Using Location Quotients to Determine Public–Natural Space Spatial Patterns: A Zurich Model

Ning Xu, Yuning Cheng, Xiaodong XuSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel quantitative method using location quotients (LQ) to analyze the spatial relationship between urban public spaces and natural landscapes. By applying this to Zurich, Switzerland, the study reveals a distinct "separation" pattern between public spaces and mountainous areas, offering a valuable model for sustainable urban design that balances ecological and social benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban planning and landscape architecture often treat artificial and natural environments as separate systems. However, integrating them is crucial for sustainable urban development. A key challenge is understanding and quantifying the complex spatial relationships between urban public spaces (where people gather and interact) and natural elements (like mountains, water, and green spaces). Existing research often falls into disciplinary silos, making it difficult to establish a unified framework for analyzing this crucial interplay. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a quantitative method to map and understand these spatial patterns, providing insights into how cities can better integrate nature for ecological and social well-being.

Methods

The core of this paper's methodology lies in the application of the Location Quotient (LQ) method. Originally developed in geography and economics, LQ is used here to measure the spatial distribution of a factor (e.g., public space, mountains) within a region relative to a larger area.

The authors define three modes of spatial relationships:

  • Overlapping Mode ("Union"): Public space and natural factors are spatially intertwined.
  • Separation Mode ("Emptiness"): Public space and natural factors are distributed independently.
  • Edge-Binding Mode ("Intersection"): Public space is located at the boundaries of natural features.

To apply LQ, the study defines:

  • Factors: Urban public space and natural factors (specifically mountains and water bodies).
  • Region: Defined in two ways: by urban layer structure (core, central, peripheral) and by administrative districts.
  • High-level Area: The entire urban area of Zurich.

The study uses ArcGIS for data processing and visualization, and SPSS for statistical analysis, including correlation and regression analysis. A key analytical step involves fitting a logarithmic curve to the relationship between public space LQ and mountain body LQ, resulting in a regression equation: PQ = -0.188lnMQ + 0.660.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is a vectorized digital base map of Zurich, Switzerland, obtained from http://maps.zh.ch. This map includes comprehensive data on:

  • Administrative zoning
  • Land-use function
  • Land parcel outlines
  • Building outlines
  • Streets

Additional data sources include:

  • Zurich's "Stadträume 2010" document for defining urban public space.
  • Site surveys conducted by the authors to verify data accuracy.
  • Statistical data on Zurich's administrative districts from http://www.stadt-zuerich.ch/prd/de/index/statistik/publikationsdatenbank/Quartierspiegel.html.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Double Framework" Concept: The paper proposes viewing urban environments as a "double framework" comprising the natural system and the urban space layout, emphasizing their interdependence.
  • LQ as a Spatial Pattern Tool: Applying LQ to urban planning is a novel approach, demonstrating its effectiveness in quantifying spatial relationships that were previously difficult to measure objectively.
  • Zurich's Separation Pattern: The most striking insight is the clear "separation" between public spaces and mountainous areas in Zurich. This suggests that in this specific context, public life is concentrated in less mountainous zones, while mountains serve as a distinct natural buffer.
  • Mutually Supplementary Mechanism: The regression equation (PQ = -0.188lnMQ + 0.660) quantifies this separation, indicating that as mountain presence (MQ) increases, public space presence (PQ) decreases, but in a non-linear, logarithmic fashion. This suggests a compensatory relationship where the presence of one enhances the perceived value or function of the other in different areas.
  • Ecological and Social Benefits: The study argues that when this relationship is properly established, it leads to significant ecological and social benefits, creating a more sustainable and livable city.

Key Results

  • Layered Distribution: Zurich exhibits a clear layer distribution trend for public space and natural factors. Public space is concentrated in the core layer (LQ = 5.796), decreasing towards the periphery, while mountain bodies are more prevalent in the peripheral layer (LQ = 1.167), increasing from the core.
  • Separation Dominance: The analysis of administrative districts confirms a strong negative correlation (R² = 0.613) between public space LQ and mountain body LQ, supporting the "separation mode" as a dominant pattern for these two factors in Zurich.
  • Overlapping and Edge-Binding: While separation is dominant for mountains, the study notes a low overlapping degree (3.2%) for natural public space in Zurich, suggesting a tendency towards polarization. The edge-binding relationship is primarily observed with water bodies, though less strongly correlated with overall public space distribution.
  • Zurich Model: The study proposes a "Zurich model" where a balanced relationship between natural systems, urban public space, and public activity centers yields ecological and social benefits.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Case Study: The authors acknowledge that the conclusions are primarily based on a single case study (Zurich). They suggest that further applications in other cities are needed to validate the methodology and explore its applicability across different urban contexts and countries.
  • Limited Natural Resources: The methodology might be less applicable to cities with scarce natural resources or without significant mountains or water bodies, as the correlation between public space and natural factors might not be established.
  • Cross-Sectional Analysis: The current research is cross-sectional, analyzing spatial patterns at a single point in time. The authors suggest that future work should consider the temporal dimension to understand the evolution of these relationships.
  • Further Evaluation Modes: The paper hints at the need for exploring other evaluation modes, particularly those that consider horizontal and vertical theoretical and empirical studies to address the issue of applicability across diverse urban environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The layout relationship between the public space system and the natural system of cities determines the trend of urban spatial forms. From the perspective of the integration of landscape architecture and urban design discipline, this paper generalizes three restriction/dependence relationship modes between urban public space and natural landscape layout: (1) overlapping mode, (2) separation mode, and (3) the mode of edge combination. Using Zurich, Switzerland, as a case study, this paper quantitatively explores the layout relationship between public space and natural landscape using the location quotient method. The research findings reveal an obvious layer distribution trend of Zurich urban public space and natural factors: the public space and mountain layout have a clear separation relationship. The regressive equation is PQ = −0.188lnMQ + 0.660, forming the mutually supplementary mechanism of the advantageous resources of public activities. The Zurich model shows that when a proper relationship is established among the natural system and the urban public space, human activities, and the public activity centers of the city, the new system provides significant ecological and social benefits. This finding provides an exemplary reference for urban construction in other countries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2018using,
  author = {Ning Xu and Yuning Cheng and Xiaodong Xu},
  title = {{Using Location Quotients to Determine Public–Natural Space Spatial Patterns: A Zurich Model}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10103462},
}
Figure