Water-Triggered, Irreversible Conformational Change of SARS-CoV-2 Main Protease on Passing from the Solid State to Aqueous Solution

Narjes Ansari, Valerio Rizzi, Paolo Carloni, Michele Parrinello

Abstract

The main protease from SARS-CoV-2 is a homodimer. Yet, a recent 0.1 ms long molecular dynamics simulation shows that it readily undergoes a symmetry breaking event on passing from the solid state to the aqueous solution. As a result, the subunits present distinct conformations of the binding pocket. By analysing this long time simulation, here we uncover a previously unrecognised role of water molecules in triggering the transition. Interestingly, each subunit presents a different collection of long-lived water molecules. Enhanced sampling methods performed here, along with machine learning approaches, further establish that the transition to the asymmetric state is essentially irreversible.

Introduction

The main protease ($M^{pro}$) of SARS-CoV-2 is a primary target for antiviral drug development due to its essential role in viral replication. Traditionally characterized as a symmetric homodimer via X-ray crystallography, recent evidence suggests that $M^{pro}$ may exhibit functional asymmetry in solution. This study investigates the transition of $M^{pro}$ from its solid-state symmetric form to an asymmetric state in aqueous environments, identifying the molecular triggers and the energetic landscape of this transformation.

Methods

The researchers utilized a 100-microsecond molecular dynamics (MD) simulation of the $M^{pro}$ homodimer in water. To explore rare conformational states, they employed On-the-fly Probability Enhanced Sampling (OPES). Machine learning, specifically Deep Linear Discriminant Analysis (Deep-LDA), was used to identify 26 key structural descriptors that distinguish active from inactive subunits. Additionally, water residency analysis categorized water molecules based on their stability within the protein's binding pockets, identifying "medium-lived" and "long-lived" populations.

Results and Discussion

The Water-Triggered Symmetry Breaking

The transition from a symmetric to an asymmetric dimer occurs rapidly upon exposure to an aqueous environment, typically within the first microsecond (between 0.75 and 1.035 $\mu$s). This process is initiated by a single "intruder" water molecule entering the S1 binding pocket of one subunit. This molecule facilitates a bridge between specific residues (His163 and Tyr161), triggering a conformational shift in Glu166. This shift breaks the hydrogen bond network with the "N-finger" (the tail of the opposite subunit), leading to the collapse of the binding pocket and subunit inactivation.

Figure 1: Structural transition of the SARS-CoV-2 Mpro homodimer. (a-c) Overview of the subunits and domains. (d-g) Time-resolved snapshots of the water-triggered conformational change involving the m-shaped loop and N-finger.

Asymmetric Water Reservoirs and Irreversibility

A key finding is the distinct behavior of water within each subunit. The active subunit maintains a stable "water reservoir," whereas the inactive subunit exhibits a fluctuating volume with different water populations. Analysis of residency times ($\tau_{max}$) reveals specific sites where water molecules remain bound for significant durations, contributing to the structural stability of the asymmetric state. The researchers identified four primary long-lived water sites (W1-W4) that differ between the subunits.

Figure 2: Mapping of water residency times within the Mpro subunits. The spheres represent long-lived water molecules (W1-W4) with varying residency times, highlighting the asymmetric hydration of the dimer.

Enhanced sampling calculations indicate that this symmetry breaking is essentially irreversible under physiological conditions. The free energy barrier to return to the symmetric state is estimated at 125–150 kJ/mol, effectively locking the enzyme into its asymmetric configuration once in solution. This suggests that the enzyme functions as a "half-of-the-sites" active dimer.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the SARS-CoV-2 $M^{pro}$ undergoes a permanent, water-induced transition to an asymmetric state in solution. This finding has significant implications for drug design, suggesting that therapeutic strategies should target the asymmetric, solution-phase structure rather than the symmetric crystal structure. Future efforts should focus on molecules that can exploit this asymmetry or stabilize the inactive conformation to inhibit viral replication more effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

The main protease from SARS-CoV-2 is a homodimer. Yet, a recent 0.1-ms-long molecular dynamics simulation performed by D. E. Shaw's research group shows that it readily undergoes a symmetry-breaking event on passing from the solid state to aqueous solution. As a result, the subunits present distinct conformations of the binding pocket. By analyzing this long simulation, we uncover a previously unrecognized role of water molecules in triggering the transition. Interestingly, each subunit presents a different collection of long-lived water molecules. Enhanced sampling simulations performed here, along with machine learning approaches, further establish that the transition to the asymmetric state is essentially irreversible.
BibTeX
@article{ansari2021water,
  author = {Narjes Ansari and Valerio Rizzi and Paolo Carloni and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Water-Triggered, Irreversible Conformational Change of SARS-CoV-2 Main Protease on Passing from the Solid State to Aqueous Solution}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.1c05301},
}
Figure