Vacuum Circuit Breaker Closing Time Key Moments Detection via Vibration Monitoring: A Run-to-Failure Study

Chi-Ching Hsu, Gaëtan Frusque, Mahir Muratović, Christian M. Franck, Olga Fink

Abstract

Circuit breakers (CBs) play an important role in modern society because they make the power transmission and distribution systems reliable and resilient. Therefore, it is important to maintain their reliability and to monitor their operation. A key to ensure a reliable operation of CBs is to monitor their condition. In this work, we performed an accelerated life testing for mechanical failures of a vacuum circuit breaker (VCB) by performing close-open operations continuously until failure. We recorded data for each operation and made the collected run-to-failure dataset publicly available. In our experiments, the VCB operated more than 26,000 close-open operations without current load with the time span of five months. The run-to-failure long-term monitoring enables us to monitor the evolution of the VCB condition and the degradation over time. To monitor CB condition, closing time is one of the indicators, which is usually measured when the CB is taken out of operation and is completely disconnected from the network. We propose an algorithm that enables to infer the same information on the closing time from a non-intrusive sensor. By utilizing the short-time energy (STE) of the vibration signal, it is possible to identify the key moments when specific events happen including the time when the latch starts to move, and the closing time. The effectiveness of the proposed algorithm is evaluated on the VCB dataset and is also compared to the binary segmentation (BS) change point detection algorithm. This research highlights the potential for continuous online condition monitoring, which is the basis for applying future predictive maintenance strategies.

Introduction

Vacuum Circuit Breakers (VCBs) are critical components of the power grid, protecting systems from catastrophic failures. While highly reliable, they often remain idle for long periods, making their operational health difficult to verify without taking them offline. A primary indicator of VCB health is the "closing time"—the interval between a control signal being sent and the contacts physically touching. Currently, measuring this requires intrusive sensors and disconnecting the equipment from the grid. This study, conducted by researchers from ETH Zurich and EPFL, proposes a non-intrusive method using accelerometers to extract these precise timing signatures from mechanical vibrations while the machine remains in service.

Methodology

The researchers developed a signal processing pipeline to transform noisy vibration data into accurate timestamps. The process involves three primary stages:

  1. Band-Pass Filtering: Cleaning the raw vibration signal to focus on the 0.5 Hz to 14 kHz range, removing irrelevant mechanical noise.
  2. Short-Time Energy (STE): Calculating energy locally using a sliding Hamming window to highlight sudden bursts of mechanical activity.
  3. Key Moment Detection: A threshold-based algorithm identifies two specific events: $t_1$ (the moment the latch is released) and $t_2$ (the moment the contacts touch, defining the closing time).
Signal processing pipeline for key moment detection.

The performance of this STE-based approach was benchmarked against Binary Segmentation (BS), a standard statistical method for change-point detection.

Experimental Setup and Dataset

The study utilized an ABB VD4 Type spring-operated VCB in an accelerated life test. Over five months, the device performed more than 26,000 close-open operations until a mechanical failure occurred due to friction. The resulting Run-to-Failure Vacuum Circuit Breaker Mechanical Test Dataset includes vibration signals, coil currents, and ground-truth contact separation measurements. This dataset is the first of its kind and is publicly available via the ETH Zurich Research Collection.

Results and Discussion

The proposed STE algorithm demonstrated high precision, achieving a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of only 0.550 ms compared to ground-truth measurements. In contrast, the Binary Segmentation baseline struggled with an RMSE of 8.438 ms, largely due to its inability to ignore mechanical "echoes" and noise.

The long-term monitoring revealed three distinct degradation stages: an initial "break-in" period, a long stationary period of stable operation, and a final "wearing" stage where timing becomes erratic, signaling imminent failure.

Evolution of closing time over 26,000 operations until failure.

Analysis showed that as the VCB ages, the total closing time increases because both the latch release ($t_1$) and the physical travel of the contacts slow down. This decomposition of timing allows for a more granular understanding of mechanical wear.

Conclusion

This research proves that vibration signals are a high-fidelity proxy for internal mechanical timings in VCBs. While the current study was conducted without an electrical load, it provides a robust foundation for future research under real-world conditions. These findings enable a transition from reactive to predictive maintenance, allowing utilities to monitor equipment health continuously and move toward "Remaining Useful Life" (RUL) modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Circuit breakers (CBs) play an important role in modern society because they make the power transmission and distribution systems reliable and resilient. Therefore, it is important to maintain their reliability and to monitor their operation. A key to ensure a reliable operation of CBs is to monitor their condition. In this work, we performed an accelerated life testing for mechanical failures of a vacuum circuit breaker (VCB) by performing close-open operations continuously until failure. We recorded data for each operation and made the collected run-to-failure dataset publicly available. In our experiments, the VCB operated more than 26000 close-open operations without current load with the time span of five months. The run-to-failure long-term monitoring enables us to monitor the evolution of the VCB condition and the degradation over time. To monitor CB condition, closing time is one of the indicators, which is usually measured when the CB is taken out of operation and is completely disconnected from the network. We propose an algorithm that enables to infer the same information on the closing time from a non-intrusive sensor. By utilizing the short-time energy (STE) of the vibration signal, it is possible to identify the key moments when specific events happen including the time when the latch starts to move, and the closing time. The effectiveness of the proposed algorithm is evaluated on the VCB dataset and is also compared to the binary segmentation (BS) change point detection algorithm. This research highlights the potential for continuous online condition monitoring, which is the basis for applying future predictive maintenance strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hsu2022vacuum,
  author = {Chi-Ching Hsu and Gaëtan Frusque and Mahir Muratović and Christian M. Franck and Olga Fink},
  title = {{Vacuum Circuit Breaker Closing Time Key Moments Detection via Vibration Monitoring: A Run-to-Failure Study}},
  booktitle = {2022},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/smc53654.2022.9945354},
}
Figure