Unravelling Distance-Dependent Inter-Site Interactions and Magnetic Transition Effects of Heteronuclear Single Atom Catalysts on Electrochemical Oxygen Reduction

Tong Yang, Jun Zhou, Xiaoyang Ma, Keda Ding, Kay Chen Tan, Ge Wang, Haitao Huang, Ming YangarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) have emerged as a frontier in electrochemical energy conversion, offering maximum atom utilization and high intrinsic activity. To transition these materials from laboratory-scale demonstrations to industrial applications, such as fuel cells and metal-air batteries, researchers must increase the density of active sites—a regime known as high-loading SACs. However, as the distance between metal centers decreases, the traditional assumption that these sites act in isolation begins to fail.

This study investigates the complex inter-site interactions in heteronuclear SAC systems, specifically focusing on iron (Fe) and cobalt (Co) atoms co-supported on nitrogen-doped graphene ($FeN_4-C$ and $CoN_4-C$). By exploring the distance-dependent relationship between these two distinct metal centers, the research reveals how electronic and magnetic coupling dictates catalytic efficiency in the Oxygen Reduction Reaction (ORR).

Methodology

The researchers utilized Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to simulate the electronic environment of Fe and Co sites. To model varying degrees of "crowding," they employed a supercell approach, adjusting the graphene lattice size from $3 \times 3$ to $11 \times 11$. This allowed for the precise control of the average inter-site distance, ranging from approximately 4 Å to 16 Å.

The study evaluated two primary configurations to account for different relative positions on the graphene lattice. Beyond standard activity metrics, the team analyzed Gibbs Free Energy for reaction intermediates (OOH, O, and *OH), magnetic moments to track spin-state transitions, and the Projected Density of States (PDOS) to observe orbital hybridization as the metal atoms approached one another.

The study reveals that Fe and Co sites respond differently to proximity.

Cobalt (Co) Sites

Cobalt exhibits a "volcano-like" evolution in activity. Its performance is not linear; rather, it reaches an optimum at an intermediate distance. Specifically, in a $5 \times 5$ configuration (approximately 7.14 Å apart), the Co site achieved a limiting potential ($U_L$) of 1.022 V. This significantly outperforms both isolated Fe (0.980 V) and isolated Co (0.925 V), suggesting that a specific degree of inter-site interaction is beneficial for cobalt’s catalytic cycle.

Iron (Fe) Sites

In contrast, Fe sites generally experience a deterioration in activity as they become more crowded. When the inter-site distance was reduced to approximately 10 Å, the limiting potential dropped sharply from 0.990 V to 0.445 V. This decline is attributed to excessively strong binding of the hydroxyl (*OH) intermediate. Interestingly, the researchers found that this performance drop could be mitigated by the presence of an axial hydroxyl ligand, which acts as a chemical spacer to modify the iron atom's electronic state.

Magnetic Transitions and Scaling Relations

A central discovery of this research is the role of adsorption-induced spin transitions. The study found that the adsorption of ORR intermediates can trigger a shift from a low-spin to a high-spin state in the metal centers. This transition is highly sensitive to the distance between sites; at short distances, the atoms are more prone to flipping to a high-spin state. This magnetic shift causes the metal to bind intermediates too strongly, which effectively "poisons" the site and reduces catalytic throughput.

Furthermore, these interactions provide a mechanism to challenge the long-standing "scaling relations" in catalysis. Typically, the binding energies of OH and OOH are linearly correlated, meaning that optimizing the binding of one often adversely affects the other. This study demonstrates that distance-dependent spin transitions can shift this linear relationship, offering a new theoretical "knob" for tuning catalyst behavior beyond traditional thermodynamic limits.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work provides a fundamental framework for understanding how high-loading SACs behave when they are no longer isolated. The identification of a "Goldilocks zone" for cobalt and the discovery of spin-state transitions as a driver of catalytic activity offer clear pathways for the design of next-generation dual-atom catalysts.

While the study uses pristine nitrogen-doped graphene models, future work will need to address the complexities of real-world materials, such as structural defects and edge effects. Additionally, the ability to shift scaling relations through magnetic transitions opens new possibilities for other multi-electron processes, including the Nitrogen Reduction Reaction (NRR) and $CO_2$ Reduction ($CO_2RR$).

Summary updated

Abstract

Inter-site interactions between single atom catalysts (SACs) in the high loading regime are critical to tuning the catalytic performance. However, the understanding on such interactions and their distance dependent effects remains elusive, especially for the heteronuclear SACs. In this study, we reveal the effects of the distance-dependent inter-site interaction on the catalytic performance of SACs. Using the density functional theory calculations, we systematically investigate the heteronuclear iron and cobalt single atoms co-supported on the nitrogen-doped graphene (FeN4-C and CoN4-C) for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). We find that as the distance between Fe and Co SACs decreases, FeN4-C exhibits a reduced catalytic activity, which can be mitigated by the presence of an axial hydroxyl ligand, whereas the activity of CoN4-C shows a volcano-like evolution with the optimum reached at the intermediate distance. We further unravel that the transition towards the high-spin state upon adsorption of ORR intermediate adsorbates is responsible for the decreased activity of both FeN4-C and CoN4-C at short inter-site distance. Such high-spin state transition is also found to significantly shift the linear relation between hydroxyl (*OH) and hydroperoxyl (*OOH) adsorbates. These findings not only shed light on the SAC-specific effect of the distance-dependent inter-site interaction between heteronuclear SACs, but also pave a way towards shifting the long-standing linear relations observed in multiple-electron chemical reactions.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2022unravelling,
  author = {Tong Yang and Jun Zhou and Xiaoyang Ma and Keda Ding and Kay Chen Tan and Ge Wang and Haitao Huang and Ming Yang},
  title = {{Unravelling Distance-Dependent Inter-Site Interactions and Magnetic Transition Effects of Heteronuclear Single Atom Catalysts on Electrochemical Oxygen Reduction}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2201.05801},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.05801},
}
Figure