Vision-Language Navigation with Continual Learning

Zhiyuan Li, Yanfeng Lv, Ziqin Tu, Di Shang, Hong Qiao

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for Vision-Language Navigation (VLN) agents that enables them to learn new environments incrementally without forgetting past knowledge, a crucial step for real-world deployment. They propose a "Dual-loop Scenario Replay" method inspired by brain memory replay to achieve this continual learning, demonstrating significant improvements in generalization and resistance to catastrophic forgetting.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vision-Language Navigation (VLN) agents are designed to follow natural language instructions to navigate 3D environments. While current VLN research has made strides in improving environmental understanding and decision accuracy, a major hurdle remains: their poor performance in novel, unseen environments. This is largely due to training data limitations; it's impractical and expensive to create datasets encompassing every possible environment. Consequently, agents trained on specific datasets struggle when deployed in new settings, a problem exacerbated by "catastrophic forgetting," where learning new information leads to the erasure of previously acquired knowledge. This paper tackles this challenge by proposing a continual learning (CL) paradigm for VLN, allowing agents to adapt to new environments while retaining what they've already learned.

Methods

The core of this work is the Vision-Language Navigation with Continual Learning (VLNCL) paradigm. To address catastrophic forgetting and enhance generalization, the authors introduce the Dual-loop Scenario Replay (Dual-SR) algorithm. This method is inspired by how the human brain consolidates memories. It features:

  • Inner Loop (Working Memory): This loop focuses on rapid adaptation to new tasks. It uses experience replay, randomly sampling past tasks from a memory buffer to update the agent's parameters. This helps balance new task learning with retaining prior knowledge.
  • Outer Loop (Long-Term Memory): This loop mimics long-term memory formation and consolidation. It employs a meta-learning approach (specifically, inspired by the Reptile algorithm) to update the agent's parameters, aiming to maximize generalization rather than just fitting the current task data. This helps preserve learned knowledge across tasks.
  • Multi-Scenario Memory Buffer: This buffer efficiently organizes and replays task memories, categorized by environment type, facilitating quick adaptation and balancing learning across different scenarios.

The paper also utilizes a structured transformer architecture for the agent's planner, which helps in processing and leveraging the structured representation of the explored environment.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for training and evaluation is the Room-to-Room (R2R) dataset. The authors adapt this dataset by splitting it into multiple "task domains," where each domain represents tasks within a specific scene. This allows them to simulate the sequential learning of new environments. They also introduce novel evaluation metrics: Unseen Transfer (UT) for generalization to new scenes and Seen Transfer (ST) for assessing continual learning performance on previously seen scenes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Brain-Inspired Continual Learning: The Dual-SR method's inspiration from human memory replay is a key insight, suggesting that biological mechanisms can offer effective solutions to AI challenges like catastrophic forgetting.
  • Balancing Stability and Plasticity: The dual-loop structure elegantly addresses the fundamental trade-off in continual learning: the need to remain stable (retain old knowledge) while being plastic (learn new information).
  • Importance of Memory Organization: The multi-scenario memory buffer highlights that simply storing past experiences isn't enough; organizing them effectively is crucial for efficient retrieval and adaptation.
  • VLNCL as a New Benchmark: The paper establishes VLNCL as a distinct research area, proposing new metrics and experimental setups that pave the way for more robust and adaptable VLN agents.

Key Results

The proposed Dual-SR method demonstrates significant improvements:

  • A 16% increase in success rate and an 8% increase in oracle success rate compared to the base agent (before continual learning).
  • The agent shows strong resistance to forgetting, with only a small drop in performance (around 20%) after processing 50 different scenario tasks.
  • It exhibits robust knowledge transfer capabilities, consistently improving performance on unseen tasks.
  • The paper claims state-of-the-art performance in continual learning ability for VLN agents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their approach significantly improves performance, integrating more advanced inference architectures with the CL approach could further enhance agent performance. They suggest that future work should focus on developing more sophisticated inference mechanisms and advancing continual learning strategies to achieve even better generalization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Vision-language navigation (VLN) is a critical domain within embedded intelligence, requiring agents to navigate 3D environments based on natural language instructions. Traditional VLN research has focused on improving environmental understanding and decision accuracy. However, these approaches often exhibit a significant performance gap when agents are deployed in novel environments, mainly due to the limited diversity of training data. Expanding datasets to cover a broader range of environments is impractical and costly. We propose the Vision-Language Navigation with Continual Learning (VLNCL) paradigm to address this challenge. In this paradigm, agents incrementally learn new environments while retaining previously acquired knowledge. VLNCL enables agents to maintain an environmental memory and extract relevant knowledge, allowing rapid adaptation to new environments while preserving existing information. We introduce a novel dual-loop scenario replay method (Dual-SR) inspired by brain memory replay mechanisms integrated with VLN agents. This method facilitates consolidating past experiences and enhances generalization across new tasks. By utilizing a multi-scenario memory buffer, the agent efficiently organizes and replays task memories, thereby bolstering its ability to adapt quickly to new environments and mitigating catastrophic forgetting. Our work pioneers continual learning in VLN agents, introducing a novel experimental setup and evaluation metrics. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach through extensive evaluations and establish a benchmark for the VLNCL paradigm. Comparative experiments with existing continual learning and VLN methods show significant improvements, achieving state-of-the-art performance in continual learning ability and highlighting the potential of our approach in enabling rapid adaptation while preserving prior knowledge.
BibTeX
@misc{li2024vision,
  author = {Zhiyuan Li and Yanfeng Lv and Ziqin Tu and Di Shang and Hong Qiao},
  title = {{Vision-Language Navigation with Continual Learning}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2409.02561},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.02561},
}
Figure