Abstract
To enhance depth perception and thus data comprehension, additional depth cues are often used in 3D visualizations of complex vascular structures. Accordingly, there is a variety of different approaches described in the literature, ranging from chromadepth color coding over depth of field to glyph-based encodings. Unfortunately, the majority of existing approaches suffers from the same problem. As these cues are directly applied to the geometry's surface, the display of additional information, such as other modalities or derived attributes, associated with a vessel is impaired. To overcome this limitation we propose Void Space Surfaces which utilize the empty space in between vessel branches to communicate depth and their relative positioning. This allows us to enhance the depth perception of vascular structures without interfering with the spatial data and potentially superimposed parameter information. Within this paper we introduce Void Space Surfaces, describe their technical realization, and show their application to various vessel trees. Moreover, we report the outcome of a user study which we have conducted in order to evaluate the perceptual impact of Void Space Surfaces as compared to existing vessel visualization techniques.
Introduction
Understanding the intricate, branching 3D structure of vascular networks is critical for medical tasks such as surgical planning. On standard 2D screens, depth perception is often aided by color-coding techniques like chromadepth, which maps colors to depth (e.g., red for near, blue for far). However, a significant conflict arises when clinicians need to visualize functional parameters—such as wall shear stress or blood pressure—mapped directly onto the vessel surfaces. If the vessel's color channel is already occupied by depth cues, overlaying functional data leads to visual clutter and reduced legibility. This research introduces Void Space Surfaces (VSS) to resolve this conflict by shifting depth cues from the vessels themselves to the empty space between them.
The Void Space Surfaces Approach
The core innovation of VSS is the utilization of the background "void space" as a canvas for depth information. This approach leaves the vessel surfaces neutral or available for functional data mapping while still providing the viewer with strong spatial context.
Technical Realization
The VSS generation involves several key steps:
- Surface Generation: The algorithm extracts 2D silhouettes of the vessels and uses Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW) to interpolate depth values into the empty spaces. This creates a smooth, view-dependent height field in the background.
- Depth Anchoring: To ensure the background height field is perceptually linked to the foreground vessels, Screen Space Ambient Occlusion (SSAO) is applied. This casts realistic shadows from the vessels onto the VSS, "anchoring" the structures together.
- Perceptual Enhancements: Various cues can be applied to the VSS, including pseudo-chromadepth (a simplified red-to-blue scale) and topographic iso-lines. Iso-lines are particularly effective for helping users distinguish between points with very small depth differences.
Evaluation and Results
The authors conducted a within-subject user study with 20 participants and 150 unique stimuli. Participants were asked to judge which of two marked points on a vessel was closer to the camera.
The study found that VSS techniques performed with the same level of accuracy as traditional methods that color the vessels directly. While traditional direct-vessel coloring was slightly faster—likely due to the minor cognitive indirection of looking at the space around a vessel—VSS significantly outperformed neutral 3D renderings without depth cues. Furthermore, the GPU implementation achieves interactive framerates, rendering the VSS in 25 ms to 165 ms depending on scene complexity.
Conclusion
Void Space Surfaces provide a powerful alternative for 3D vascular visualization, effectively decoupling depth cues from the primary data surface. While the technique requires sufficient "void space" to be effective, it offers a clear path forward for multi-modal medical visualizations where both spatial structure and functional attributes must be understood simultaneously. Future work will explore the use of eye-tracking to better understand how users interact with these background cues and investigate the use of the VSS canvas for additional annotations.
Summary updated