What Color Scheme is More Effective in Assisting Readers to Locate Information in a Color-Coded Article?

Ho Yin Ng, Zeyu He, Ting-Hao Kenneth Huang

Abstract

As Large Language Models (LLMs) automate text categorization, the primary challenge for readers has shifted from coding documents to effectively visualizing them. This study evaluates 10 color schemes for text annotation, finding that non-analogous (mixed-temperature) and yellow-inclusive schemes significantly enhance information-seeking speed and accuracy, whereas red-heavy schemes tend to hinder performance.

Introduction

Color coding is essential for academic and professional reading, allowing for the rapid clustering of information types such as "Methods" versus "Findings." While LLMs like GPT-4 can now annotate vast amounts of text instantaneously, a standardized "best practice" for color selection in dense textual environments remains elusive. Most existing research focuses on maps or data visualizations rather than paragraphs of text. This paper addresses how hue and color temperature (warm vs. cool) influence a reader's ability to locate specific information within highlighted text.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a controlled study with 32 participants tasked with locating specific labels (e.g., "Method") within scholarly abstracts.

Experimental Design

The study utilized 10 distinct color schemes derived from the Material UI system, using Red, Yellow, Green, and Blue as base colors. These schemes were categorized into four groups based on their chromatic relationships:

  • Monochromatic: Shades of a single color.
  • Dichromatic: Combinations of two base colors.
  • Analogous: Hues that are visually similar (e.g., Green-Blue).
  • Non-analogous: Contrasting hues (e.g., Yellow-Blue).
Overview of the 10 color schemes categorized by chromaticity and temperature.

To ensure legibility, all schemes were standardized to a contrast ratio of approximately 5.55:1 against black text. Participants were given an 8-second time limit per query to simulate rapid information seeking.

Dataset

The study employed 706 abstracts from the arXiv HCI field, labeled using the CODA-19 framework (Background, Purpose, Method, Finding, Other). A final selection of 120 abstracts was used for the main task, ensuring each contained the four primary classes.

Key Insights

The Importance of Contrast

Non-analogous schemes outperformed analogous ones. When colors are too similar, visual boundaries blur, increasing cognitive load. Conversely, disparate hues (mixing warm and cool colors) help readers distinguish sections more efficiently.

The "Yellow Priority" vs. "Red Distraction"

Yellow-inclusive schemes emerged as the most effective, yielding the fastest response times and highest participant preference. This suggests a "yellow priority" effect where the color is perceived as prominent yet easy on the eyes. In contrast, red-inclusive schemes resulted in the slowest response times. Participants found red "distracting," likely due to its cultural association with errors or high-alert signals, which may interfere with neutral information seeking.

Results

Quantitative analysis confirmed these qualitative observations. Non-analogous schemes achieved a significantly higher accuracy of 98% compared to 95.7% for analogous schemes ($p=0.001$).

Accuracy vs. Response Time for the evaluated color schemes, highlighting the efficiency of yellow-inclusive and mixed-temperature schemes.

As shown in the performance scatter plot, yellow-inclusive schemes were the fastest overall (mean 4.120s), while red-inclusive schemes were the slowest (mean 4.350s). Participant preference peaked with the Yellow-Green scheme (4.58/5) and was lowest for pure Red (2.42/5).

Discussion and Limitations

While high-contrast colors facilitate rapid information location, their impact on deep reading comprehension remains to be studied. Furthermore, the findings are currently limited to scholarly abstracts and may vary across different document types like legal or creative texts. Future work should also address accessibility for visually impaired readers and explore more complex color appearance models to account for individual perceptual differences.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{ng2024what,
  author = {Ho Yin Ng and Zeyu He and Ting-Hao Kenneth Huang},
  title = {{What Color Scheme is More Effective in Assisting Readers to Locate Information in a Color-Coded Article?}},
  booktitle = {IEEE vis},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/vis55277.2024.00066},
}
Figure