Variable resolution discretization for high-accuracy solutions of optimal control problems

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel variable resolution discretization technique for solving continuous-state optimal control problems. By adaptively refining the state space based on local and global criteria, it achieves near-optimal policies with significantly fewer states than uniform discretization methods, offering a more efficient approach to complex control tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solving optimal control problems in continuous state spaces is computationally challenging. Traditional methods often resort to uniform discretization, where the entire state space is divided into equally sized cells. While this approach guarantees convergence, it becomes computationally intractable as the state space grows, requiring an enormous number of cells to achieve sufficient accuracy. This paper tackles the problem of efficiently finding high-accuracy, near-optimal policies for deterministic continuous-state control problems by developing a variable resolution discretization strategy. Instead of uniformly dividing the space, it intelligently refines only the critical regions, leading to a more parsimonious and computationally feasible solution.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in its adaptive discretization strategy, which builds upon a kd-tree structure to represent the state space. The process starts with a coarse grid and iteratively refines it using a splitting criterion. The paper explores several criteria:

  • Local Splitting Criteria:
    • Average Corner-Value Difference: Splits cells where the average value at the corners differs significantly across an axis.
  • Value Non-linearity: Splits cells based on the variance of the value function's increase at the corners, aiming to capture non-linear behavior.
  • Policy Disagreement: Splits cells where the optimal control derived from the discretized Markov Decision Process (MDP) differs from the control suggested by the gradient of the value function. This focuses refinement on areas where the optimal policy changes.
  • Global Splitting Criterion (Stdev_Inf): This novel criterion combines two measures:
  • Variance ($\sigma^2(\xi)$): Estimates the uncertainty in the value function approximation due to discretization. High variance indicates areas where refinement is likely to improve accuracy.
  • Influence ($I(\xi|\Omega)$): Measures how much a state $\xi$ contributes to the value function of a set of states $\Omega$ (specifically, states of policy disagreement). This helps identify states whose value function significantly impacts critical regions of the state space.

    The Stdev_Inf criterion splits cells with high values of $\sigma(\xi) \cdot I(\xi|\Omega)$, effectively prioritizing refinement in areas that are both uncertain in their value function approximation and influential on critical policy regions.

The discretization process converts the continuous control problem into a discrete Markov Decision Process (MDP). The value function is approximated using barycentric interpolators within the triangulated cells.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its methods on several benchmark problems:

  • Car on the Hill: A 2D continuous-state problem.
  • Cart-Pole: A 4D continuous-state problem.
  • Acrobot: A 4D continuous-state problem.

These are standard benchmarks in reinforcement learning and optimal control. The paper does not introduce new datasets but uses these existing ones to demonstrate the effectiveness of its variable resolution approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptive Refinement is Crucial: Uniform discretization is often inefficient. Focusing computational resources on critical areas of the state space (where the value function or policy changes significantly) leads to much better performance with fewer states.
  • Policy Matters as Much as Value: While value-based criteria are useful, focusing on areas where the optimal policy changes (policy disagreement) is essential for achieving accurate control, even if the value function itself is smooth in those regions.
  • Global View Enhances Local Decisions: The Stdev_Inf criterion, by considering both the uncertainty in value approximation (variance) and the impact on critical policy regions (influence), provides a powerful heuristic for guiding refinement. This global perspective helps avoid wasting resources on refining irrelevant or already well-approximated areas.
  • Trade-off Between States and Optimality: The paper clearly demonstrates that variable resolution methods achieve near-optimal performance with significantly fewer states compared to uniform grids, highlighting a favorable trade-off.

Key Results

  • Variable resolution grids, particularly those using the Stdev_Inf criterion, significantly outperform uniform grids in terms of performance (closeness to optimality) for a given number of states.
  • For example, on the "Car on the Hill" problem, variable resolution grids needed approximately four times fewer states than uniform grids to achieve an almost optimal performance of 80%.
  • The Stdev_Inf criterion consistently performed very well across the tested problems (Car on the Hill, Cart-Pole, Acrobot), often outperforming local criteria and uniform grids.
  • Local criteria (value non-linearity, policy disagreement) sometimes struggled on problems with discontinuities or narrow goal regions (like Cart-Pole), indicating the importance of the global perspective offered by Stdev_Inf.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local Criteria Limitations: The paper acknowledges that purely local splitting criteria can sometimes lead to suboptimal performance or inefficient resource allocation, especially in higher dimensions or problems with complex state-space structures (e.g., Cart-Pole).
  • Future Work:
    • Pruning: The authors plan to investigate pruning techniques to group areas that have been over-refined, further optimizing the resolution.
  • "Specific towards General" Grouping: Exploring methods to group refined areas back into more general representations.
  • Continuous Stochastic Systems: Extending the approach to handle continuous stochastic systems, such as those found in production scheduling.
  • Empirical Performance Criteria: Mentioning that previous work used empirical performance criteria for tree partitioning, suggesting a potential avenue for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

State abstraction is of central importance in remforcement learning and Markov Decision Processes. This paper studies the case of variable resolution state abstraction for continuous-state, deterministic dynamic control problems in which near-optimal policies are required. We describe variable resolution policy and value function representations based on Kuhn triangulations embedded in a kd-tree. We then consider top-down approaches to choosing which cells to split in order to generate improved policies. We begin with local approaches based on value function properties and policy properties that use only features of individual cells in making splitting choices. Later, by introducing two new non-local measures, influence and variance, we derive a splitting criterion that allows one cell to efficiently take into account its impact on other cells when deciding whether to split. We evaluate the performance of a variety of splitting criteria on many benchmark problems (published on the web), paying careful attention to their number-of-cells versus closeness-to-optimality tradeoff curves.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{1999variable,
  title = {{Variable resolution discretization for high-accuracy solutions of optimal control problems}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1999},
}
Figure