Abstract
Standard robust Reinforcement Learning (RL) often produces overly conservative policies by optimizing for the absolute worst-case scenario. This paper introduces User-Oriented Robust RL (UOR-RL), a framework that allows users to balance performance across different environments based on their specific preferences and the actual probability of those environments occurring. By generalizing average-case and worst-case metrics, UOR-RL provides a tunable spectrum of robustness that avoids the pitfalls of extreme conservatism.
Introduction
In the transition from simulation to the real world (sim-to-real), RL agents frequently encounter environments that differ from their training conditions. Traditional approaches utilize max-min robustness, which optimizes for the single worst possible environment. However, this method suffers from two major flaws:
- Over-Conservatism: Optimizing solely for rare, extreme scenarios (e.g., total power failure) can significantly degrade performance in common, everyday situations.
- Ignoring User Preference: Standard robust RL offers a one-size-fits-all solution, ignoring that different users have varying risk tolerances—some may prefer aggressive performance while others prioritize safety.
The User-Oriented Robustness (UOR) Framework
The authors propose the User-Oriented Robustness (UOR) metric, defined as a weighted sum of performance across various environments. The weights are determined by three key factors:
- Environment Distribution: The likelihood of an environment occurring.
- Relative Performance: The policy's performance in a specific environment compared to others.
- Preference Function ($W$): A user-defined function that dictates the weight given to "bad" environments. By adjusting a single parameter ($k$), users can navigate a spectrum from "Average-Case" ($k=0$) to "Worst-Case" ($k \to \infty$).
Algorithms
To optimize this metric, two algorithms were developed:
- DB-UOR-RL (Distribution-Based): Applicable when the environment probability distribution is known, using discretization into "blocks" to calculate the UOR metric.
- DF-UOR-RL (Distribution-Free): A practical variant for unknown distributions that uses trajectory clustering to estimate the metric dynamically.
Experimental Evaluation
The framework was evaluated using the MuJoCo physics engine across six continuous control tasks: Reacher, Hopper, HalfCheetah, Humanoid, Ant, and Walker 2d. Physical parameters such as body size, density, and friction were varied to create a diverse set of test environments.
Key Results and Insights
UOR-RL demonstrates that robustness is a spectrum rather than a binary choice. By weighting environments based on their performance rank, the agent prioritizes scenarios where it struggles most, aligned with the user's risk tolerance.
Performance and Robustness
DB-UOR-RL outperformed state-of-the-art baselines like EPOpt and MRPO across all MuJoCo tasks when evaluated using the UOR metric ($k=1$). Furthermore, UOR-RL remained competitive even on traditional "worst-case" metrics. For instance, in the Ant task, DF-UOR-RL achieved a score of 3265, significantly higher than MRPO's 2187.
Visual analysis via heatmaps confirms that UOR-RL policies maintain high performance over a much broader range of physical conditions (e.g., friction vs. density) than baseline methods.
Conclusion and Future Work
While UOR-RL offers a flexible and robust framework, challenges remain. The computational complexity of block division grows with the dimensionality of environment parameters. Additionally, while the $k$ parameter simplifies preference, real-world preferences may require more complex modeling. Future research will focus on learning preference functions from user behavior and validating these policies on physical robotic hardware.
Summary updated