Variational Barycentric Coordinates

Ana Dodik, Oded Stein, Vincent Sitzmann, Justin Solomon

TL;DR

This paper introduces Variational Barycentric Coordinates (VBCs), a novel neural network-based framework for computing generalized barycentric coordinates. VBCs offer unprecedented flexibility by allowing users to optimize for custom objective functions, leading to more controllable and aesthetically pleasing mesh deformations and interpolations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Generalized barycentric coordinates are fundamental in computer graphics for tasks like interpolating data across a mesh's interior or deforming complex shapes using a simpler "cage" structure. Traditional methods for computing these coordinates are often rigid, offering limited control over the resulting interpolations or deformations. They typically rely on fixed closed-form solutions or mesh-based discretizations, which restrict the types of objective functions that can be optimized. This lack of flexibility can lead to undesirable "rubbery" deformations or unnatural interpolations, especially when dealing with complex geometries or specific artistic requirements. The authors aim to bridge this gap by providing a flexible, neural-network-based approach that allows for optimization-driven barycentric coordinate generation.

Methods

The core of the VBC framework lies in representing barycentric coordinates as a neural field. Instead of relying on traditional mesh-based methods, VBCs decompose the problem into a convex combination of simplex (triangle/tetrahedron) barycentric coordinates. A neural network then learns to predict the weights for these simplex coordinates for any given point within the cage.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Neural Field Parameterization: A neural network acts as a continuous function that maps interior points to a distribution over simplex barycentric coordinates. This allows for a mesh-free representation and avoids the limitations of discrete meshes.
  • Theoretical Characterization: The authors provide a theoretical foundation showing that any valid barycentric coordinate function can be represented as a convex combination of simplex barycentric coordinates. This underpins the neural network's ability to learn the entire space of valid coordinates.
  • Optimization Flexibility: The framework is designed to be compatible with various objective functions. This includes standard smoothness energies like Total Variation (TV) and Dirichlet energy, as well as deformation-aware energies like As-Rigid-As-Possible (ARAP).
  • Handling Discontinuities: A novel approach is presented to approximate and optimize energies like TV on discontinuous neural fields by using mollification techniques to smooth out discontinuities.
  • Pruning Heuristic: To manage the computational complexity arising from a large number of potential simplices, a pruning strategy is introduced that removes redundant or non-local simplices, significantly reducing the number of parameters and improving efficiency.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses various 2D and 3D meshes (e.g., GECKO, HORSE, ELEPHANT, BUST OF SAPPHO, HAND, PANDA, ARMADILLO, HUMAN) for training and evaluation. These meshes are scaled to unit size for consistent parameter application.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Neural Fields as a Universal Barycentric Coordinate Representation: The paper demonstrates that neural fields are a powerful tool for representing the complex function space of barycentric coordinates, offering a flexible alternative to traditional methods.
  • Deformation-Aware Optimization: By allowing optimization with deformation-aware energies like ARAP, VBCs can produce significantly more natural and less "rubbery" deformations compared to purely smoothness-driven approaches. This is a crucial insight for applications requiring realistic motion.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The work successfully connects the theoretical properties of barycentric coordinates with a practical, implementable neural network architecture, making advanced geometry processing techniques more accessible.
  • Efficiency through Pruning: The proposed pruning heuristic is vital for making the neural field approach computationally tractable for complex cages, demonstrating that intelligent simplification can maintain representational power.

Key Results

  • Qualitative Improvements: VBCs produce visually smoother and more natural-looking interpolations and deformations, as shown in figures comparing their results to previous methods.
  • Quantitative Error Reduction: In inverse deformation problems (e.g., matching a soft-body simulation), jointly optimizing cage vertices and VBC weights reduced approximation error by up to two-thirds compared to optimizing cage vertices alone.
  • Efficiency Gains: The pruning strategy significantly reduces the number of simplices used, leading to practical training and inference times, as detailed in Table 2. For instance, the number of used simplices is drastically lower than the total possible simplices.
  • Flexibility Demonstrated: The paper showcases the ability to achieve different visual styles (e.g., more localized vs. smoother influence) by simply changing the optimization objective (e.g., TV vs. Dirichlet energy).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitation of Pruning: The current pruning heuristic limits coordinates to "star-shaped" neighborhoods around cage vertices. This can lead to issues when a cage bends into a concavity. The authors suggest exploring geodesic distances for pruning, though this would sacrifice the grid-free nature of the method.
  • Surface vs. Volumetric Deformation: Current deformation-aware energies are primarily surface-based. Future work could explore volumetric deformation energies for more comprehensive control.
  • Inverse Problems with Sparse Correspondences: The current inverse deformation framework relies on dense correspondences. Future research could investigate solving these problems with sparser correspondences.
  • Amortizing Physics Simulations: The authors suggest amortizing physics simulations over datasets to create class-specific coordinates, which could significantly speed up complex simulations.
  • Performance Optimization: Further improvements in performance are possible through stochastic finite-difference estimators and acceleration data structures for simplex searching. The authors also note that their current hardware limitations prevented them from fully exploiting the capabilities of their chosen neural network library.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a variational technique to optimize for generalized barycentric coordinates that offers additional control compared to existing models. Prior work represents barycentric coordinates using meshes or closed-form formulae, in practice limiting the choice of objective function. In contrast, we directly parameterize the continuous function that maps any coordinate in a polytope's interior to its barycentric coordinates using a neural field. This formulation is enabled by our theoretical characterization of barycentric coordinates, which allows us to construct neural fields that parameterize the entire function class of valid coordinates. We demonstrate the flexibility of our model using a variety of objective functions, including multiple smoothness and deformation-aware energies; as a side contribution, we also present mathematically-justified means of measuring and minimizing objectives like total variation on discontinuous neural fields. We offer a practical acceleration strategy, present a thorough validation of our algorithm, and demonstrate several applications.
BibTeX
@article{dodik2023variational,
  author = {Ana Dodik and Oded Stein and Vincent Sitzmann and Justin Solomon},
  title = {{Variational Barycentric Coordinates}},
  journal = {ACM Trans. Graphics},
  year = {2023},
}

Loading related content...

Figure