Variant Landscape of 15 Genes Involved in Corneal Dystrophies: Report of 30 Families and Comprehensive Analysis of the Literature

Di Zhu, Junwen Wang, Yingwei Wang, Yi Jiang, Shiqiang Li, Xueshan Xiao, Panfeng Wang, Qingjiong ZhangInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps the genetic variations associated with corneal dystrophies (CDs) across 15 key genes, analyzing a cohort of Chinese families and a vast literature dataset. It identifies 17 pathogenic variants in four genes (TGFBI, CHST6, SLC4A11, ZEB1) within their cohort and highlights the critical issue of misinterpreting benign variants as pathogenic, which can mislead clinical genetic testing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Corneal dystrophies (CDs) are a group of rare, inherited eye diseases characterized by the abnormal buildup of material in the cornea, leading to progressive vision loss. While over 15 genes are known to be involved, understanding the full spectrum of genetic variations and their clinical significance, especially in diverse populations, remains a challenge. A particular problem is the misclassification of genetic variants, where benign or likely benign variants are mistakenly identified as disease-causing. This can lead to incorrect diagnoses, genetic counseling, and potentially ineffective treatments, especially as genomic medicine becomes more widespread.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Exome Sequencing: Genomic DNA from 37 families with CDs was analyzed using exome sequencing to identify genetic variants.
  • Bioinformatic Filtering: A multi-step bioinformatics pipeline was used to filter and prioritize potential pathogenic variants.
  • Sanger Sequencing: Candidate variants were confirmed using Sanger sequencing for validation.
  • Literature and Database Analysis: A comprehensive analysis was conducted using published literature, the HGMD database, and the gnomAD database to compare their findings with existing knowledge. This included re-evaluating reported variants for their pathogenicity.
  • ACMG/AMP Classification: Variants were classified according to the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) and the Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) guidelines.
  • Clinical Data Integration: Clinical information from patients was collected and analyzed to establish genotype-phenotype correlations.

Datasets

  • In-house Cohort: Genomic DNA from 37 families with corneal dystrophies (CDs) from a Chinese cohort.
  • Literature Data: A comprehensive collection of 586 variants reported in 2933 families with CDs from published literature.
  • HGMD Database: Human Gene Mutation Database was used to gather information on known gene variants.
  • gnomAD Database: Genome Aggregation Database was utilized to assess the frequency of variants in the general population.
  • In-house Exome Data: Data from 10,530 unrelated families with various eye conditions was used for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dominance of Key Genes: The study reinforces that a few genes, particularly TGFBI, are overwhelmingly responsible for a large proportion of corneal dystrophies, even within a specific ethnic group.
  • The Peril of Misinterpreted Variants: A significant finding is the identification of variants previously reported as pathogenic that are likely benign or benign. This highlights a critical flaw in current variant interpretation practices and underscores the need for rigorous re-evaluation.
  • Population-Specific Patterns: While some genes show consistent prevalence across ethnicities, others exhibit distinct ethnic distributions (e.g., TGFBI, CHST6, SLC4A11 more common in Asians; ZEB1, UBIAD1, OVOL2 more common in Caucasians).
  • The Importance of Allele Frequency: The study emphasizes using allele frequency in large population databases like gnomAD as a crucial filter to identify potentially misclassified variants. Variants with higher-than-expected frequencies in the general population are suspect.
  • Genotype-Phenotype Nuances: The research provides detailed clinical information, linking specific variants to particular CD subtypes and even co-occurring conditions like high myopia and glaucoma.

Key Results

  • Cohort Findings: In their cohort of 37 families, 17 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were identified in 30 families, affecting four genes: TGFBI (21 families), CHST6 (6 families), SLC4A11 (2 families), and ZEB1 (1 family). Four novel variants were also discovered.
  • Literature Analysis: Across 2933 reported families, TGFBI was the most implicated gene (62.82%), followed by CHST6 (16.64%) and SLC4A11 (6.93%).
  • Misinterpreted Variants: The study identified 12 variants from 61 families that were likely benign or benign, failing to meet the criteria for pathogenic variants based on allele frequency and ACMG/AMP guidelines. A notable example is TGFBI c.1501C>A, p.(Pro501Thr).
  • Ethnic Distribution: TGFBI, CHST6, and SLC4A11 were predominantly found in Asian subjects, while ZEB1, UBIAD1, and OVOL2 were more common in Caucasian subjects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the absence of variants in some of the 15 genes in their cohort might be due to the relatively small sample size and the rarity of variants in those genes.
  • The classification of variants in TGFBI can be challenging due to the difficulty in differentiating between pathogenic and non-pathogenic variants using in silico tools alone.
  • The study notes that about half of reported CDs might be polygenic, meaning their analysis focused on monogenic causes.
  • Future Work:
    • Further research is needed to clarify the pathogenicity of variants in genes with relatively rare reports.
  • More studies are required to fully elucidate the mechanisms behind the concentration of pathogenic variants in specific "hot spots" within genes like TGFBI.
  • The authors emphasize the need for rigorous application of ACMG/AMP standards and guidelines to reduce the misinterpretation of variants.
  • Comparative analysis of large datasets is crucial for identifying and correcting misinterpreted variants.

Summary updated

Abstract

Corneal dystrophies (CDs) represent a group of inherited diseases characterized by the progressive deposit of abnormal materials in the cornea. This study aimed to describe the variant landscape of 15 genes responsible for CDs based on a cohort of Chinese families and a comparative analysis of literature reports. Families with CDs were recruited from our eye clinic. Their genomic DNA was analyzed using exome sequencing. The detected variants were filtered using multi-step bioinformatics and confirmed using Sanger sequencing. Previously reported variants in the literature were summarized and evaluated based on the gnomAD database and in-house exome data. In 30 of 37 families with CDs, 17 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were detected in 4 of the 15 genes, including <i>TGFBI</i>, <i>CHST6</i>, <i>SLC4A11</i>, and <i>ZEB1</i>. A comparative analysis of large datasets revealed that 12 of the 586 reported variants are unlikely causative of CDs in monogenic mode, accounting for 61 of 2933 families in the literature. Of the 15 genes, the gene most frequently implicated in CDs was <i>TGFBI</i> (1823/2902, 62.82% of families), followed by <i>CHST6</i> (483/2902, 16.64%) and <i>SLC4A11</i> (201/2902, 6.93%). This study presents, for the first time, the landscape of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants in the 15 genes responsible for CDs. Awareness of frequently misinterpreted variants, such as c.1501C>A, p.(Pro501Thr) in <i>TGFBI</i>, is crucial in the era of genomic medicine.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2023variant,
  author = {Di Zhu and Junwen Wang and Yingwei Wang and Yi Jiang and Shiqiang Li and Xueshan Xiao and Panfeng Wang and Qingjiong Zhang},
  title = {{Variant Landscape of 15 Genes Involved in Corneal Dystrophies: Report of 30 Families and Comprehensive Analysis of the Literature}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms24055012},
}
Figure