Visual experience has opposing influences on the quality of stimulus representation in adult primary visual cortex

Brian B. Jeon, Thomas Fuchs, Steven M. Chase, Sandra J. Kuhlman

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of transient dark exposure (DE) followed by light reintroduction (LRx) on visual processing in adult mice. They found that while DE temporarily reduces the brain's ability to distinguish visual stimuli, it surprisingly stabilizes neural representations and signal correlations. Crucially, these effects are transient, with visual processing returning to its original state after LRx, suggesting DE is a safe treatment for amblyopia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Amblyopia, often called "lazy eye," is a condition where vision doesn't develop properly in one eye, usually due to misalignment or blockage during childhood. While treatments exist, restoring vision in adults is challenging because the visual system becomes less plastic after a critical developmental period. A promising new treatment involves transiently exposing subjects to darkness (DE) followed by light reintroduction (LRx). This is thought to re-engage juvenile-like plasticity, allowing previously deprived visual inputs to gain cortical territory. However, a key question remained: could this dark exposure itself negatively impact the existing visual processing in the non-deprived eye? This paper addresses this by examining how DE affects the representation of visual stimuli in the adult primary visual cortex (V1).

Methods

The researchers used two-photon calcium imaging in awake, head-fixed adult mice to record neural activity in V1. This technique allows for longitudinal tracking of individual neurons. They imaged neural activity before DE, immediately after 8 days of DE, and after 8 days of LRx.

To assess visual processing, they employed several methods:

  • Tuning stability analysis: They fitted a two-dimensional Gaussian model to neural responses to grating stimuli of various orientations and spatial frequencies to measure how stable a neuron's preferred stimulus was over time.
  • Neural discriminability: They used k-nearest neighbor (KNN) classifiers to determine how well the activity patterns of V1 neurons could distinguish between different visual stimuli. This was done using "fixed classifiers" to measure representational drift.
  • Response reliability: They quantified the consistency of neural responses to the same stimulus across different trials.
  • Signal correlation: They calculated the Pearson correlation between the responses of pairs of neurons to assess how their activity co-varied.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from six adult mice. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the researchers collected novel neural activity data from these mice under controlled experimental conditions (baseline, dark exposure, and light reintroduction).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Darkness as a Stabilizer, Not a Disruptor: Counterintuitively, dark exposure, which might be expected to degrade visual processing, actually stabilized orientation preference and signal correlations in V1 neurons. This suggests that continuous natural vision might have a subtly disrupting influence on the stability of simple stimulus representations.
  • Transient Nature of Impairment: The temporary dip in neural discriminability after dark exposure highlights that while the system is affected, it's not permanently damaged. The recovery after light reintroduction is a critical finding for therapeutic applications.
  • "Backbone" Hypothesis: The results support the idea of a stable "backbone" of neurons that maintains fundamental visual processing, even when other aspects of representation are temporarily affected by DE. This backbone allows for recovery and integration of new information.
  • Natural Vision's Dual Role: The findings suggest that natural, complex visual experience, while improving discriminability, might also introduce a degree of instability in the representation of simple stimuli compared to a period of darkness.

Key Results

  • Transient Decrease in Discriminability: Classification accuracy, a measure of how well V1 activity represents visual stimuli, decreased by approximately 15% immediately after 8 days of dark exposure. This impairment was observed across both low and high spatial frequencies.
  • Recovery of Discriminability: Within 8 days of light reintroduction (LRx), neural discriminability recovered to pre-dark exposure levels.
  • Stabilization of Orientation Preference: Dark exposure significantly reduced the change in orientation preference of V1 neurons compared to control conditions, indicating increased stability.
  • Stabilization of Signal Correlation: The similarity of signal correlation matrices between pairs of neurons was significantly higher in the dark-exposed condition compared to the control.
  • No Lasting Negative Impact: Fixed classifiers demonstrated that stimulus representation rebounded to its original, pre-deprivation state after LRx, confirming that DE does not permanently disrupt visual processing.
  • No Impact of LRx on Stability: Light reintroduction did not further disrupt tuning stability or signal correlation in neurons that remained tuned after DE.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Simple Stimuli: The study primarily used static grating stimuli. Future work could explore how DE affects the representation of more complex, naturalistic visual scenes.
  • Age and Plasticity: While the study was conducted in adult mice, the degree of plasticity can vary with age. Further investigation into how age influences the response to DE and LRx could be valuable.
  • Mechanisms of Stabilization: The paper speculates that DE's stabilizing effect might be due to the removal of a "disrupting influence" from natural vision, rather than an active homeostatic mechanism. Future research could delve deeper into the underlying molecular and cellular mechanisms responsible for this stabilization.
  • Therapeutic Implications: The authors suggest that DE as a treatment for amblyopia is unlikely to negatively impact existing visual function. Future studies could investigate whether DE transiently enhances the ability of the visual system to integrate newly acquired information, which is crucial for perceptual training.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transient dark exposure, typically 7-10 days in duration, followed by light reintroduction is an emerging treatment for improving the restoration of vision in amblyopic subjects whose occlusion is removed in adulthood. Dark exposure initiates homeostatic mechanisms that together with light-induced changes in cellular signaling pathways result in the re-engagement of juvenile-like plasticity in the adult such that previously deprived inputs can gain cortical territory. It is possible that dark exposure itself degrades visual responses, and this could place constraints on the optimal duration of dark exposure treatment. To determine whether eight days of dark exposure has a lasting negative impact on responses to classic grating stimuli, neural activity was recorded before and after dark exposure in awake head-fixed mice using two-photon calcium imaging. Neural discriminability, assessed using classifiers, was transiently reduced following dark exposure; a decrease in response reliability across a broad range of spatial frequencies likely contributed to the disruption. Both discriminability and reliability recovered. Fixed classifiers were used to demonstrate that stimulus representation rebounded to the original, pre-deprivation state, thus dark exposure did not appear to have a lasting negative impact on visual processing. Unexpectedly, we found that dark exposure significantly stabilized orientation preference and signal correlation. Our results reveal that natural vision exerts a disrupting influence on the stability of stimulus preference for classic grating stimuli and, at the same time, improves neural discriminability for both low and high-spatial frequency stimuli.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jeon2022visual,
  author = {Brian B. Jeon and Thomas Fuchs and Steven M. Chase and Sandra J. Kuhlman},
  title = {{Visual experience has opposing influences on the quality of stimulus representation in adult primary visual cortex}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.80361},
}
Figure