Viscosity and viscosity anomalies of model silicates and magmas: A numerical investigation

Mathieu Bauchy, B. Guillot, M. Micoulaut, Nicolas Sator

This research paper, titled "Viscosity and viscosity anomalies of model silicates and magmas: a numerical investigation," explores the complex transport properties of molten rocks (silicates) under extreme conditions. By using molecular dynamics simulations, the authors delve into why some magmas behave "anomalously"—such as becoming less viscous when under higher pressure—and test the fundamental physics equations we use to describe these liquids.

TL;DR

Researchers used molecular dynamics to simulate how pressure and temperature change the flow of sodium disilicate and basaltic melts. They found that while simple models can predict viscosity for thick, "slow" liquids, the relationship breaks down in hotter, more fluid magmas, and that atomic-level structural changes (like silicon coordination) drive complex viscosity "anomalies."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In Earth Sciences, understanding the viscosity of magmatic liquids is vital for modeling everything from volcanic eruptions to the cooling of the early Earth’s magma ocean. However, silicates are "weird" liquids. While most fluids become more viscous (thicker) under pressure, certain silicate melts show a viscosity minimum—they actually get thinner before getting thicker again.

Experimental data at the extreme pressures and temperatures of the Earth's mantle is incredibly difficult to obtain. This paper uses computer simulations to bridge the gap between the microscopic atomic structure and the macroscopic flow properties, specifically looking for the structural "smoking gun" behind these viscosity anomalies.

Methods

The authors employed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations using the DL_POLY 2.0 code.

  • Systems Studied: They modeled two distinct liquids: a simple binary sodium disilicate (NS2) and a complex, nine-component mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB).
  • Formalism: To calculate viscosity from equilibrium simulations, they used the Green-Kubo (GK) formalism, which involves integrating the "stress auto-correlation function"—essentially measuring how long the system "remembers" a mechanical stress.
  • Potentials: They used two-body Born-Majer type potentials to describe the forces between atoms.
  • Analysis: They tracked the Mean Square Displacement (MSD) of atoms to calculate diffusion coefficients and analyzed the Coordination Number (how many neighbors each silicon atom has) to link structure to dynamics.

Datasets

The study did not use external "big data" sets but rather generated its own data through high-performance computing:

  • NS2 Model: 3,000 atoms (666 Si, 666 Na, 1668 O).
  • MORB Model: 3,000 atoms representing a complex mix of Si, Ti, Al, Fe, Mg, Ca, Na, K, and O.
  • Validation: The results were compared against classic experimental datasets, such as those from Bockris et al. (1955) for NS2 and Villeneuve et al. (2008) for basalt.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Eyring Equation's Limits: The Eyring equation relates viscosity ($\eta$) to the diffusion coefficient ($D$). The authors found this holds up well in high-viscosity melts (where the liquid is "slow"). However, in low-viscosity, high-temperature melts, the calculated "jump distance" ($\lambda$) becomes physically unrealistic (up to 22 Å), suggesting the equation fails in these regimes.
  • Structural Drivers: The viscosity minimum in NS2 (occurring between 4–10 GPa) is closely tied to silicon atoms changing their coordination from 4-fold (tetrahedral) to 5- and 6-fold. However, the viscosity minimum doesn't perfectly align with the diffusivity maximum, indicating that "network-modifying" ions like Sodium also play a significant role in the flow.
  • Basalt vs. Simple Silicates: Unlike the simple NS2, the complex MORB liquid shows a viscosity plateau up to 5 GPa before steadily increasing. This highlights that multicomponent magmas are more resistant to "anomalous" thinning than simpler laboratory silicates.
  • High-Temperature Convergence: The simulations suggest that at extremely high temperatures (near the critical point), all silicate melts converge toward a common "universal" viscosity limit of approximately $10^{-3}$ to $10^{-2}$ Poise.

Key Results

  • Viscosity Minimum: For NS2 at 2000K, the simulation successfully reproduced a viscosity minimum in the 4–10 GPa range.
  • Diffusion Maxima: Network-forming ions (Si, O) in NS2 showed a clear diffusivity maximum at ~15 GPa.
  • Quantitative Accuracy: The simulated viscosity for NS2 was within a factor of 2 of experimental data. For MORB, the simulation was about 50 times less viscous than reality at 1673K, illustrating how sensitive viscosity is to the specific mathematical "potentials" used to describe atomic bonds.
  • Activation Energy: The calculated activation energy for viscous flow in NS2 was ~1.33 eV, comparing favorably to experimental values (~1.65 eV).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Potential Sensitivity: The discrepancy in the MORB viscosity results shows that current interatomic potentials still struggle to perfectly capture the dynamics of complex, multicomponent magmas.
  • Timescale Constraints: MD simulations are limited to nanosecond timescales. This means they can only investigate relatively "runny" liquids ($\eta < 10$ Pa·s). Probing the "glassy" or highly viscous regime remains a massive computational challenge.
  • Thermodynamic Link: While the authors explored configurational entropy, they noted that establishing a firm, quantitative relationship between thermodynamics, structure, and dynamics remains "deceptive" and requires further investigation into order parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present results for transport properties (diffusion and viscosity) using computer simulations. Focus is made on a densified binary sodium disilicate 2SiO$_2$-Na$_2$O (NS2) liquid and on multicomponent magmatic liquids (MORB, basalt). In the NS2 liquid, results show that a certain number of anomalies appear when the system is densified: the usual diffusivity maxima/minima is found for the network-forming ions (Si,O) whereas the sodium atom displays three distinct régimes for diffusion. Some of these features can be correlated with the obtained viscosity anomaly under pressure, the latter being be fairly well reproduced from the simulated diffusion constant. In model magmas (MORB liquid), we find a plateau followed by a continuous increase of the viscosity with pressure. Finally, having computed both diffusion and viscosity independently, we can discuss the validity of the Eyring equation for viscosity which relates diffusion and viscosity. It is shown that it can be considered as valid in melts with a high viscosity. On the overall, these results highlight the difficulty of establishing a firm relationship between dynamics, structure and thermodynamics in complex liquids.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bauchy2012viscosity,
  author = {Mathieu Bauchy and B. Guillot and M. Micoulaut and Nicolas Sator},
  title = {{Viscosity and viscosity anomalies of model silicates and magmas: A numerical investigation}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1016/j.chemgeo.2012.08.035},
}

Loading related content...

Figure