What Can Interactive Visualization Do for Participatory Budgeting in Chicago?

Alex Kale, Danni Liu, Maria Gabriela Ayala, Harper Schwab, Andrew McNutt

Abstract

Participatory budgeting (PB) is a democratic approach to allocating municipal spending that has been adopted in many places in recent years, including in Chicago. Current PB voting resembles a ballot where residents are asked which municipal projects, such as school improvements and road repairs, to fund with a limited budget. In this work, we ask how interactive visualization can benefit PB by conducting a design probe-based interview study (N=13) with policy workers and academics with expertise in PB, urban planning, and civic HCI. Our probe explores how graphical elicitation of voter preferences and a dashboard of voting statistics can be incorporated into a realistic PB tool. Through qualitative analysis, we find that visualization creates opportunities for city government to set expectations about budget constraints while also granting their constituents greater freedom to articulate a wider range of preferences. However, using visualization to provide transparency about PB requires efforts to mitigate potential access barriers and mistrust. We call for more visualization professionals to help build civic capacity by working in and studying political systems.

Introduction

Participatory Budgeting (PB) allows residents to directly decide how to spend a portion of a public budget. While a powerful democratic tool, current implementations often rely on static, paper-like surveys where residents pick projects until a budget cap is reached. This approach faces two primary hurdles: the cognitive difficulty of articulating nuanced priorities under constraints, and a "black box" transparency gap between voting and final spending decisions.

The participatory budgeting process, from identifying community issues to using digital tools for funding decisions.

This research explores whether interactive visualization can transform PB from simple vote-counting into an educational dialogue that empowers both residents and government officials.

Methods and Design Probe

We conducted a design probe-based interview study with 13 experts in policy, urban planning, and civic HCI. The probe centered on a web-based PB tool featuring:

  • Three-Stage Voting: Users sort projects, allocate funds via an interactive bar chart (initially without cost data), and then adjust allocations once real costs are revealed.
  • Graphical Elicitation: Instead of binary checkboxes, users manipulate bars on a chart to "draw" their desired budget distribution.
  • Results Dashboard: A post-vote interface using heatmaps and strip plots to compare voter demographics and distribution of preferences.
Graphical elicitation allows residents to directly manipulate budget bars to express funding preferences.

The study utilized simulated data based on 2020 Chicago Census data and historical PB ballots to ensure a realistic experience for participants. This allowed the researchers to observe how experts viewed the role of visualization in governance without requiring a massive live deployment.

Key Insights and Results

Visualization as Perspective Taking

Interactive tools make budget trade-offs visceral. Experts observed that when users see one project's funding drop as they increase another, they begin to think like policymakers, confronting the reality of limited resources. Interaction logs showed that participants significantly revised their preferences once cost information was revealed (the "sticker shock" moment), proving that this "predict-and-reveal" pattern is a powerful educational tool.

Expressive Power of Partial Funding

Traditional ballots are binary. Graphical elicitation enables "partial allocations," signaling to the city that a resident values a project (e.g., a park) even if they don't support the full proposed amount. This provides much richer data on public priorities than a simple "yes/no" vote.

The Transparency Paradox

While dashboards offer transparency, they can be a double-edged sword. Experts warned that showing low turnout or demographic imbalances might decrease trust or encourage strategic "herding" behavior. They suggested that "narrative data stories" with clear takeaways might be more effective for the general public than raw data exploration.

Discussion and Future Work

Visualization is most valuable when it supports deliberation and accountability. However, designers must be wary of UI bias; researchers found that "shortcut" buttons (like "fill up") can heavily influence decisions, highlighting the ethical responsibility of designers in democratic interfaces.

Future work must address the "resident gap" by testing these tools directly with diverse community members. Accessibility remains a critical challenge, as drag-and-drop interactions are not screen-reader friendly. We advocate for "Hybrid PB" models that combine digital tools with in-person outreach to avoid marginalizing those with lower digital literacy. Finally, we call for the visualization community to establish ethical standards for civic interfaces to prevent their use for electioneering.

Summary updated

Abstract

Participatory budgeting (PB) is a democratic approach to allocating municipal spending that has been adopted in many places in recent years, including in Chicago. Current PB voting resembles a ballot where residents are asked which municipal projects, such as school improvements and road repairs, to fund with a limited budget. In this work, we ask how interactive visualization can benefit PB by conducting a design probe-based interview study (N=13) with policy workers and academics with expertise in PB, urban planning, and civic HCI. Our probe explores how graphical elicitation of voter preferences and a dashboard of voting statistics can be incorporated into a realistic PB tool. Through qualitative analysis, we find that visualization creates opportunities for city government to set expectations about budget constraints while also granting their constituents greater freedom to articulate a wider range of preferences. However, using visualization to provide transparency about PB requires efforts to mitigate potential access barriers and mistrust. We call for more visualization professionals to help build civic capacity by working in and studying political systems.
BibTeX
@article{kale2024what,
  author = {Alex Kale and Danni Liu and Maria Gabriela Ayala and Harper Schwab and Andrew McNutt},
  title = {{What Can Interactive Visualization Do for Participatory Budgeting in Chicago?}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tvcg.2024.3456343},
}
Figure