Abstract
This paper presents a novel vision-motion planning framework for autonomous mobile robots that explicitly accounts for both sensor uncertainty and the computational cost of planning. By treating planning as an iterative refinement process, the robot balances the expected quality of a navigation plan against the time required to compute it. The approach utilizes "performance profiles" to predict the benefits of finer-grained search, enabling a form of limited rationality where the robot decides when further "thinking" is no longer cost-effective compared to "moving."
Introduction
Autonomous navigation in uncertain environments requires balancing two conflicting factors: the inherent inaccuracy of vision sensors and the finite computational resources available for planning. Traditional planners often focus solely on execution time, ignoring the "meta-cost" of the planning process itself. In scenarios where a robot must decide between a potentially blocked shortcut (a "gate") and a known-passable detour, spending excessive time calculating the optimal path can be counterproductive if the time saved in execution is less than the time spent planning.
Problem Formulation: Uncertainty and Limited Resources
The core challenge addressed is the trade-off between plan quality and computational overhead.
- Vision Uncertainty: Sensors like stereo cameras provide probabilistic estimates of environmental features. A robot may observe a gate but remain uncertain whether its width exceeds the robot's own width ($W_{robot}$).
- Computational Constraints: Handling uncertainty often involves simulating numerous branching outcomes, which is computationally expensive.
As shown in the figure above, the robot categorizes paths as passable, impassable, or unknown based on the probability distribution of the detected distance between objects relative to its own width.
Methodology
The proposed system employs an iterative refinement strategy to optimize the total cost (planning time + execution time).
AND/OR Tree Representation
Plans are modeled as trees where "OR" nodes represent action choices and "AND" nodes represent possible environmental states (e.g., passable vs. blocked). The robot starts with a simple, feasible baseline—such as taking a known detour—and iteratively expands the tree to explore more complex, potentially more efficient sequences.
Performance Profiles and Meta-Planning
To manage the refinement process, the authors introduce "performance profiles." These mathematical models predict how much the execution cost of a plan will decrease as the granularity of the search increases. The algorithm terminates refinement when the predicted improvement in the plan is outweighed by the computational cost of further search. This adaptive "meta-planning" allows the robot to stop thinking quickly for simple problems while investing more time in complex, high-stakes scenarios.
Experimental Results
The method was evaluated through both simulations and real-world experiments.
- Simulation: Across 40 diverse navigation problems, the adaptive planner outperformed fixed-granularity methods in 66% of cases and remained within 1% of optimal performance in the rest.
- Real-World Validation: A physical robot equipped with stereo vision successfully navigated a hallway by estimating gate passability and deciding on optimal observation points, demonstrating the practical utility of the probabilistic framework.
Conclusion
This research highlights the importance of considering planning costs in autonomous systems. By using performance profiles to guide iterative refinement, robots can achieve a more efficient balance between computation and action. Future work will focus on scaling this approach to complex environments with multiple obstacles and dynamic agents.
Summary updated