Web Futures: Inclusive, Intelligent, Sustainable The 2020 Manifesto for Web Science (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 18262)

Bettina Berendt, Fabien Gandon, Susan Halford, Wendy Hall, Jim Hendler, Katharina E. Kinder-Kurlanda, Eirini Ntoutsi, Steffen Staab

TL;DR

This manifesto, born from a 2018 Web Science workshop, argues that the Web's future hinges on navigating inherent ambivalences, particularly with the rise of AI. It calls for a proactive, interdisciplinary "Web Science" to shape an inclusive, intelligent, and sustainable Web, emphasizing the need for global collaboration and capacity building.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors address the fundamental challenge of understanding and shaping the future of the World Wide Web. While the Web has brought immense benefits in information sharing, collective organization, and social inclusion, it also carries significant negative consequences like surveillance, misinformation, and the concentration of power in a few corporations. The paper highlights that the increasing integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) will amplify both these positive and negative aspects, making it crucial to proactively guide the Web's evolution. They aim to move beyond simply observing the Web to actively engineering its future, emphasizing the need for a robust scientific discipline – Web Science – to tackle these complex, sociotechnical issues.

Methods

This paper is not a traditional research paper presenting empirical results from experiments or data analysis. Instead, it's a manifesto and a call to action stemming from a workshop. The "method" is essentially a synthesis of the collective expertise and discussions of a diverse group of scholars (sociologists, computer scientists, philosophers, etc.) who convened to reflect on the past decade of Web Science and chart a course for the future. Their approach involves:

  • Revisiting the origins and evolution of the Web: Understanding its historical trajectory and the emergence of Web Science.
  • Identifying and analyzing "ambivalences": Pinpointing inherent tensions within the Web (e.g., information freedom vs. quality, personalization vs. privacy).
  • Exploring the impact of AI: Examining how AI amplifies these ambivalences and presents new challenges and opportunities.
  • Proposing future directions for Web Science: Outlining key areas for research, capacity building, and action.
  • Advocating for interdisciplinary collaboration: Emphasizing the necessity of bringing together diverse fields to address the Web's complexity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Web is a "nervous system" for the planet: It's deeply embedded in and shapes all aspects of global society, not just a technical infrastructure.
  • Inherent "ambivalences" are core to the Web's nature: These tensions (e.g., freedom vs. quality, privacy vs. personalization) are not easily resolved and require continuous navigation.
  • AI is a double-edged sword for the Web: It can amplify both the Web's benefits (e.g., intelligent services) and its harms (e.g., misinformation, exploitation).
  • Web Science must evolve to be proactive, not just descriptive: The discipline needs to actively shape the Web's future, not just study its past and present.
  • "Web governance" needs to expand beyond "Internet governance": It must encompass not only technical aspects but also the complex social, ethical, and legal dimensions, including the governance of AI agents.
  • Capacity building is crucial: This involves fostering interdisciplinarity, collaboration, and developing the "Sustainable," "Intelligent," and "Inclusive" Web.
  • Individual and collective action are vital: Shaping the Web's future requires both personal responsibility and systemic change driven by institutions and policymakers.

Key Results

As a manifesto, this paper doesn't present quantitative results. Its "results" are conceptual and prescriptive:

  • Identification of five key ambivalences: Information Freedom vs. Information Quality, Personalization vs. Privacy, Mass Participation vs. Manipulation of the Masses, Inclusiveness and Fairness vs. Exploitation, and Sustainability vs. Growth.
  • Outline of challenges at individual and group levels: Particularly concerning the integration of AI and the need for "AI-friendly" Web architectures.
  • Proposals for extending Web Science: Emphasizing collaborative research, shared infrastructures, and participatory methods.
  • A framework for capacity building: Detailing actions for researchers, academic institutions, educators, enterprises, and policymakers across five key areas.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Western-centric perspective: The authors acknowledge that their observations are skewed towards their experience as Western scholars, and Web Science needs to overcome this limitation.
  • Complexity of governance: The paper highlights the immense challenge of creating effective global Web governance that balances diverse rights and interests, especially with the rise of AI.
  • Need for ongoing dialogue: The manifesto emphasizes that the Web is a "never-ending project" and that continuous adaptation, reflection, and collaboration are necessary to address emerging problems and opportunities.
  • Future work is implicitly defined by the proposed actions: The paper calls for significant efforts in interdisciplinarity, collaboration, supporting the sustainable, intelligent, and inclusive Web, and developing robust governance and capacity-building mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

This Manifesto was produced from the Perspectives Workshop 18262 entitled "10 Years of Web Science" that took place at Schloss Dagstuhl from June 24 – 29, 2018. At the Workshop, we revisited the origins of Web Science, explored the challenges and opportunities of the Web, and looked ahead to potential futures for both the Web and Web Science. We explain issues that society faces in the Web by the ambivalences that are inherent in the Web. All the enormous benefits that the Web offers - for information sharing, collective organization and distributed activity, social inclusion and economic growth - will always carry along negative consequences, too, and 30 years after its creation negative consequences of the Web are only too apparent. The Web continues to evolve and its next major step will involve Artificial Intelligence (AI) at large. AI has the potential to amplify positive and negative outcomes, and we explore these possibilities, situating them within the wider debate about the future of regulation and governance for the Web. Finally, we outline the need to extend Web Science as the science that is devoted to the analysis and engineering of the Web, to strengthen our role in shaping the future of the Web and present five key directions for capacity building that are necessary to achieve this: (i), supporting interdisciplinarity, (ii), supporting collaboration, (iii), supporting the sustainable Web, (iv), supporting the Intelligent Web, and (v), supporting the Inclusive Web. Our writing reflects our background in several disciplines of the social and technical sciences and that these disciplines emphasize topics to various extents. We are acutely aware that our observations occupy a particular point in time and are skewed towards our experience as Western scholars - a limitation that Web Science will need to overcome.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berendt2021web,
  author = {Bettina Berendt and Fabien Gandon and Susan Halford and Wendy Hall and Jim Hendler and Katharina E. Kinder-Kurlanda and Eirini Ntoutsi and Steffen Staab},
  title = {{Web Futures: Inclusive, Intelligent, Sustainable The 2020 Manifesto for Web Science (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 18262)}},
  booktitle = {Dagstuhl Manifestos},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=1qpsp0bkBE3},
}

Loading related content...

Figure