives willingness to travel in the context of COVID-19?—A measurement of eco-environmental values

Yuling Zhang, Mengqing Wang, Kangmin WuFrontiers in Environmental Science 2023 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Environmental Science, explores the psychological and geographical drivers of travel intentions during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic in China. By analyzing how residents' "eco-environmental values" and sociodemographic factors influenced their desire for suburban, domestic, and international trips, the researchers reveal a significant disconnect between the actual spread of the virus and the public's willingness to move.

TL;DR

While the actual spread of COVID-19 followed "distance decay" patterns (fewer cases further from the epicenter), travel willingness did not. Instead, travel intentions were primarily driven by educational background, personal cognition of the virus, and regional geography rather than local infection rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The tourism industry was one of the hardest-hit sectors during the pandemic, yet most research has focused on the macro-economic impact or specific destination recovery. There is a gap in understanding the "micro" level: what actually drives an individual's desire to travel when faced with a global health crisis?

Specifically, the authors investigate whether Distance Decay Theory—the geographical principle that interaction between two locales declines as the distance between them increases—holds true for travel intentions during a pandemic. They also look at how "eco-environmental values" (how individuals perceive the relationship between humans, nature, and the virus) act as a predictor for travel behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged quantitative approach:

  • Survey Instrument: An online questionnaire (using "Wenjuanxing") collected data on sociodemographics, travel willingness (suburban, domestic, overseas), and a custom "EV-COVID" scale.
  • EV-COVID Scale: This measured three dimensions: Cognition of COVID-19, Cognition of the relationship between humans and nature, and Anthropocentrism.
  • Spatial Analysis: Using ArcGIS software, the team mapped the proportion of travel willingness across China’s provinces and compared it against the distribution of confirmed cases.
  • Statistical Modeling: Binary logistic regression was used to identify which factors (age, gender, income, education, virus cognition, and geography) significantly predicted the "Yes/No" choice to travel at different distance tiers.

Datasets

  • Primary Survey Data: 2,724 valid samples from residents across mainland China, collected between January 23 and February 24, 2020.
  • Epidemiological Data: Official COVID-19 confirmed case counts from the National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China for the same period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Distance Decay Paradox: The virus itself followed distance decay (cases radiated out from Hubei/Wuhan). However, travel willingness was spatially clustered rather than decaying from the epicenter. High willingness was concentrated in the south and east, regardless of proximity to Hubei.
  • The "Forbidden Fruit" Effect: Interestingly, the study notes that strict home quarantines may have actually increased the desire to travel among some residents due to the psychological appeal of what is currently unobtainable.
  • Cognition > Reality: A person's cognition of the virus (how dangerous they perceived it to be) was a much stronger predictor of travel willingness than the actual number of confirmed cases in their province.
  • Education as a Risk Regulator: Higher education levels consistently correlated with lower travel willingness. The authors suggest this is due to a higher sense of social responsibility and a better understanding of transmission risks among highly educated groups.

Key Results

  • Suburban Preference: Suburban recreation was the most resilient category, with nearly 73% of respondents expressing willingness, compared to only 0–25% for overseas travel.
  • Gender and Age: Men were 1.181 times more likely to choose suburban trips than women. Older residents generally showed lower willingness for any travel compared to younger cohorts.
  • Income and International Travel: Monthly income was a significant predictor only for overseas travel. High-income individuals were more likely to choose international trips, viewing them as a way to "escape" the domestic pandemic situation.
  • Regional Drivers: Residents in eastern and southern coastal regions were approximately 2 times more likely to want to travel overseas than those in Hubei, likely due to better accessibility and higher economic status.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Bias: The "snowball" sampling method resulted in a participant pool dominated by young people and students, which may not fully represent the elderly or rural populations.
  • Intent vs. Action: The study measures willingness, not actual behavior. Future research could compare these early intentions with actual travel data once restrictions were lifted.
  • Temporal Snapshot: The data reflects the "shock" phase of the pandemic. The authors suggest that "pandemic normalization" (living with the virus long-term) likely shifted these values and drivers, warranting longitudinal studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The outbreak of COVID-19 has had tremendous impacts on human health and the world economy. Studies have focused on the impact of COVID-19 on potential tourists and tourism destinations from the perspectives of individuals, industries and organizations, and they have provided some measures for tourism recovery. However, under the situation of individual restriction, research has not systematically explained residents’ desire for trips of different distances and factors or the similarities and differences in the factors affecting tourism willingness for trips of different distances. In this context, a measurement of eco-environmental values is used to investigate these issues to help the tourism economy recover. Using online questionnaires covering all provinces in mainland China, this paper investigates residents’ travel willingness to make trips of different distances, and it utilizes binary logistic regression analysis to examine the factors that help predict tourists’ travel intentions. In addition, the patterns of willingness to travel different distances are displayed in maps generated by ArcGIS software. The results suggest that the objective COVID-19 confirmed case distribution follows distance decay theory; however, the distribution patterns of travel willingness are not in accordance with distance decay. The factors that have a significant impact on predicting travel willingness regarding the three kinds of trip distances are educational background, cognition of COVID-19, and geographical division factors. Income and the severity of the pandemic situation play different roles in predicting travel willingness in this study. Overall, the findings of this study extend the application of distance decay theory, which contributes to tourism studies in the COVID-19 context. The findings are also beneficial for tourism recovery and crisis management against the backdrop of pandemic normalization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023what,
  author = {Yuling Zhang and Mengqing Wang and Kangmin Wu},
  title = {{What drives willingness to travel in the context of COVID-19?—A measurement of eco-environmental values}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Environmental Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenvs.2023.1106969},
}
Figure