Abstract
We provide an update on the RBC & UKQCD lattice calculation of the measure of Standard Model direct CP-violation in kaon decays, $\epsilon'$. By incorporating a new scalar operator and leveraging lattice symmetries, we resolve the long-standing discrepancy in the pion scattering phase shift and achieve a 7.6x reduction in computational cost.
Introduction
CP-violation is a fundamental asymmetry between matter and antimatter, essential for explaining the matter-dominated universe. In the Standard Model, direct CP-violation in neutral kaon decays is quantified by the parameter $\epsilon'$. Calculating $\epsilon'$ from first principles is a formidable challenge due to the non-perturbative nature of the strong force (QCD) at the energy scales of kaon decay.
In 2015, the RBC & UKQCD collaborations published the first lattice QCD calculation of $\epsilon'$. However, a significant "phase-shift puzzle" emerged: the calculated pion-pion scattering phase shift ($\delta_0$) exhibited a 5-sigma discrepancy with predictions from dispersion theory. This suggested either an unaccounted-for systematic error or potential "New Physics."
Methodology: Operator Expansion and Symmetry Optimization
To address the phase-shift discrepancy, the collaboration expanded the operator basis. The original calculation was contaminated by an excited state near 770 MeV. By introducing a new scalar $\pi\pi$ operator ($\mathcal{O}_\sigma$) and an additional operator ($\mathcal{O}_{\pi\pi(311)}$), the simulation can now effectively distinguish the ground state from nearby excited states.
The inclusion of these operators significantly increases the number of "Wick contractions"—the mathematical representations of quark paths. To manage this complexity, the team utilized lattice symmetries, including parity, axis permutation, and a novel auxiliary-diagram symmetry.
These optimizations reduced the required momentum combinations from 7,848 to 1,037, representing a 7.6x improvement in computational efficiency.
Results: Resolving the Phase-Shift Puzzle
The primary breakthrough of this update is the resolution of the phase-shift discrepancy. By "projecting out" the excited state using the $\sigma$ operator, the team identified a stable ground-state plateau.
The updated ground-state phase shift is $\delta_0 = 30.9(1.5)(3.0)^\circ$, which is now statistically consistent with the theoretical prediction of approximately $34^\circ$. This alignment validates the lattice framework and removes a major source of systematic uncertainty.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The resolution of the phase-shift puzzle marks a significant milestone in the precision study of CP-violation. While the full $K \to \pi\pi$ matrix elements for the new operator basis are still being finalized, the technical hurdles have been overcome. The collaboration expects to provide an updated, high-precision value for $\epsilon'$ in the near future, which will serve as a rigorous test of the Standard Model and a potential window into physics beyond it.
Summary updated