WFIRST: The Essential Cosmology Space Observatory for the Coming Decade

Olivier Doré, Christopher M. Hirata, Yun Wang, David H. Weinberg, T. F. Eifler, R. J. Foley, Chen Heinrich, E. Krause, S. Perlmutter, Alice Pisani, D. Scolnic, David N. Spergel, N. B. Suntzeff, G. Aldering, C. Baltay, P. Capak, A. Choi, Susana E. Deustua, Cora Dvorkin, S. Michael Fall, Xiao Fang, A. S. Fruchter, L. Galbany, Shirley Ho, Rebekah Hounsell, Albert Izard, Bhuvnesh Jain, Anton M. Koekemoer, J. W. Kruk, Alexie Leauthaud, Sangeeta Malhotra, Rachel Mandelbaum, Elena Massara, Daniel Masters, Hironao Miyatake, A. A. Plazas, James E. Rhoads, Jason Rhodes, Benjamin Rose, D. Rubin, M. Šako, Lado Samushia, Masato Shirasaki, Melanie Simet, Masahiro Takada, M. A. Troxel, Hao‐Yi Wu, Naoki Yoshida, Zhongxu Zhai

Abstract: Two decades after its discovery, cosmic acceleration remains the most profound mystery in cosmology and arguably in all of physics. Either the Universe is dominated by a form of dark energy with exotic physical properties not predicted by standard model physics, or General Relativity is not an adequate description of gravity over cosmic distances. WFIRST emerged as a top priority of Astro2010 in part because of its ability to address the mystery of cosmic acceleration through both high precision measurements of the cosmic expansion history and the growth of cosmic structures with multiple and redundant probes. We illustrate in this white paper how mission design changes since Astro2010 have made WFIRST an even more powerful dark energy facility and have improved the ability of WFIRST to respond to changes in the experimental landscape. WFIRST is the space-based probe of DE the community needs in the mid-2020s.

The Challenge of Cosmic Acceleration

Since the discovery of cosmic acceleration two decades ago, physics has faced a fundamental fork in the road: either the vacuum of space contains a mysterious "dark energy" (DE), or our theory of gravity (General Relativity) is incomplete. Current observations have reached a "tension" phase, characterized by significant discrepancies between the Hubble constant ($H_0$) measured from the local universe versus the early universe (CMB). Additionally, measurements of matter clustering ($S_8$) show a slight but persistent mismatch with standard $\Lambda$CDM model predictions.

To resolve these discrepancies, the scientific community requires a massive leap in systematic error control. Ground-based surveys are inherently limited by the atmosphere, and current space missions lack the specific combination of wide-field area and infrared sensitivity required to cross-validate these conflicting results. WFIRST (now known as the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope) is designed to address these challenges head-on.

Methodology: A Multi-Probe Strategy

WFIRST is designed as an agile and efficient observatory, utilizing a 2.4-meter telescope equipped with a Wide Field Instrument (WFI). This instrument provides a field of view 100 times larger than Hubble's infrared camera while maintaining high angular resolution (0.11" pixels). Unlike missions that specialize in a single area, WFIRST employs three primary "probes" to ensure redundancy and robust systematic mitigation:

  1. Weak Lensing (WL): Measuring the subtle distortion of galaxy shapes to map dark matter distribution.
  2. Supernovae (SN): Utilizing Type Ia supernovae as "standard candles" to measure expansion history.
  3. Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) & Redshift-Space Distortions (RSD): Mapping the 3D distribution of galaxies to measure the growth of cosmic structures.

Notional Survey Design

The mission's capabilities are demonstrated through several "Notional Surveys":

  • High Latitude Survey (HLS): A 2,000 deg² survey reaching depths of ~26.9 magnitude, providing imaging data significantly deeper and clearer than ground-based alternatives.
  • SN Survey: A multi-tier survey designed to discover and track approximately 11,000 Type Ia supernovae up to a redshift of $z=3$.
  • Synergistic Integration: WFIRST will integrate with data from the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST), Euclid, and DESI to provide "object-by-object" cross-validation.

Projected Performance and Tension Resolution

WFIRST's design prioritizes stability and redundant measurement methods to handle "unknown unknowns." The mission is projected to achieve sub-percent accuracy in measuring the cosmic expansion history.

Projected fractional errors for WFIRST notional surveys across different cosmological probes compared to 2019 benchmarks.

As shown in the figure above, WFIRST (solid lines) significantly improves upon the precision of 2019-era benchmarks (stars) across multiple probes, including Supernovae ($D_L(z)$), Galaxy redshift surveys ($H(z)$ and $D_M(z)$), and Weak Lensing ($\sigma_8(z)$). This high-density mapping is expected to yield 14 million $H\alpha$ redshifts and 3.8 million [OIII] redshifts.

Furthermore, WFIRST's precision is expected to definitively confirm or rule out current cosmological tensions. By providing imaging data that is significantly deeper and more stable than ground-based surveys, it will provide tight constraints on parameters like $S_8$ and $\Omega_m$.

Projected constraints on $S_8$ and $\Omega_m$ for WFIRST compared to DES Y1 and Planck 2015, demonstrating the potential to resolve current cosmological tensions.

Future Outlook

While WFIRST offers unprecedented precision, challenges remain. The exact yield of redshift surveys depends on the still-uncertain galaxy emission-line luminosity function. Additionally, while the "Notional Surveys" provide a baseline, the final allocation of observation time between imaging and spectroscopy will be determined closer to launch based on the evolving state of the field. Despite these variables, the "space advantage"—photometric stability and infrared sensitivity—makes WFIRST the essential tool for exploring the distant, high-redshift universe where dark energy began to dominate.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two decades after its discovery, cosmic acceleration remains the most profound mystery in cosmology and arguably in all of physics. Either the Universe is dominated by a form of dark energy with exotic physical properties not predicted by standard model physics, or General Relativity is not an adequate description of gravity over cosmic distances. WFIRST emerged as a top priority of Astro2010 in part because of its ability to address the mystery of cosmic acceleration through both high precision measurements of the cosmic expansion history and the growth of cosmic structures with multiple and redundant probes. We illustrate in this white paper how mission design changes since Astro2010 have made WFIRST an even more powerful dark energy facility and have improved the ability of WFIRST to respond to changes in the experimental landscape. WFIRST is the space-based probe of DE the community needs in the mid-2020s.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dore2019wfirst,
  author = {Olivier Doré and Christopher M. Hirata and Yun Wang and David H. Weinberg and T. F. Eifler and R. J. Foley and Chen Heinrich and E. Krause and S. Perlmutter and Alice Pisani and D. Scolnic and David N. Spergel and N. B. Suntzeff and G. Aldering and C. Baltay and P. Capak and A. Choi and Susana E. Deustua and Cora Dvorkin and S. Michael Fall and Xiao Fang and A. S. Fruchter and L. Galbany and Shirley Ho and Rebekah Hounsell and Albert Izard and Bhuvnesh Jain and Anton M. Koekemoer and J. W. Kruk and Alexie Leauthaud and Sangeeta Malhotra and Rachel Mandelbaum and Elena Massara and Daniel Masters and Hironao Miyatake and A. A. Plazas and James E. Rhoads and Jason Rhodes and Benjamin Rose and D. Rubin and M. Šako and Lado Samushia and Masato Shirasaki and Melanie Simet and Masahiro Takada and M. A. Troxel and Hao‐Yi Wu and Naoki Yoshida and Zhongxu Zhai},
  title = {{WFIRST: The Essential Cosmology Space Observatory for the Coming Decade}},
  booktitle = {CaltechAUTHORS},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure