Using IS-LM Model to Analyze the Effects of Covid-19 on Chinese Economy

Haonan WangAdvances 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Covid-19 has affected Chinese economy greatly. Each local industries and companies are influenced by the isolation policy, and people are losing jobs. Because most industries and companies are affected, the GDP growth rate of the first quarter in 2020 have decreased a lot. After discussing how does the quarter GDP growth rate decrease detailed, the theory that coronavirus influenced Chinese economies significantly, will be proved by IS-LM model through accurate data from National Bureau of Statistics and other statistics by using formula equations. Those statistics will show the change of each element of the financial market and goods market, which are corresponding to each variable in the formula of IS-LM model. The changes in these variables give the expectation of how economy changes over time. According to the analysis in this paper, coronavirus has brought huge impact on the net export, the investment inboard and aboard, and the employment as well as salaries, leading to an overall decrease in output and the nominal interest rate. Therefore, both the goods markets and the financial markets are affected through the pandemic, corresponding to the situation in China at the first quarter of 2020.

TL;DR

This paper applies the classic IS-LM macroeconomic framework to analyze the shockwaves sent through the Chinese economy during the initial COVID-19 outbreak in early 2020. By mapping real-world data onto the model’s variables, the author demonstrates how simultaneous hits to consumption, investment, and exports forced a leftward shift in the IS curve, resulting in a significant contraction of national output and a drop in nominal interest rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the immediate impacts of COVID-19—lockdowns, business closures, and job losses—were visible to everyone, economists seek to understand the underlying mechanics of how these disruptions interact. The author addresses the challenge of quantifying the pandemic's "total" impact on both the goods market and the financial market in China.

The paper aims to bridge the gap between raw statistical data (like a -6.8% GDP growth rate) and economic theory. By using the IS-LM model, the author explains why specific shifts in variables like "net exports" or "fixed asset investment" led to the specific macroeconomic equilibrium observed during the first half of 2020.

Methods

The author employs the IS-LM (Investment-Savings / Liquidity preference-Money supply) model, a cornerstone of Keynesian macroeconomics.

IS Curve Analysis

The author examines the "Goods Market" using the formula $Y = C(Y-T) + I + G + (X-M)$. They analyze how decreases in Consumption ($C$), Investment ($I$), and Net Exports ($X-M$)—driven by isolation policies and global trade halts—shifted the IS curve to the left.

Figure 5: Leftward shift of the IS curve due to decreased consumption and investment.

LM Curve Analysis

The author looks at the "Money Market," specifically how a decrease in nominal income ($Y$) led to a decrease in the demand for money ($M^d$), which in turn influenced the nominal interest rate ($i$).

Figure 3: Shift in money demand (Md) resulting from lower nominal income.

Equilibrium Mapping

By combining these shifts, the paper illustrates the transition from a pre-pandemic equilibrium to a pandemic-era equilibrium characterized by lower output and lower interest rates.

Datasets

The study relies on empirical data from the first half of 2020 to validate the theoretical model:

  • National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) of China: Provided core metrics including the -6.8% GDP growth rate, the 6.2% urban unemployment rate, and the -18% growth rate in the accommodation and catering sectors.
  • KUAIYI Network: Used for data regarding the manufacturing industry’s contribution to GDP (27.17%).
  • Specific Economic Indicators: The paper cites fixed asset investment (19,919.4 billion yuan, down 6.3%) and total import/export volumes (11.54 trillion yuan, down 4.9%) as key inputs for the IS-LM variables.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Multiplier Effect of Isolation: The "isolation policy" didn't just stop people from traveling; it created a chain reaction. Lower "volume of commuters" increased transportation costs, which hurt manufacturing, which then reduced the "added value" that makes up over a quarter of China's GDP.
  • The Interest Rate Paradox: In the IS-LM framework, a decrease in output ($Y$) naturally leads to a decrease in the demand for money. With a stable money supply, this forces the nominal interest rate down. The paper highlights that even if the epidemic isn't fully controlled, this decline in interest rates acts as a minor theoretical stabilizer to minimize losses.
  • Sectoral Disparity: The data shows that while the overall economy contracted, specific "high-contact" sectors like catering and accommodation were hit nearly three times harder than the general GDP, highlighting where the IS curve's consumption variable ($C$) was most fragile.
  • Policy Priority: The author argues that because the IS-LM model shows the economy will naturally trend toward recovery once "work" resumes, the government’s primary economic policy should actually be a health policy: accelerating vaccine research to ensure that the return to work is sustainable and doesn't prolong the epidemic.

Key Results

  • IS Curve Shift: Decreases in retail sales (13,873 billion yuan) and fixed asset investment (down 6.3%) successfully proved a significant leftward shift of the IS curve.
  • LM Curve Shift: The rise in unemployment to 6.2% led to a decline in nominal income, which shifted the money demand curve to the left, lowering the equilibrium interest rate.
  • Macro-Equilibrium: The model successfully mirrored the real-world situation of Q1 2020: a simultaneous decrease in both total national output ($Y$) and the nominal interest rate ($i$).

Limitations and Future Work

The paper primarily focuses on the short-term shock of the initial 2020 outbreak. It does not account for:

  • Long-term Policy Shifts: The impact of later "Zero-COVID" iterations or the massive government stimulus packages that might have shifted the $G$ (Government Spending) variable in the IS equation more aggressively.
  • Global Inflation: The model used is a standard IS-LM, which often assumes a relatively stable price level; it does not address the global inflationary pressures that emerged in the later stages of the pandemic.
  • Future Directions: The author suggests that future research should focus on how international trade cooperation can accelerate the "economic upturn" once the health crisis is fully managed.

Summary updated

Abstract

Covid-19 has affected Chinese economy greatly. Each local industries and companies are influenced by the isolation policy, and people are losing jobs. Because most industries and companies are affected, the GDP growth rate of the first quarter in 2020 have decreased a lot. After discussing how does the quarter GDP growth rate decrease detailed, the theory that coronavirus influenced Chinese economies significantly, will be proved by IS-LM model through accurate data from National Bureau of Statistics and other statistics by using formula equations. Those statistics will show the change of each element of the financial market and goods market, which are corresponding to each variable in the formula of IS-LM model. The changes in these variables give the expectation of how economy changes over time. According to the analysis in this paper, coronavirus has brought huge impact on the net export, the investment inboard and aboard, and the employment as well as salaries, leading to an overall decrease in output and the nominal interest rate. Therefore, both the goods markets and the financial markets are affected through the pandemic, corresponding to the situation in China at the first quarter of 2020.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021using,
  author = {Haonan Wang},
  title = {{Using IS-LM Model to Analyze the Effects of Covid-19 on Chinese Economy}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2991/aebmr.k.210319.087},
}
Figure