Wakeful rest compared to vigilance reduces intrusive but not deliberate memory for traumatic videos

Lone D. Hørlyck, James A. Bisby, John A. King, Neil BurgessScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that a brief period of wakeful rest immediately after viewing traumatic content significantly reduces intrusive memories without affecting deliberate recall. This suggests that distinct memory systems underlie intrusive and deliberate memories, offering a new avenue for therapeutic interventions targeting post-traumatic stress.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intrusive memories, characterized by unwanted distressing images, are a hallmark of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Understanding how these memories form and their relationship to conscious, deliberate memories is crucial for developing effective treatments. Two competing theories exist: one posits a single memory system where both intrusive and deliberate memories are strengthened or weakened together, while the other suggests separate memory systems, allowing for differential effects. Specifically, this paper investigates the critical window immediately following trauma encoding, exploring how different post-encoding activities influence the consolidation of traumatic memories and subsequent intrusive and deliberate recall.

Methods

The researchers conducted two experiments using a paradigm that mimics exposure to traumatic events. Participants watched emotionally negative film clips. Immediately after viewing, they were assigned to one of two conditions:

  • Wakeful Rest: A 10-minute period of quiet relaxation with no specific instructions on what to think about.
  • Vigilance Task (0-back): A 10-minute task requiring sustained attention to a series of numbers presented sequentially, with the instruction to respond when a number matches the one presented immediately before it.

Following the intervention, participants kept a diary for a week to record any spontaneous intrusive memories related to the film clips. After this week, they returned for a recognition memory test to assess deliberate memory recall.

Experiment 2 employed a within-subjects design, meaning each participant experienced both wakeful rest and the 0-back task on separate occasions. This experiment also included neutral film clips alongside negative ones to investigate potential valence-specific effects and introduced an "intrusion provocation task" to further assess intrusive memories.

Datasets

The study utilized custom-created "trauma films" composed of short, emotionally negative video clips. In Experiment 2, neutral clips depicting everyday events were also used. The data collected included:

  • Intrusion Diary Data: Self-reported spontaneous intrusive memories recorded over a week.
  • Recognition Memory Test Data: Performance on a task assessing the ability to distinguish between previously seen images (from the trauma film) and new foil images.
  • Self-Report Questionnaires: Measures of trait and state anxiety, positive and negative affect, and trauma-related thoughts.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relied on established methods for measuring intrusive and deliberate memory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dissociable Memory Systems: The most significant finding is that wakeful rest differentially affects intrusive and deliberate memories. This strongly supports the "dual representation" theory, suggesting that these two types of memory are not solely dependent on a single, unified system.
  • The Power of "Doing Nothing": Contrary to what might be expected, simply allowing the mind to wander during wakeful rest, rather than actively engaging in a task, was beneficial for reducing intrusive memories. This highlights the importance of passive consolidation processes.
  • Contextual Consolidation: The researchers propose that wakeful rest may enhance the consolidation of contextual information related to the traumatic event. Strengthening these contextual representations could make it harder for the emotional core of the memory to be reactivated involuntarily, thus reducing intrusions.
  • Therapeutic Implications: The findings suggest that interventions aimed at facilitating memory consolidation, such as promoting periods of calm rest after a traumatic experience, could be a valuable strategy for preventing or reducing intrusive memories. This offers an alternative to solely focusing on disrupting the emotional or sensory aspects of the memory.

Key Results

  • Reduced Intrusive Memories: Participants who underwent wakeful rest reported significantly fewer intrusive memories over the week following the trauma film compared to those who performed the 0-back vigilance task.
  • Unaffected Deliberate Memory: There were no significant differences in deliberate memory performance (measured by recognition accuracy) between the wakeful rest and 0-back conditions in either experiment.
  • Experiment 2 Nuances: While overall deliberate memory (d') didn't differ, Experiment 2 showed a higher hit rate in the wakeful rest condition, suggesting a potential subtle benefit that was counteracted by a numerical increase in false alarms. This experiment also confirmed that the reduction in intrusions was specific to the wakeful rest condition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Analogue Trauma: The study used film clips as a proxy for real-life trauma. The level of arousal and distress experienced in the experiments was likely less intense than that in actual traumatic events, which could influence the generalizability of the findings.
  • Generalizability of Wakeful Rest: While wakeful rest was effective, the study acknowledges that in real-life trauma, severe stress might interfere with consolidation processes even during rest.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring therapeutic approaches that combine arousal reduction with memory consolidation strategies, such as Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR). Further research could also investigate how different types of stimuli (e.g., more complex narratives, different emotional valences) interact with wakeful rest and other post-encoding interventions. The potential for wakeful rest to enhance deliberate memory for emotional materials, as suggested by some previous studies, warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intrusive memories are prominent features of post-traumatic stress disorder, but the mechanisms supporting their development, and their relationship to deliberate memories, are subject to competing theories. Are they strengthened examples of a unitary memory system, or fragmented representations lacking aspects of healthy memories? Given the importance of post-encoding processing in memory consolidation, we investigated the effects of a brief wakeful rest compared to a vigilance task immediately after the encoding of traumatic material on subsequent intrusive and deliberate memory. Across two experiments, participants watched emotionally negative film clips immediately followed by a brief wakeful rest or a simple vigilance (0-back) task. Brief wakeful rest had distinct effects on memory compared to the 0-back task, reducing intrusive memory frequency but not changing deliberate memory performance. These differential effects suggest that intrusive memory and deliberate memory reflect dissociable systems, arguing against unitary accounts. Our findings highlight the importance of post-encoding processing in the consolidation of traumatic material and the development of intrusive memories and provide a new perspective for interpreting mechanisms of therapeutic intervention.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hrlyck2019wakeful,
  author = {Lone D. Hørlyck and James A. Bisby and John A. King and Neil Burgess},
  title = {{Wakeful rest compared to vigilance reduces intrusive but not deliberate memory for traumatic videos}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-49634-8},
}
Figure