Abstract
The admissible modules for $\hat{sl}_2$ are studied from the point of view of vertex operator algebra. If $l$ is rational such that $l+2={p\over q}$ for some coprime positive integers $p\ge 2$ and $q$, Kac and Wakimoto found finitely many distinguished irreducible representations for $\hat{sl}_2$, called admissible representations. In this paper we prove that the vertex operator algebra $L(l,0)$ associated to irreducible highest weight representation of $l$ is not rational if $l$ is not a positive integer. However if we change the Virasoro algebra in certain way, $L(l,0)$ becomes a rational vertex operator algebra whose irreducible representations are exactly those admissible representations. We show that the $q$-dimensions with respect to the new Virasoro algebra are modular functions. We also calculate the fusions rules.
Introduction
In the mathematical framework of conformal field theory (CFT), Vertex Operator Algebras (VOAs) serve as the rigorous foundation for understanding the symmetries of physical models. A central property in this field is "rationality." When a VOA is rational, its representation theory is well-behaved: it possesses a finite number of irreducible modules, every module is completely reducible (semisimple), and the characters of these modules exhibit modular invariance.
For the affine Lie algebra $\hat{sl}_2$, rationality is well-established when the level $l$ is a positive integer. However, in many physical applications—particularly non-unitary models—the level $l$ is a rational number. Specifically, Kac and Wakimoto identified a class of "admissible levels" where $l + 2 = p/q$. While these levels are physically significant, they traditionally fail the mathematical criteria for rationality. This paper addresses this discrepancy by redefining the grading of the VOA, effectively bridging the gap between the physical importance of admissible representations and the formal requirements of VOA theory.
The Problem of Admissible Levels
At non-integer admissible levels, the standard VOA framework for $L(l, 0)$ encounters significant hurdles. The weight spaces of the representations become infinite-dimensional under the standard Virasoro grading, and the standard characters do not converge or transform as modular forms. Consequently, the VOA is not rational in the traditional sense. This lack of rationality has historically prevented a full categorical treatment of these algebras, despite their known relevance to string theory and non-unitary CFTs.
Methodology: Redefining the Virasoro Algebra
The primary innovation of this work is the modification of the underlying Virasoro algebra. The authors introduce a new Virasoro vector:
$$\omega_z = \omega + \frac{1}{2}zh(-2)\mathbf{1}$$
This shift effectively changes the "internal clock" or grading of the algebra. By moving from a standard integer grading ($\mathbb{Z}$) to a rational grading ($\mathbb{Q}$), the infinite-dimensional subspaces associated with the standard grading are redistributed into finite-dimensional ones.
To analyze this new structure, the authors extend Zhu’s $A(V)$-theory to accommodate $\mathbb{Q}$-graded VOAs. This extension allows for a one-to-one correspondence between VOA modules and the modules of a simpler associative algebra. Furthermore, the authors utilize Malikov-Feigin-Fuchs (MFF) singular vector expressions and Fuchs’ projection formulas to calculate fusion rules—the rules governing how representations "multiply" or interact.
Key Results
Rationality and Semisimplicity
The most significant result is Theorem 3.14, which formally proves that the $\mathbb{Q}$-graded VOA $(L(l, 0), \omega_z)$ is rational. Under this new grading, the category of modules is semisimple, and the irreducible modules are precisely the admissible weights $j$ identified by Kac and Wakimoto. This restores the structural elegance typically reserved for integer-level VOAs.
Fusion Rules and $C_2$-Finiteness
The authors provide an explicit formula for the fusion rules $L(l, j_1) \times L(l, j_2)$ in Theorem 4.7. Notably, for integer levels, this formula simplifies to the well-known Verlinde formula, demonstrating consistency with established theory. Additionally, Theorem 4.10 proves that the modified VOA satisfies the $C_2$-finiteness condition. This technical milestone is crucial, as $C_2$-finiteness is a prerequisite for many advanced properties in VOA theory, including the convergence of characters.
Modular Functions
The paper demonstrates that the modified characters, defined as $tr_{L(l,j)} q^{L_z(0) - c_{l,z}/24}$, are convergent in the upper half-plane. These characters transform predictably under modular transformations. The central charge $c_{l,z}$ of the modified Virasoro algebra serves as the "modular anomaly," providing a natural mathematical interpretation for terms that previously appeared as corrective factors in physical models.
Conclusion and Future Work
By shifting the grading of $\hat{sl}_2$ at admissible levels, this research successfully incorporates a vital class of representations into the framework of rational VOAs. This work confirms that the "non-rationality" previously observed was largely a consequence of the chosen grading rather than an inherent flaw in the representations themselves.
While this paper provides a robust foundation, several avenues for future research remain. The authors note that a full proof of modular invariance for the space spanned by these new characters (under the transformation $\tau \to -1/\tau$ with $z$ fixed) is a work in progress. Furthermore, while the methods used here for $\hat{sl}_2$ are likely generalizable to other affine Lie algebras like $\hat{sl}_n$, the specific singular vector calculations and grading shifts must be derived for higher ranks. Finally, the direct mapping of these $\mathbb{Q}$-graded structures to specific non-unitary string theory models continues to be a fertile ground for interdisciplinary exploration.
Summary updated