Volatile Flavor of Tricholoma matsutake from the Different Regions of China by Using GC×GC-TOF MS

Yingtong Feng, Shaoxiong Liu, Yuan Fang, Jianying Li, Ming Ma, Zhenfu Yang, Lue Shang, Xiang Guo, Hua Rong, Dafeng SunFoods 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced GC×GC-TOF MS to comprehensively analyze the volatile flavor compounds (VOCs) of Tricholoma matsutake mushrooms from six different regions in China. The findings reveal significant regional variations in VOC profiles, allowing for the distinction of samples and the identification of key aroma compounds and sensory attributes that define the unique flavor of this prized mushroom.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tricholoma matsutake, commonly known as Matsutake, is a highly sought-after wild edible mushroom prized for its distinctive aroma. While its nutritional and medicinal properties are well-documented, understanding the specific volatile compounds that contribute to its unique flavor and how these vary geographically has been less explored. This is particularly important given that Matsutake cannot be cultivated artificially, making its origin and regional characteristics crucial for quality control, traceability, and potentially for guiding sustainable harvesting practices. The problem this paper addresses is the lack of detailed, region-specific analysis of the volatile flavor compounds of T. matsutake from China, a major source of this mushroom.

Methods

The core technique employed is two-dimensional gas chromatography-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (GC×GC-TOF MS). This advanced analytical method combines the separation power of two-dimensional gas chromatography with the high sensitivity and speed of time-of-flight mass spectrometry. This allows for the resolution and identification of a vast number of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) even in complex matrices like mushroom extracts.

Key steps included:

  • Sample Preparation: Solid-phase micro-extraction (SPME) was used to extract volatile compounds from the mushroom samples.
  • GC×GC-TOF MS Analysis: A specific GC×GC-TOF MS system with a two-stage cryogenic modulator was utilized. The analysis involved two different chromatographic columns (DB-Heavy Wax and Rxi-5Sil MS) to achieve enhanced separation.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Compound Identification: The NIST2020 database and Chroma TOF software were used for identifying the detected VOCs.
  • Statistical Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Partial Least Squares-Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) were employed to analyze the complex datasets and identify patterns and differences in VOC profiles across the different geographical regions.
  • Sensory Analysis: Flavor databases (Flavordb) were used to correlate identified VOCs with sensory attributes.
  • Network Analysis: A network analysis was performed to visualize the correlations between sensory attributes and specific aroma compounds, identifying key contributors to regional flavor differences.

Datasets

The study utilized Tricholoma matsutake fruiting bodies collected from six distinct geographical regions in China:

  • CX: Chuxiong, Yunnan province
  • DL: Dali, Yunnan province
  • DQ: Diqing, Yunnan province
  • JL: Yanji, Jilin province
  • SC: Xiaojin, Sichuan province
  • XZ: Linzhi, Xizang province

These samples were collected in August 2024. The study also referenced existing databases for compound identification (NIST2020) and sensory annotation (Flavordb, Odor Thresholds for Chemicals with Established Health Standards).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unprecedented VOC Diversity: The sheer number of identified VOCs (2730) highlights the complexity of Matsutake's aroma profile and the power of GC×GC-TOF MS in capturing this diversity.
  • Geographical Fingerprinting: The distinct VOC profiles observed across different regions suggest that geographical location, climate, and environmental factors play a significant role in shaping the mushroom's flavor. This opens doors for origin tracing and quality authentication.
  • Sensory Attributes as Drivers: The study successfully linked specific VOCs to key sensory attributes like "sweet," "fruity," "green," "waxy," and "floral," demonstrating that these are not just arbitrary descriptors but are directly tied to chemical composition.
  • Marker Compounds Identified: The identification of 33 specific aroma compounds as markers for regional differentiation is a crucial outcome, providing concrete chemical targets for understanding and potentially manipulating Matsutake flavor.

Key Results

  • A total of 2730 volatile organic compounds (VOCs) were identified across the six T. matsutake samples.
  • The JL (Yanji) sample had the highest VOC count (1234), while the DL (Dali) sample had the lowest (942).
  • The most abundant classes of VOCs were organoheterocyclic compounds (742) and hydrocarbons (630).
  • PCA and PLS-DA analyses successfully distinguished samples from different regions, indicating significant regional variations in their volatile profiles.
  • Network analysis identified 33 aroma compounds that act as key markers for differentiating the samples from the six regions.
  • The sensory attributes sweet, fruity, green, waxy, and floral were found to be most significant to the flavor profile.
  • Specific compounds like 1-Nonanol, 2-Nonanone, Nonanoic acid, ethyl ester, 1-Undecanol, 2-Undecanone, Octanoic acid, ethyl ester, 2H-Pyran, and tetrahydro-4-methyl-2-(2-methyl-1-propenyl)- were identified as primary contributors to regional aroma differences.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the limited number of samples (six regions, three fruiting bodies per region) may not fully capture the entire spectrum of volatile flavor characteristics of T. matsutake in China. They suggest that future research should expand the sample range to include more regions and varieties of Matsutake mushrooms to enhance the representativeness and accuracy of the findings. This would further solidify the theoretical and practical foundation for understanding the flavors of this precious edible fungus.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two-dimensional gas chromatography-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (GC × GC-TOF MS) was employed to analyze the volatile flavor compounds (VOCs) of <i>Tricholoma matsutake</i> samples from six different geographical regions: CX (Chuxiong), DL (Dali), DQ (Diqing), JL (Yanji), SC (Xiaojin) and XZ (Linzhi). The result indicate that a total of 2730 kinds of VOCs were identified from the fruiting bodies of six <i>T. matsutake</i> samples. The primary types of volatile organic compounds identified were 349 alcohols, 92 aldehydes, 146 carboxylic_acids, 311 esters, 742 organoheterocyclic compounds, 630 hydrocarbons, 381 ketones, 51 organic acids, and 28 derivatives and organosulfur compounds. Furthermore, PCA and PLS-DA analysis from the GC×GC-ToF-MS showed that samples from different regions could be distinguished by their VOCs. Network analysis revealed that 33 aroma compounds were identified as markers for distinguishing the samples from the six regions. The sensory attributes sweet, fruity, green, waxy, and floral were found to be more significant to the flavor profile of <i>T. matsutake</i>. 1-Nonanol, 2-Nonanone, Nonanoic acid, ethyl ester, 1-Undecanol, 2-Undecanone, Octanoic acid, ethyl ester, 2H-Pyran, and tetrahy-dro-4-methyl-2-(2-methyl-1-propenyl)- primarily contribute to the differences in the aroma characteristics among six <i>T. matsutake</i> samples. The results also provide a theoretical and practical foundation for the flavor compounds of these precious edible fungi in different regions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2025volatile,
  author = {Yingtong Feng and Shaoxiong Liu and Yuan Fang and Jianying Li and Ming Ma and Zhenfu Yang and Lue Shang and Xiang Guo and Hua Rong and Dafeng Sun},
  title = {{Volatile Flavor of Tricholoma matsutake from the Different Regions of China by Using GC×GC-TOF MS}},
  booktitle = {Foods},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/foods14101824},
}
Figure