Using Benson's Algorithm for Regularization Parameter Tracking

Joachim Giesen, Sören Laue, Andreas Löhne, Christopher Schneider

Introduction

Regularization techniques such as Lasso and Elastic Net are fundamental in preventing overfitting in machine learning models. These methods introduce hyperparameters (e.g., $\alpha, \beta$) that control the penalty strength. Traditionally, finding the optimal hyperparameter configuration involves computationally expensive cross-validation via grid search or random search. However, these methods are often inefficient, calculating solutions in regions of low variance, and lack formal guarantees regarding the coverage of the parameter space.

Methodology: A Vector Optimization Approach

This research proposes a novel framework for regularization parameter tracking by treating it as a vector optimization problem. Instead of minimizing a weighted sum of loss and penalty terms, the loss and regularization components are treated as separate objectives. The goal is to identify the Pareto front—the set of all optimal trade-offs between these objectives.

The core of this approach is Benson’s Algorithm, which offers several advantages over traditional methods:

  1. Adaptive Sampling: Unlike fixed grid searches, the algorithm automatically allocates more computational resources to regions where the solution changes rapidly.
  2. Mathematical Guarantees: It provides a rigorous stopping criterion based on an $\epsilon$-approximation of the Pareto front.
  3. Genericity: The method is applicable to any convex regularized problem without requiring problem-specific derivations.
Adaptive sampling allows the algorithm to focus on regions where the model's behavior changes most significantly.

The algorithm constructs an inner polyhedral approximation of the "upper image" of the objective space. By iteratively adding vertices to this polyhedron, it refines the approximation until the error falls below a user-defined threshold $\epsilon$.

The algorithm provides a guaranteed $\epsilon$-approximation, ensuring the true Pareto front $\mathcal{P}$ is bounded by polyhedral approximations.

Experimental Evaluation

The method was evaluated using the Elastic Net (two regularization parameters) on eight high-dimensional microarray datasets, including ALLAML, arcene, and GLIOMA. These datasets are characterized by a high feature-to-instance ratio ($m \gg n$), where effective regularization is critical.

Key Results

  • Efficiency: Benson’s algorithm achieved the same minimum Mean Squared Error (MSE) as a fine-mesh grid search while solving approximately 100 times fewer optimization problems.
  • Performance: It outperformed the previous state-of-the-art "Solution Gamut" method by an order of magnitude in terms of computational efficiency.
  • Theoretical Consistency: Experimental results aligned with the theoretical lower bounds for complexity ($\Omega(1/\epsilon)$), demonstrating the algorithm's near-optimality.
  • Model Interpretability: In a case study on the "14cancer" dataset, the algorithm identified distinct regions of the parameter space offering different levels of sparsity (e.g., 1814 vs. 79 features) with comparable performance, providing practitioners with meaningful trade-offs.

Conclusion and Future Work

By framing hyperparameter tuning as a vector optimization problem, this work provides a faster, more reliable alternative to grid search. While highly effective for convex problems with a small number of parameters, future research is needed to extend these techniques to non-convex models (such as deep neural networks) and to improve scaling for models with a large number of hyperparameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Regularized loss minimization, where a statistical model is obtained from minimizing the sum of a loss function and weighted regularization terms, is still in widespread use in machine learning. The statistical performance of the resulting models depends on the choice of weights (regularization parameters) that are typically tuned by cross-validation. For finding the best regularization parameters, the regularized minimization problem needs to be solved for the whole parameter domain. A practically more feasible approach is covering the parameter domain with approximate solutions of the loss minimization problem for some prescribed approximation accuracy. The problem of computing such a covering is known as the approximate solution gamut problem. Existing algorithms for the solution gamut problem suffer from several problems. For instance, they require a grid on the parameter domain whose spacing is difficult to determine in practice, and they are not generic in the sense that they rely on problem specific plug-in functions. Here, we show that a well-known algorithm from vector optimization, namely the Benson algorithm, can be used directly for computing approximate solution gamuts while avoiding the problems of existing algorithms. Experiments for the Elastic Net on real world data sets demonstrate the effectiveness of Benson’s algorithm for regularization parameter tracking.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giesen2019using,
  author = {Joachim Giesen and Sören Laue and Andreas Löhne and Christopher Schneider},
  title = {{Using Benson's Algorithm for Regularization Parameter Tracking}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v33i01.33013689},
}
Figure