Unknotting genus one knots

Alexander Coward, Marc Lackenby

Abstract: For any knot with genus one and unknotting number one, other than the figure-eight knot, we prove that there is exactly one way to unknot it by means of a crossing change. In the case of the figure-eight knot, we prove that there are precisely two unknotting crossing changes. The proof uses sutured manifold theory and an analysis of the arc complex of the once-punctured torus.

The Challenge of Unknotting

In knot theory, the unknotting number is a fundamental invariant representing the minimum number of times one strand of a knot must pass through another (a "crossing change") to transform it into the unknot (a simple circle). While determining the unknotting number itself is notoriously difficult, a deeper question persists: How many distinct ways can a knot be unknotted in a single move?

This paper provides a rare finiteness result for genus one knots—knots that can be bounded by a surface with exactly one hole (a punctured torus). The authors demonstrate that for this class of knots, the number of unknotting sites is almost always unique.

The Geometry of Crossing Changes

A crossing change can be formally modeled as a topological operation called surgery. Specifically, a crossing change is equivalent to performing $+1$ or $-1$ surgery along a small loop, called a crossing circle, that encircles the two strands at the crossing site.

A crossing change represented as +1 surgery along a crossing circle C.

Defining equivalence is crucial: two unknotting moves are considered the same if one crossing circle can be moved to the other via ambient isotopy—essentially sliding the circle along the knot without cutting it.

Methodology: Surfaces and Arcs

The authors combine geometric topology with combinatorial tools to classify these unknotting sites:

  • Sutured Manifold Theory: Using theorems by Scharlemann and Thompson, the authors translate the physical act of a crossing change into the decomposition of the knot's associated Seifert surface. They show that unknotting a genus one knot is equivalent to decomposing its surface into simpler pieces, specifically requiring the presence of a "Hopf band."
  • The Arc Complex and Farey Graph: For "fibred" knots (like the trefoil and figure-eight), the problem is mapped to the study of how the knot's internal twist (monodromy) acts on the arcs of a punctured torus. The authors use the Farey graph—a geometric representation of rational numbers—to track these arcs and prove that only a very limited number of arcs can satisfy the unknotting conditions.

Key Results

The central finding of the paper is a strict limit on the number of unknotting sites:

  1. Theorem 1.1: For a genus one knot with unknotting number one, there is precisely one crossing change that unknots it, unless the knot is the figure-eight knot.
  2. The Figure-Eight Exception: The figure-eight knot is unique in this class, admitting precisely two distinct unknotting crossing changes. While the trefoil knot may appear to have three sites, the authors prove they are all equivalent under the knot's inherent symmetry.
Examples of unknotting crossing circles on knot diagrams, illustrating the specific sites where a single change results in the unknot.

Implications and Future Work

Based on these findings, the authors propose Conjecture 1.3: for any knot $K$, there are only finitely many ways to unknot it in a single move. While this paper settles the case for genus one, the complexity of the arc complex grows significantly for higher-genus knots. This work suggests that despite the potential for infinite complexity in 3-manifold surgery, the knots themselves behave with remarkable rigidity.

Summary updated

Abstract

For any knot with genus one and unknotting number one, other than the figure-eight knot, we prove that there is exactly one way to unknot it by means of a crossing change. In the case of the figure-eight knot, we prove that there are precisely two unknotting crossing changes. The proof uses sutured manifold theory and an analysis of the arc complex of the once-punctured torus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{coward2011unknotting,
  author = {Alexander Coward and Marc Lackenby},
  title = {{Unknotting genus one knots}},
  booktitle = {Commentarii},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.4171/cmh/227},
}
Figure