The Impacts of China's Shadow Banking Credit Creation on the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy

Zhang Huiyi, Richard Skolnik, Yu Han, Jinpei WuInternational Journal of Finance & Banking Studies (2147-4486) 2020 · DOI

Abstract: This paper researches the impact that shadow banking in China has upon credit creation and the potential effectiveness of monetary policy. Using a credit creation model, we derive the effect that shadow banking has upon the money multiplier and the money supply. The model shows that shadow banking can change the money multiplier, potentially increasing it during an expansion and decreasing it during a contraction. Introducing shadow banking in a CC-LM model results in a shift of the CC and LM curves resulting in a higher equilibrium output. A vector autoregressive model is used to empirically estimate the impact of shadow banking deposits' growth rate on the growth rates of the broad money supply, GDP, and the CPI. The results show that shadow banking's credit creation function in China has a pro-cyclical characteristic, potentially reducing the money supply's controllability and increasing the difficulty in effectively regulating monetary policy.

Introduction

In most Western economies, shadow banking consists of non-bank financial institutions operating outside the traditional system. In China, however, shadow banking is often described as "the shadow of the bank"—it is deeply intertwined with commercial banks, primarily through off-balance-sheet activities like entrusted loans and trust products.

As shadow banking grew to account for roughly 64% of China’s nominal GDP by 2019, it created a massive "leakage" in the traditional credit creation process. This paper explores how this "disguised" credit creation complicates the central bank's ability to regulate the economy by integrating shadow banking into classical macroeconomic models.

Modeling the Credit Creation Process

The core problem is that shadow banking activities bypass statutory reserve requirements and other regulatory constraints. The researchers modified the standard money multiplier formula to include new variables: the shadow bank leakage rate (the proportion of deposits shunted to the shadow sector) and the reserved deduction rate (the portion shadow banks hold back for liquidity).

Table 1: The multi-stage credit creation process incorporating shadow banking variables such as leakage (v) and deduction rates (a).

As illustrated in the table above, shadow banking effectively increases the economy's money multiplier. Because shadow banks do not have to follow the central bank's statutory reserve requirements ($r_d$), they can create more credit per unit of deposit than traditional banks. This behavior is inherently pro-cyclical: during economic expansions, shadow banks lower their internal "reserve" rates to maximize lending, amplifying the boom.

The CC-LM Framework and Equilibrium

To understand the macroeconomic impact, the authors extended the classic IS-LM model into a CC-LM (Commodity-Credit/Liquidity-Money) framework. This allows for the explicit modeling of the credit market alongside the commodity and currency markets.

Figure 1: The shift in equilibrium output (Y) due to shadow banking credit creation in the CC-LM model.

In this framework, the introduction of shadow banking shifts both the CC (Credit-Commodity) and LM (Liquidity-Money) curves to the right. As shown in the figure, this results in a higher equilibrium output ($Y_2$ vs $Y_1$) at point $F$. While this suggests a boost to economic activity, it comes at the cost of reduced central bank oversight. When the central bank tries to tighten the money supply, commercial banks may simply shift more activity to their off-balance-sheet "shadow" accounts, effectively neutralizing the policy intent.

Empirical Findings

Using a Vector Autoregressive (VAR) model with monthly data from January 2008 to December 2018, the study tested the causal relationships between shadow banking growth and macroeconomic indicators:

  • Granger Causality: Tests confirmed that shadow banking growth is a significant "Granger reason" for changes in the money supply (M2), price levels (CPI), and economic growth (GDP).
  • Impulse Response: A shock to shadow banking deposits leads to an immediate positive response in the broad money supply. The impact on GDP growth shows a four-month lag before becoming significant.
  • Variance Contribution: Shadow banking changes explain approximately 7% of the variance in GDP growth, indicating it is a meaningful driver of economic volatility.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The findings suggest that shadow banking in China acts as a pro-cyclical accelerator that decouples the money supply from central bank control. To mitigate this, monetary policy alone may no longer be sufficient. Future regulatory frameworks should focus on coordinating interest rate policy with leverage ratio regulations to manage the "shadow" effect. Additionally, further research is needed to understand how shadow banking activities by non-financial companies, such as peer-to-peer lending, further complicate the monetary landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper researches the impact that shadow banking in China has upon credit creation and the potential effectiveness of monetary policy. Using a credit creation model, we derive the effect that shadow banking has upon the money multiplier and the money supply. The model shows that shadow banking can change the money multiplier, potentially increasing it during an expansion and decreasing it during a contraction. Introducing shadow banking in a CC-LM model results in a shift of the CC and LM curves resulting in a higher equilibrium output. A vector autoregressive model is used to empirically estimate the impact of shadow banking deposits' growth rate on the growth rates of the broad money supply, GDP, and the CPI. The results show that shadow banking's credit creation function in China has a pro-cyclical characteristic, potentially reducing the money supply's controllability and increasing the difficulty in effectively regulating monetary policy. This paper introduces shadow banking into the currency creation process of traditional commercial banks, accounting for the reserve requirement ratio, the excess reserve ratio, the shadow bank leakage rate, and the reserved deduction rate. Future research can determine whether coordinating monetary policy and leverage ratio regulation mitigates the impact of shadow banking. Another area of research is how the shadow banking of non-financial companies affect monetary policy.
BibTeX
@article{huiyi2020impacts,
  author = {Zhang Huiyi and Richard Skolnik and Yu Han and Jinpei Wu},
  title = {{The Impacts of China's Shadow Banking Credit Creation on the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy}},
  journal = {International Journal of Finance \& Banking Studies (2147-4486)},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.20525/ijfbs.v9i4.899},
}
Figure