Urban Heat Island Simulations in Guangzhou, China, Using the Coupled WRF/UCM Model with a Land Use Map Extracted from Remote Sensing Data

Guang Chen, Lihua Zhao, Akashi MochidaSustainability 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that using up-to-date land use data, extracted from remote sensing, significantly improves the accuracy of urban heat island (UHI) simulations in Guangzhou, China, when using the WRF/UCM model. The enhanced land use data allows for a more realistic representation of urban thermal environments, leading to better predictions of 2-m air temperature and UHI intensity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urbanization is a major driver of climate change at local scales, leading to the Urban Heat Island (UHI) effect, where urban areas are significantly warmer than their rural surroundings. Accurately simulating this phenomenon is crucial for urban planning, public health, and climate adaptation strategies. However, a key challenge in these simulations is the availability and accuracy of land use data. Standard land use datasets used in atmospheric models often lag behind rapid urban development, especially in fast-growing cities like Guangzhou. This mismatch between model input and reality can lead to inaccurate simulations of urban climate. This paper addresses this gap by evaluating the performance of the WRF/UCM model using newly derived, high-resolution land use data for Guangzhou, aiming to improve UHI simulation accuracy.

Methods

The researchers employed the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model coupled with a single-layer Urban Canopy Model (UCM). This coupled model is designed to simulate the complex interactions between the urban surface and the atmosphere. To address the issue of outdated land use data, they extracted and processed new land use data from Landsat-7 satellite imagery for the Guangzhou region. This new dataset was further refined by classifying urban land into three subcategories (commercial/industrial/transportation, high-intensity residential, and low-intensity residential) using nighttime light imagery and the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI). This enhanced land use dataset, termed "UCM_12," was then used in three numerical experiments:

  1. MODIS experiment: Using the default MODIS land use data with WRF, but without the UCM.
  2. RS_12 experiment: Using the extracted Landsat-7 land use data (without subcategories) with WRF, but without the UCM.
  3. UCM_12 experiment: Using the enhanced Landsat-7 land use data (with subcategories) coupled with the WRF/UCM model.

The performance of these experiments was evaluated against observed 2-m air temperature and wind velocity data from weather stations in Guangzhou.

Datasets

  • Land Use Data:
    • MODIS Land Use Data: The default land use dataset used in the WRF model.
  • Landsat-7 ETM+ Imagery: Used to extract new land use data for Guangzhou.
  • DMSP-OLS Nighttime Light Imagery: Used in conjunction with NDVI to classify urban land into subcategories.
  • SPOT NDVI Data: Used to generate a new NDVI composite index for urban land classification.
  • UCM_12: The newly derived, enhanced land use dataset for Guangzhou, classified into urban subcategories.
  • Meteorological Data:
    • NCEP Global Forecast System Final Analyses: Used for initial and lateral boundary conditions for the WRF model.
  • Guangzhou Meteorological Bureau Data: Observed 2-m air temperature and wind velocity data from four weather stations (one suburban, three urban) for model evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The critical role of up-to-date land use data: The study strongly emphasizes that outdated land use data is a significant limitation in accurately simulating urban climate. The rapid pace of urbanization in cities like Guangzhou renders older datasets insufficient.
  • Urban sub-classification matters: Differentiating urban land into categories like commercial/industrial, high-intensity residential, and low-intensity residential provides a more nuanced representation of urban surface properties, leading to improved simulation results compared to a single "urban" category.
  • UCM enhances realism: Coupling the WRF model with an Urban Canopy Model (UCM) is essential for capturing the specific thermal and radiative properties of urban surfaces, leading to better temperature predictions, especially during nighttime.
  • Energy balance reveals UHI drivers: Analyzing the energy equilibrium parameters (shortwave absorbed, latent heat flux, ground heat flux, etc.) in urban versus suburban areas helps explain the mechanisms behind the UHI, such as reduced evaporation in urban areas and increased sensible heating.

Key Results

  • Temperature Simulation: The UCM_12 experiment, using the enhanced land use data and coupled UCM, provided the best reproduction of observed 2-m air temperature evolution, showing the smallest minimum absolute average error compared to experiments without the UCM. The RS_12 experiment (without UCM but with new land use) also performed better than the MODIS experiment.
  • UHI Intensity: All experiments reproduced the diurnal characteristics of UHI intensity. The RS_12 and UCM_12 simulations showed better correspondence with observations than the MODIS results, though none perfectly replicated the observed UHI intensity, particularly during rainy periods. The UCM_12 experiment showed better nighttime UHI simulation.
  • Wind Velocity: Modeled wind velocity was generally overestimated across all experiments. The new land use data did not significantly alter wind velocity simulation results compared to the default MODIS data. However, the UCM_12 experiment showed slightly better performance in wind velocity simulation based on quantitative evaluation metrics.
  • Energy Equilibrium: The UCM_12 experiment successfully reproduced the differences in energy equilibrium between urban and suburban areas, highlighting reduced latent heat flux and increased sensible heating in urban environments, which are key drivers of the UHI.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Underestimation of UHII: The study acknowledges that all experiments, including the UCM_12, consistently underestimated the Urban Heat Island Intensity (UHII). This suggests that even with improved land use data and the UCM, there are still aspects of the urban environment that are not fully captured.
  • Wind Velocity Overestimation: The modeled wind velocity was consistently higher than observed values, indicating that the model's representation of urban surface roughness and building effects on wind flow might be insufficient.
  • Rainy Day Performance: The simulations showed less accuracy on rainy days, suggesting that the model's performance might be more sensitive to precipitation events.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the coupled WRF/UCM model with land use data extracted from remote sensing is an effective tool for urban thermal environment analyses. Future work could focus on improving the representation of urban canopy effects on wind, further refining land use classification, and extending the simulation period to capture a wider range of meteorological conditions. Investigating the impact of different urban canopy parameterizations could also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model coupled with an Urban Canopy Model (UCM) was used for studying urban environmental issues. Because land use data employed in the WRF model do not agree with the current situation around Guangzhou, China, the performance of WRF/UCM with new land-use data extracted from Remote Sensing (RS) data was evaluated in early August 2012. Results from simulations reveal that experiments with the extracted data are capable of reasonable reproductions of the majority of the observed temporal characteristics of the 2-m temperature, and can capture the characteristics of Urban Heat Island (UHI). The “UCM_12” simulation, which employed the extracted land-use data with the WRF/UCM model, provided the best reproduction of the 2-m temperature data evolution and the smallest minimum absolute average error when compared with the other two experiments without coupled UCM. The contributions of various factors to the UHI effect were analyzed by comparing the energy equilibrium processes of “UCM_12” in urban and suburban areas. Analysis revealed that energy equilibrium processes with new land use data can explain the diurnal character of the UHI intensity variation. Furthermore, land use data extracted from RS can be used to simulate the UHI.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2016urban,
  author = {Guang Chen and Lihua Zhao and Akashi Mochida},
  title = {{Urban Heat Island Simulations in Guangzhou, China, Using the Coupled WRF/UCM Model with a Land Use Map Extracted from Remote Sensing Data}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/su8070628},
}
Figure