What can be measured asymptotically?

Simon Caron-Huot, Mathieu Giroux, Holmfridur S. Hannesdottir, Sebastian Mizera

TL;DR

This paper expands the standard "S-matrix" framework of quantum field theory beyond simple scattering amplitudes to include a vast library of "out-of-time-order" observables, such as gravitational radiation waveforms. By generalizing the LSZ reduction formula and using a diagrammatic approach called "blobology," the authors provide a systematic way to calculate what we actually measure in experiments like LIGO.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In traditional particle physics, the "S-matrix" is the holy grail—it tells us the probability of an initial state of particles (the "in" state) evolving into a final state (the "out" state). We usually calculate scattering amplitudes, square them, and get cross-sections.

However, many real-world physical questions don't fit this "in-to-out" mold. For example, if you want to know the gravitational waveform produced by two black holes colliding, you aren't asking for the probability of a specific final state. Instead, you are asking for the expectation value of the gravitational field at a specific point in the future, given a known starting point. This is an "in-in" observable.

The challenge is that these observables involve different operator orderings that standard textbook QFT isn't always equipped to handle. There has been a gap in the formal "rules of the game" for systematically calculating these non-time-ordered quantities, especially in the context of classical gravity and the post-Minkowski expansion.

Methods

The authors bridge this gap using three primary pillars:

  1. Blobology: A diagrammatic tool that treats S-matrices and their complex conjugates ($S^\dagger$) as "blobs." By sewing these blobs together with "cuts" (representing on-shell intermediate states), they can decompose complex inclusive observables into products of standard amplitudes.
  2. Generalized LSZ Reduction: The LSZ formula is the standard bridge between correlation functions and scattering amplitudes. The authors extend this to "out-of-time-order" correlators, showing how different surface terms at past and future infinity correspond to different physical measurements.
  3. Schwinger-Keldysh Formalism: They utilize multi-time-fold contours (path integrals that run forward and then backward in time) to represent these observables. This allows them to derive Feynman rules that naturally incorporate "cut" propagators and reversed $i\epsilon$ prescriptions.

As a practical application, they apply these methods to calculate one-loop master integrals for gravitational waveforms in the "eikonal limit" (the regime of high energy and small scattering angles).

Datasets

Not applicable. This is a theoretical physics paper focused on mathematical derivations and analytical calculations within Quantum Field Theory and General Relativity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Waveforms are Linear, Not Quadratic: Unlike cross-sections, which are the square of an amplitude, radiation waveforms are linear in the field. This makes them fundamentally different objects that require their own set of "master integrals."
  • The Role of the "Cut": To get a causal waveform, you can't just use a standard time-ordered amplitude. You must subtract specific "cut" terms. These subtractions remove interactions that would happen after the radiation is emitted, ensuring the result only depends on the physics in the radiation's past light cone.
  • $i\epsilon$ Matters: The paper highlights that the choice of $i\epsilon$ (the infinitesimal imaginary part added to propagators) is not just a mathematical trick but a physical requirement. Reversing the sign of $i\epsilon$ in certain channels is equivalent to propagating a particle backward in time, which is necessary for calculating expectation values.
  • Infrared Physics Divergence: The authors find that the infrared (low-energy) divergences for "in-in" observables (like waveforms) are different from "in-out" observables (like amplitudes). Specifically, they account for the propagation of massive bodies from the infinite past, leading to a new prediction for the total infrared-divergent time delay.

Key Results

  • Enumeration of Observables: The authors prove that the number of distinct types of asymptotic measurements grows exponentially with the number of particles ($T_n \sim (2+\sqrt{2})^{n-3}$), showing that standard amplitudes are just a tiny subset of what is theoretically measurable.
  • Master Integral Library: They provide a subset of differential equations and boundary conditions for the eikonal master integrals needed for one-loop gravitational waveform calculations.
  • Causality Restoration: They demonstrate explicitly how the "classical cut" contribution ensures that the calculated waveform follows causal propagation, correcting previous approaches that relied solely on time-ordered (principal-value) integrals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Higher-Loop Complexity: While the relationship between "cuts" and the imaginary parts of diagrams is straightforward at one loop, the authors note it becomes much more complex at higher loops.
  • Local Analyticity: A major open question is determining which combinations of these generalized amplitudes are "locally analytic"—meaning they can be smoothly deformed into one another in complex momentum space. This is crucial for understanding "crossing symmetry" (the relationship between particles and antiparticles).
  • String Theory: The authors suggest that these "in-in" type integrals might eventually be calculated using strings on a Schwinger-Keldysh target space, a potentially powerful future direction for high-energy physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We consider asymptotic observables in quantum field theories in which the S-matrix makes sense. We argue that in addition to scattering amplitudes, a whole compendium of inclusive observables exists where the time-ordering is relaxed. These include expectation values of electromagnetic or gravitational radiation fields as well as out-of-time-order amplitudes. We explain how to calculate them in two ways: by relating them to amplitudes and products of amplitudes, and by using a generalization of the LSZ reduction formula. As an application, we discuss one-loop master integrals contributing to gravitational radiation in the post-Minkowski expansion, emphasizing the role of classical cut contributions and highlighting the different infrared physics of in-in observables.
BibTeX
@article{caronhuot2024what,
  author = {Simon Caron-Huot and Mathieu Giroux and Holmfridur S. Hannesdottir and Sebastian Mizera},
  title = {{What can be measured asymptotically?}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2024)139},
}

Loading related content...

Figure