Value of Assistance for Mobile Agents

Adi Amuzig, David Dovrat, Sarah Keren

Introduction

Autonomous mobile agents often face the challenge of localization uncertainty, which typically compounds as the agent moves through its environment. This phenomenon, known as "localization drift," can significantly impede a robot's ability to complete its mission efficiently or safely. While collaborative systems allow for "helper" agents—such as drones—to assist ground robots by providing precise location data or physical relocation, such assistance is often a limited and costly resource.

To address this, we propose the Value of Assistance (VOA) framework. VOA provides a principled metric to quantify the expected reduction in mission cost that an assistive action would provide at any given point in a robot's execution. By strategically calculating when and where to provide help, multi-robot systems can optimize the allocation of scarce assistive resources.

The VOA Framework

The core of the VOA approach lies in modeling the robot's trajectory and the environmental risks simultaneously.

Uncertainty Modeling

We model the robot’s location over time as a Gaussian Process (GP). As the robot follows a planned path, its location covariance (Σ) grows monotonically, representing the increasing uncertainty of its true position relative to its internal odometry.

Cost-Maps

The environment is represented by a user-defined cost-map (M). Unlike simple obstacle maps, a cost-map assigns a continuous range of values to coordinates. High-cost areas might represent physical hazards or regions with poor sensor coverage, while low-cost areas represent safe, traversable paths.

Defining Value of Assistance

VOA is defined as the difference between the expected cost of completing a path without assistance and the expected cost with assistance. The framework considers two primary forms of assistance:

  1. Relocation: The helper moves the robot directly to its intended waypoint, effectively resetting its uncertainty to zero at that specific coordinate.
  2. Localization: The helper provides the robot with its exact current coordinates. The robot then executes a corrective plan to return to its intended path, accumulating new uncertainty as it continues.

Experimental Validation

The effectiveness of VOA was tested through both large-scale simulations and physical laboratory experiments.

Synthetic Simulations

The authors conducted 3 million simulated scenarios across 100 randomized 100x100 grid cost-maps. These simulations compared the theoretical VOA against the Average Executed Cost Difference (AECD)—the actual observed benefit recorded during execution. The results demonstrated that VOA values were highly predictive of empirical outcomes. Notably, the waypoint identified by VOA as having the highest value was among the top three actual most beneficial intervention points in 92% of cases.

Real-World Lab Experiments

To validate the framework under physical constraints, experiments were conducted using a TurtleBot3 in a lab environment equipped with an OptiTrack motion-capture system. Over 155 real-world runs, the VOA metric successfully accounted for actual robotic hardware noise. In 3,999 out of 4,000 tested cases, the predicted VOA fell within one standard deviation of the empirical results, confirming the model's robustness to real-world sensor noise.

Key Insights

  • Context-Aware Assistance: VOA demonstrates that the "most lost" robot is not always the one most in need of help. A robot with high uncertainty in a safe, low-cost area may have a lower VOA than a robot with low uncertainty that is operating near a high-risk "cliff."
  • Robustness to Misestimation: A critical finding for deployment is that VOA remains a reliable predictor even if the movement noise estimate is off by as much as 25%. This suggests the framework is viable even when precise noise parameters are difficult to calibrate.
  • Strategic Timing: The benefit of assistance is highly sensitive to the specific waypoint where it is delivered. VOA provides a mathematical "sweet spot" for intervention.

Limitations and Future Work

While VOA provides a robust foundation for assistive decision-making, several areas remain for future development. Currently, the model treats the helper as an abstract entity and does not account for the helper's own operational costs, such as drone battery consumption. Additionally, the framework assumes uncertainty always increases; integrating the ability for robots to self-correct using environmental landmarks would expand the model's applicability. Finally, adapting VOA to handle dynamic cost-maps, where risks change in real-time, remains a necessary step for complex, real-world deployments.

By providing a rigorous way to calculate the benefit of intervention, VOA moves multi-robot collaboration from heuristic-based help to strategic, cost-optimized assistance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mobile robotic agents often suffer from localization uncertainty which grows with time and with the agents' movement. This can hinder their ability to accomplish their task. In some settings, it may be possible to perform assistive actions that reduce uncertainty about a robot's location. For example, in a collaborative multi-robot system, a wheeled robot can request assistance from a drone that can fly to its estimated location and reveal its exact location on the map or accompany it to its intended location. Since assistance may be costly and limited, and may be requested by different members of a team, there is a need for principled ways to support the decision of which assistance to provide to an agent and when, as well as to decide which agent to help within a team. For this purpose, we propose Value of Assistance (VOA) to represent the expected cost reduction that assistance will yield at a given point of execution. We offer ways to compute VOA based on estimations of the robot's future uncertainty, modeled as a Gaussian process. We specify conditions under which our VOA measures are valid and empirically demonstrate the ability of our measures to predict the agent's average cost reduction when receiving assistance in both simulated and real-world robotic settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{amuzig2023value,
  author = {Adi Amuzig and David Dovrat and Sarah Keren},
  title = {{Value of Assistance for Mobile Agents}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=PfnZxQfHHF},
}
Figure