Variability of the NGC 1333 IRAS 4A Outflow: Molecular Hydrogen and Silicon Monoxide Images

Minho Choi, K. W. Hodapp, Masahiko Hayashi, Kentaro Motohara, Soojong Pak, Tae‐Soo PyoThe Astrophysical Journal 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents detailed H2 and SiO images of the NGC 1333 IRAS 4A outflow, revealing a complex, S-shaped structure. The findings strongly suggest that the outflow's driving source axis is undergoing a continuous, clockwise drift, leading to a point-symmetric morphology and explaining the observed deflection by a dense core.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Young stellar objects (YSOs) are known to drive powerful outflows of gas and dust, which play a crucial role in star formation by regulating the accretion of material onto the star and influencing the surrounding interstellar medium. However, the detailed dynamics and evolution of these outflows are complex and not fully understood. Specifically, the IRAS 4A outflow in the NGC 1333 region exhibits an unusual, bent morphology that previous studies could not fully explain. This paper aims to disentangle the various components and variability mechanisms contributing to the observed structure of the IRAS 4A outflow, particularly focusing on the interplay between the outflow's driving source and its interaction with the ambient environment.

Methods

The researchers utilized two primary observational techniques:

  • High-Resolution Imaging: They obtained images of the molecular hydrogen (H2) emission in the 1-0 S(1) line using two different telescopes: the University of Hawaii (UH) 2.2m telescope and the Subaru telescope. These observations provided detailed spatial information about the shocked gas in the outflow.
  • Multi-Tracer Analysis: The H2 images were combined with previously published maps of silicon monoxide (SiO) emission. SiO is a tracer of shocked gas at higher densities and closer to the driving source, offering complementary information to the H2 observations.
  • Astrometric Calibration: Precise alignment of the H2 and SiO images was crucial for comparing their structures. This was achieved by identifying common field stars and using IRAF's geomap and geotran packages to transform the observed images.
  • Morphological Analysis: The position angles (PAs) of emission peaks in both H2 and SiO were plotted against their distance from the driving source. This analysis revealed the bending and curvature of the outflow.
  • Proper Motion Measurement: By comparing images taken at different times (UH and Subaru H2 images), the researchers measured the proper motion of specific H2 features, providing insights into the outflow's velocity and timescale.

Datasets

  • UH 2.2m Telescope H2 Images: Provided a wide-field view of the NGC 1333 region in H2 1-0 S(1) emission.
  • Subaru Telescope H2 Images: Offered higher sensitivity and angular resolution for a smaller field of view.
  • VLA SiO Maps: Previously published maps of SiO v=0 J=1→0 emission, crucial for tracing the outflow closer to the driving source.
  • 2MASS Point Source Catalogue: Used for astrometric calibration of the H2 images.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Axis Drift as the Primary Driver of Symmetry: The most striking finding is the strong evidence for a continuous, clockwise drift of the outflow's driving source axis. This drift naturally explains the observed point-symmetry (S-shape) of the bipolar outflow lobes.
  • Outflow Deflection by a Dense Core: The northeastern outflow lobe shows a significant deflection. The paper argues that this is a consequence of the drifting outflow axis encountering a dense core in the ambient molecular cloud. As the axis drifts, the impact point on the core's "surface" changes, leading to an increasing deflection angle over time.
  • Complementary Nature of H2 and SiO: The H2 images reveal the larger-scale structure of the outflow, while the SiO maps are essential for understanding the outflow's behavior very close to the driving source, where H2 emission is obscured by high extinction.
  • Asymmetric Lateral Intensity Profiles: The SiO outflow exhibits asymmetric intensity profiles (steeper on one side than the other). This asymmetry is interpreted as a consequence of the drifting axis, where the leading (clockwise) side encounters fresher, potentially denser ambient gas, leading to stronger shock and emission.
  • New Outflow Features Identified: The high-sensitivity H2 images revealed several previously undetected or unlabeled emission features, some of which are identified as potential new outflows.

Key Results

  • The IRAS 4A outflow exhibits a clear S-shaped morphology, with the southwestern lobe curving smoothly and the northeastern lobe showing a sharp bend.
  • The point-symmetry between the northeastern and southwestern lobes strongly suggests an intrinsic variability of the driving source, specifically a clockwise axis drift.
  • The axis drift rate is estimated to be approximately 0.011 degrees per year.
  • The deflection of the northeastern outflow is well-explained by the interaction with a dense core, with the impact parameter decreasing as the outflow axis drifts clockwise.
  • The proper motion of some H2 features (HL 5 peaks) suggests an outflow timescale of around 2000 years.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ambiguity in Outflow Driving: While the axis drift model is compelling, the exact mechanism driving this drift (e.g., binary interaction, anisotropic accretion) remains speculative and requires further investigation.
  • Completeness of Outflow Tracing: The paper notes that the SiO map likely traces the entire southern outflow, but the full extent of other outflows identified is not always clear.
  • Characterization of New Features: Several newly identified H2 emission features (labeled CHH) are described, but their driving sources and outflow dynamics require further study.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that observational tests for the anisotropic accretion model could involve determining the rotation axis of the IRAS 4A core. Further studies are also needed to test whether the HH 270/110 system is a similar case of deflected outflow. Detailed kinematic studies of the newly identified features are also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The NGC 1333 region was observed in the H2 1-0 S(1) line. The H2 images cover a 5' x 7' region around IRAS 4. Numerous H2 emission features were detected. The northeast-southwest bipolar outflow driven by IRAS 4A was studied by combining the H2 images with SiO maps published previously. The SiO-H2 outflows are continuous on the southwestern side but show a gap on the northeastern side. The southwestern outflow lobe curves smoothly, and the position angle increases with the distance from the driving source. The base and the outer tip of the northeastern outflow lobe are located at positions opposite to the corresponding parts of the southwestern lobe. This point-symmetry suggests that the outflow axis may be drifting or precessing clockwise in the plane of the sky and that the cause of the axis drift may be intrinsic to the outflow engine. The axis drift model is supported by the asymmetric lateral intensity profile of the SiO outflow. The axis drift rate is about 0.011 deg yr-1. The middle part of the northeastern outflow does not exactly follow the point symmetry because of the superposition of two different kinds of directional variability: the axis drift of the driving source and the deflection by a dense core. The axis drift model provides a good explanation for the large deflection angle of the northeastern outflow. Other H2 emission features around the IRAS 4 region are discussed briefly. Some of them are newly found outflows, and some are associated with outflows already known before.
BibTeX
@article{choi2006variability,
  author = {Minho Choi and K. W. Hodapp and Masahiko Hayashi and Kentaro Motohara and Soojong Pak and Tae‐Soo Pyo},
  title = {{Variability of the NGC 1333 IRAS 4A Outflow: Molecular Hydrogen and Silicon Monoxide Images}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1086/505037},
}
Figure