Upward-Pointing Cosmic-Ray-like Events Observed with ANITA

A. Romero‐Wolf, P. W. Gorham, J. W. Nam, S. Hoover, P. Allison, O. Banerjee, L. Batten, J. J. Beatty, K. Belov, D. Besson, W. R. Binns, V. Bugaev, Pinlu Cao, C. Chen, Pisin Chen, J. M. Clem, A. Connolly, B. Dailey, Cosmin Deaconu, L. Cremonesi, P. F. Dowkontt, M. A. DuVernois, R. C. Field, B. W. Fox, D. Goldstein, J. Gordon, C. Hast, Clément Hébert, B. Hill, K. Hughes, R. Hupe, M. H. Israel, A. Javaid, J. Kowalski, J. Lam, Andrew Ludwig, J. G. Learned, K. M. Liewer, T. C. Liu, J. T. Link, Elizabeth R. Lusczek, S. Matsuno, B. C. Mercurio, C. Miki, P. Miočinović, M. Mottram, Katharine Mulrey, C. J. Naudet, J. Ng, R. J. Nichol, Alexander Novikov, K. J. Palladino, S. Prohira, B. F. Rauch, K. Reil, Jason L. Roberts, M. Rosen, Björn Rotter, John W. Russell, Larry Ruckman, D. Saltzberg, D. Seckel, S. Stafford, J. Stockham, M. Stockham, Benjamin Strutt, K. Tatem, G. Varner, A. G. Vieregg, D. Walz, Stephanie Wissel, Fan Wu, Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz, W. Rodrigues de Carvalho, Harm Schoorlemmer, E. Zas

Abstract

The Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA) collaboration recently reported four upward-pointing cosmic-ray-like events from its first flight. While three are consistent with stratospheric air showers, the fourth appears to emerge from the Antarctic ice at a $25.4^\circ$ angle. This paper models the hypothesis that this event originated from a tau neutrino ($\nu_\tau$) interaction. Our simulations show that under Standard Model physics, ANITA’s exposure is significantly lower than that of the Pierre Auger Observatory and IceCube, creating a strong statistical tension that suggests either a transient source or physics beyond the Standard Model.

Introduction

ANITA is a balloon-borne experiment designed to detect ultra-high-energy (UHE) neutrinos by monitoring the Antarctic ice sheet for impulsive radio signals. During its first mission (ANITA-I), it detected an anomalous "upward-pointing" event. Unlike typical cosmic rays that arrive from above, this event appeared to originate from the Earth's surface. If interpreted as a $\nu_\tau$ interaction, where a neutrino traverses the Earth and produces a tau lepton ($\tau$) that decays in the atmosphere, it poses a challenge: at UHE energies, the Earth is expected to be opaque to neutrinos at such steep angles.

Modeling the Tau Neutrino Hypothesis

To test the $\nu_\tau$ origin, we developed a simulation pipeline to calculate ANITA's "acceptance"—the effective area and solid angle over which it can detect such events. The geometry of the interaction is complex, involving neutrino propagation through the Earth's interior, the production of a tau lepton, and its subsequent decay into an extensive air shower (EAS) upon exiting the ice.

Geometry of a tau neutrino interaction and the resulting air shower observed by ANITA.

The simulation accounts for neutrino propagation (including "regeneration" effects where $\tau$ decays back into $\nu_\tau$), radio emission modeling using ZHAireS, and a conservative upper bound for ANITA's detector sensitivity based on the quietest detected events.

Results: The Tension with Other Observatories

Our primary finding is a significant discrepancy between ANITA's observation and the null results from other major neutrino observatories. We compared ANITA's calculated exposure across various Standard Model (SM) variations—adjusting neutrino cross-sections and energy loss rates—against public data from the Pierre Auger Observatory and IceCube.

Comparison of ANITA's exposure to $\nu_\tau$ events against IceCube and Auger for different Standard Model physics assumptions.

As shown in the exposure curves, ANITA’s sensitivity is approximately 60 times lower than that of Auger or IceCube at the relevant energy scales. If the ANITA event were part of a steady "diffuse flux" of neutrinos, Auger and IceCube should have detected dozens of similar events. The absence of such detections in those experiments makes the ANITA-I event an extreme statistical outlier under the diffuse flux hypothesis.

Discussion and Conclusion

The "tension" between ANITA and other detectors remains robust even when pushing Standard Model uncertainties to their limits. This suggests two primary possibilities:

  1. Transient Sources: The event may have originated from a short-lived, high-intensity burst of neutrinos from a specific point source that happened to be in ANITA's field of view.
  2. Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) Physics: There may be unknown physical processes or particles that allow UHE neutrinos to penetrate the Earth more efficiently than predicted by the Standard Model.

Future analyses of data from ANITA-III and ANITA-IV will be crucial. If more upward-pointing events are confirmed, it will necessitate a fundamental re-evaluation of our understanding of high-energy particle interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

These proceedings address a recent publication by the ANITA collaboration of four upward- pointing cosmic-ray-like events observed in the first flight of ANITA. Three of these events were consistent with stratospheric cosmic-ray air showers where the axis of propagation does not inter- sect the surface of the Earth. The fourth event was consistent with a primary particle that emerges from the surface of the ice suggesting a possible τ-lepton decay as the origin of this event. These proceedings follow-up on the modeling and testing of the hypothesis that this event was of τ neutrino origin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{romerowolf2017upward,
  author = {A. Romero‐Wolf and P. W. Gorham and J. W. Nam and S. Hoover and P. Allison and O. Banerjee and L. Batten and J. J. Beatty and K. Belov and D. Besson and W. R. Binns and V. Bugaev and Pinlu Cao and C. Chen and Pisin Chen and J. M. Clem and A. Connolly and B. Dailey and Cosmin Deaconu and L. Cremonesi and P. F. Dowkontt and M. A. DuVernois and R. C. Field and B. W. Fox and D. Goldstein and J. Gordon and C. Hast and Clément Hébert and B. Hill and K. Hughes and R. Hupe and M. H. Israel and A. Javaid and J. Kowalski and J. Lam and Andrew Ludwig and J. G. Learned and K. M. Liewer and T. C. Liu and J. T. Link and Elizabeth R. Lusczek and S. Matsuno and B. C. Mercurio and C. Miki and P. Miočinović and M. Mottram and Katharine Mulrey and C. J. Naudet and J. Ng and R. J. Nichol and Alexander Novikov and K. J. Palladino and S. Prohira and B. F. Rauch and K. Reil and Jason L. Roberts and M. Rosen and Björn Rotter and John W. Russell and Larry Ruckman and D. Saltzberg and D. Seckel and S. Stafford and J. Stockham and M. Stockham and Benjamin Strutt and K. Tatem and G. Varner and A. G. Vieregg and D. Walz and Stephanie Wissel and Fan Wu and Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz and W. Rodrigues de Carvalho and Harm Schoorlemmer and E. Zas},
  title = {{Upward-Pointing Cosmic-Ray-like Events Observed with ANITA}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of 35th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2017)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.22323/1.301.0935},
}
Figure