Weighted persistent homology for osmolyte molecular aggregation and hydrogen-bonding network analysis

D. Vijay Anand, Kelin Xia, Yuguang Mu

Abstract

It has long been observed that trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) and urea demonstrate dramatically different properties in protein folding processes. Despite extensive research, the underlying mechanisms of these two osmolytes remain largely elusive. This paper proposes the use of weighted persistent homology (WPH) to systematically study osmolyte molecular aggregation and hydrogen-bonding networks from a local topological perspective. By employing two weighted models—localized persistent homology (LPH) and interactive persistent homology (IPH)—we reveal distinct local topologies. TMAO exhibits local network structures that tighten with increasing concentration, while urea shows local clusters and sparse global loops. Furthermore, we introduce the persistent radial distribution function (PRDF), which captures both traditional physical properties and hidden local-scale interaction information, distinguishing the behavior of TMAO and urea across varying filtration sizes.

Introduction

In structural biology, TMAO and urea are renowned for their opposing roles: TMAO acts as a protein stabilizer, while urea serves as a denaturant. Understanding how these molecules aggregate and interact with water at a local level is critical to decoding their biological functions. Traditional metrics like the Radial Distribution Function (RDF) provide global averages of molecular distances but often fail to capture the specific "shape" or connectivity of the local environment. This study addresses this gap by applying Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to distinguish between "structure-making" and "structure-breaking" molecular networks.

Methodology and Models

The researchers utilize Persistent Homology (PH) to monitor the evolution of topological features—such as connected components ($\beta_0$) and loops ($\beta_1$)—as a distance scale (filtration) varies. Two primary weighted models are introduced:

  1. Localized Persistent Homology (LPH): This model focuses on a sphere of radius $R_c$ around a specific molecule to capture local clustering and aggregation patterns, filtering out global noise.
  2. Interactive Persistent Homology (IPH): This model tracks interactions specifically between different species (e.g., osmolyte-to-water), ignoring same-species distances to isolate cross-interaction dynamics.
Schematic of Localized Persistent Homology (LPH) showing the local analysis region $\Omega$ defined by a cutoff radius $R_c$ around a central molecule.

The study relies on Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations performed in GROMACS, using the TIP4P-EW water model and concentrations ranging from 1M to 8M. The topological regularity of these systems is further quantified using Persistent Entropy (PE) and Persistent Betti Numbers (PBN).

Key Insights: Network Builders vs. Clusterers

The topological analysis reveals fundamental differences in how these osmolytes organize:

  • TMAO as a Network Builder: TMAO molecules form regular, local network structures. As concentration increases, the number of topological loops ($\beta_1$) grows while their size decreases, suggesting the formation of a more compact and organized local lattice.
  • Urea as a Clusterer: In contrast, urea lacks consistent network growth. It exhibits two distinct patterns: small local clusters (around 6 Å) and a few large, global loops (around 12 Å). Persistent Entropy measurements confirm that urea maintains a higher degree of disorder compared to the increasingly "lattice-like" TMAO systems.

Quantitative Results via PRDF

A major contribution of this work is the Persistent Radial Distribution Function (PRDF). While the PRDF matches traditional RDF properties at a global scale, it provides superior resolution for local-scale interactions.

Persistent Radial Distribution Functions (PRDFs) for TMAO (top row) and urea (bottom row) across different concentrations (1M-8M) and local radii $R_c$ (9Å, 12Å, 15Å).

As shown in the PRDF plots, TMAO and urea exhibit a clear difference in their first interaction peak at a filtration size of 4 Å. Furthermore, they show divergent behaviors in the second peak region (5 Å to 10 Å). For TMAO, the peak of the $\beta_1$ distribution shifts from ~13 Å to ~7 Å as concentration rises, indicating a systematic shrinking of molecular rings. For urea, the variance in Persistent Entropy increases with concentration, highlighting its growing heterogeneity.

Conclusion

By bridging TDA with physical chemistry, this research provides a new lens through which to view molecular liquids. The weighted persistent homology models successfully characterize the elusive local structures of TMAO and urea, explaining their divergent effects on protein stability. These topological "fingerprints" are highly generalizable and could be applied to study ion aggregation, DNA trajectories, and other complex chemical networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has long been observed that trimethylamin N-oxide (TMAO) and urea demonstrate dramatically different properties in a protein folding process. Even with the enormous theoretical and experimental research work of the two osmolytes, various aspects of their underlying mechanisms still remain largely elusive. In this paper, we propose to use the weighted persistent homology to systematically study the osmolytes molecular aggregation and their hydrogen-bonding network from a local topological perspective. We consider two weighted models, i.e., localized persistent homology (LPH) and interactive persistent homology (IPH). From the localized persistent homology models, we have found that TMAO and urea have very different local topology. TMAO shows local network structures. With the concentration increase, the circle elements in these networks show a clear increase in their total numbers and a decrease in their relative sizes. In contrast, urea shows two types of local topological patterns, i.e., local clusters around 6 Å~ and a few global circle elements at around 12 Å. From the interactive persistent homology models, it has been found that our persistent radial distribution function (PRDF) from the global-scale IPH has same physical properties as the traditional radial distribution function (RDF). Moreover, PRDFs from the local-scale IPH can also be generated and used to characterize the local interaction information. Other than the clear difference of the first peak value of PRDFs at filtration size 4Å, TMAO and urea also shows very different behaviors at the second peak region from filtration size 5Å~ to 10 Å.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anand2020weighted,
  author = {D. Vijay Anand and Kelin Xia and Yuguang Mu},
  title = {{Weighted persistent homology for osmolyte molecular aggregation and hydrogen-bonding network analysis}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-66710-6},
}
Figure