Wet scavenging limits the detection of aerosol effects on precipitation

Edward Gryspeerdt, Philip Stier, Bethan White, Zak Kipling

TL;DR

This paper reveals that wet scavenging by precipitation significantly reduces aerosol optical depth (AOD) in cloudy and precipitating regions, making it difficult for satellite observations to capture aerosol-cloud-precipitation interactions. This sampling difference between "clear-sky" satellite AOD and "all-sky" model AOD explains discrepancies between models and observations, potentially masking aerosol invigoration effects on precipitation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Scientists are keen to understand how aerosols influence precipitation. Satellite observations often show a positive correlation between aerosol load (measured by AOD) and precipitation, suggesting aerosols might invigorate clouds. However, general circulation models (GCMs) sometimes show a negative correlation, or no correlation at all. This discrepancy is partly attributed to how aerosols and clouds are sampled. Satellites primarily retrieve AOD in "clear-sky" conditions, while GCMs inherently consider "all-sky" conditions, including those with clouds and precipitation. This paper investigates how the process of wet scavenging, where precipitation removes aerosols from the atmosphere, combined with this sampling difference, affects observed aerosol-precipitation relationships, particularly in convective clouds.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Regional Climate Modeling (WRF-Chem): They used a high-resolution WRF-Chem model to simulate aerosol and precipitation dynamics over the Congo Basin. This allowed them to investigate aerosol behavior under various precipitation conditions and to explicitly model wet scavenging.
  • Satellite Data Analysis: They utilized satellite-derived AOD (MODIS) and precipitation data (TRMM) to analyze observed relationships. A key technique was the "precipitation development method," which accounts for meteorological covariations to isolate aerosol-precipitation links.
  • Reanalysis Data (MACC): To represent an "all-sky" AOD similar to what GCMs experience, they used the MACC reanalysis AOD product. This product assimilates satellite data but also provides AOD estimates for cloudy and precipitating regions.
  • Storm Composites: They created composite images of convective storms to visualize how AOD changes in and around precipitating systems. This was done both with and without wet scavenging enabled in the model to isolate its effect.

Datasets

  • MODIS Collection 5.1 Level 3 product: Used for aerosol optical depth (AOD) retrievals.
  • TRMM 3B42 merged precipitation product: Used for 3-hourly precipitation estimates.
  • MACC (Monitoring Atmospheric Composition and Climate) reanalysis AOD product: Used to represent "all-sky" AOD.
  • NCEP reanalysis data: Used for initial and boundary conditions for the WRF-Chem model.
  • MODIS fire counts (MCD14ML): Used for biomass burning emission estimates in WRF-Chem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wet Scavenging is a Dominant Factor: The study strongly suggests that wet scavenging is a primary driver of the negative correlation between AOD and precipitation in cloudy/precipitating regions. Precipitation effectively cleans the atmosphere, reducing AOD.
  • "Clear-Sky" vs. "All-Sky" Sampling Matters: The difference in what satellites (clear-sky AOD) and models (all-sky AOD) "see" is crucial. Models, by including cloudy/precipitating regions, see a much lower AOD due to scavenging, which can mask potential aerosol influences on precipitation.
  • Obscured Invigoration: The paper argues that the strong effect of wet scavenging in high-precipitation regions can obscure the subtle signals of aerosol invigoration (where aerosols might enhance precipitation) that might be detectable in "clear-sky" satellite data.
  • Convective Systems are Key: The research highlights that these effects are particularly pronounced in convective cloud regimes, which are common in the tropics and are significant precipitation producers.
  • Model Limitations: The findings imply that even with perfect representations of aerosol physics, GCMs might struggle to reproduce observed aerosol-precipitation correlations due to their inherent "all-sky" sampling and the difficulty in separating clear-sky aerosol from the heavily scavenged all-sky aerosol.

Key Results

  • AOD Reduction in Precipitating Regions: WRF-Chem simulations showed a significant reduction in AOD in precipitating and cloudy areas, with the reduction becoming more pronounced with stricter definitions of precipitation/cloudiness.
  • Storm Composite Findings: A composite of convective storms revealed a strong reduction in column-integrated AOD at the storm's center and along its path, attributed to wet scavenging. This reduction was absent in simulations where wet scavenging was turned off.
  • Precipitation Development Plots: When using MODIS (clear-sky) AOD, the precipitation development method revealed both wet scavenging signatures (decrease in precipitation before T+0 for high AOD) and potential invigoration signatures (increase in precipitation after T+0 for high AOD) in shallow cumulus regimes. However, when using MACC (all-sky) AOD, the invigoration signature was often masked, especially in high CF regimes.
  • Model-Satellite Correlation Differences: The study provides evidence that the difference in AOD-precipitation correlations between models and satellites, as seen in Figure 1 of the paper, can be explained by wet scavenging and the resulting sampling differences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Resolution: The WRF-Chem model used a 10 km horizontal grid length, which is not sufficient to resolve small-scale convective features. While it can resolve larger precipitating systems, finer resolution might reveal more detailed interactions.
  • Idealized Setup: The WRF-Chem simulation used a semi-idealized setup with emissions generated within the domain. While this was deemed sufficient for studying precipitation-aerosol interactions within the domain, it doesn't fully represent the transport of aerosols from outside.
  • Storm Composite Bias: The filtering techniques used to select storms for the composite might introduce biases, making it not entirely representative of all convective storms.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further investigation into how GCMs handle the separation of "clear-sky" and "all-sky" aerosol is needed. They also imply that understanding the role of aerosol hygroscopic growth in "clear-sky" conditions is important for explaining positive correlations in certain regions. The paper also points to the need for better methods to distinguish aerosol influences from meteorological covariations, especially in complex cloud regimes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Satellite studies of aerosol–cloud interactions usually make use of retrievals of both aerosol and cloud properties, but these retrievals are rarely spatially co-located. While it is possible to retrieve aerosol properties above clouds under certain circumstances, aerosol properties are usually only retrieved in cloud-free scenes. Generally, the smaller spatial variability of aerosols compared to clouds reduces the importance of this sampling difference. However, as precipitation generates an increase in spatial variability of aerosols, the imperfect co-location of aerosol and cloud property retrievals may lead to changes in observed aerosol–cloud–precipitation relationships in precipitating environments. In this work, we use a regional-scale model, satellite observations and reanalysis data to investigate how the non-coincidence of aerosol, cloud and precipitation retrievals affects correlations between them. We show that the difference in the aerosol optical depth (AOD)–precipitation relationship between general circulation models (GCMs) and satellite observations can be explained by the wet scavenging of aerosol. Using observations of the development of precipitation from cloud regimes, we show how the influence of wet scavenging can obscure possible aerosol influences on precipitation from convective clouds. This obscuring of aerosol–cloud–precipitation interactions by wet scavenging suggests that even if GCMs contained a perfect representation of aerosol influences on convective clouds, the difficulty of separating the "clear-sky" aerosol from the "all-sky" aerosol in GCMs may prevent them from reproducing the correlations seen in satellite data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gryspeerdt2015wet,
  author = {Edward Gryspeerdt and Philip Stier and Bethan White and Zak Kipling},
  title = {{Wet scavenging limits the detection of aerosol effects on precipitation}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-15-7557-2015},
}
Figure