University-industry collaboration: The impact of postdoctoral workstations on labor investment efficiency

Yiding Liu, Kefu Yi, Guanhua HuangFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates whether managers use knowledge transferred from university-industry collaboration when making investment decisions on labor. To establish causality, we use a difference-in-difference method based on the staggered establishment of postdoctoral workstations in Chinese firms. We find that postdoctoral workstations enable managers to improve labor investment efficiency and thus help mitigate over- and under-investment problems in labor, and the higher the operational quality of the workstation, the more significant the increase in investment efficiency. This finding is robust to utilizing the event study approach, placebo test, propensity score matching, instrumental variable, and entropy balancing. Brain gain and knowledge transfer effects between universities and industries are two plausible mechanisms. Furthermore, the main effect is more pronounced for firms located closer to prestigious universities, firms are non-state-owned enterprises, human-capital-intensive, have political connections, and without national fellows' lead. Our findings suggest that brain gain in firms does not merely increase or reduce labor investments Per se, but rather inspires managers to maintain optimal labor levels through knowledge transfer processes.

Introduction

Firms rarely achieve perfect staffing levels. They frequently suffer from Labor Investment Inefficiency (LIE), falling into the trap of either "over-investment" (hiring more workers than economic fundamentals justify, often due to agency problems) or "under-investment" (failing to hire necessary talent due to financial constraints or information gaps). In emerging markets like China, this problem is exacerbated by a shifting demographic landscape and a "brain drain" of high-end talent.

This study investigates whether a specific policy tool—the industrial postdoctoral workstation—can mitigate these inefficiencies. These workstations are joint ventures where firms and universities collaborate to host PhD graduates. The core question is: Does bringing high-level academic expertise into a corporate setting help managers make smarter, more efficient decisions about their broader workforce?

Methodology and Data

The researchers employed a staggered Difference-in-Differences (DiD) approach, comparing "treated" firms (those establishing workstations) against "control" firms across a timeline from 2011 to 2019. The dataset included 10,392 firm-year observations from 2,457 Chinese A-share listed firms, with workstation data manually collected from the Chinese Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security (MOHRSS).

To measure labor efficiency, the study utilized the Pinnuck and Lillis (2007) model to predict "expected" hiring based on financial fundamentals. The gap between actual and predicted hiring served as the metric for inefficiency.

Key Findings

1. Significant Efficiency Gains

The establishment of a postdoctoral workstation leads to a 1.89% reduction in inefficient labor investment. This corresponds to shrinking the gap between actual and optimal labor levels by approximately 11.5%.

2. Causal Evidence and Robustness

To ensure the validity of these results, the authors conducted an event study to test for parallel trends. As shown in the event study plot, there were no significant differences in labor efficiency between the treatment and control groups prior to the establishment of the workstation (years $t-3$ to $t-1$). The significant improvement in efficiency occurs precisely at the time of establishment ($t$).

Figure 6: Event study plot showing the impact on coefficients relative to the year of workstation establishment.

Furthermore, a placebo test was conducted by randomly assigning workstation establishment dates 500 times. The resulting distribution of coefficients, centered around zero, confirms that the benchmark result (the vertical blue line at -0.0189) is not a product of random chance.

Figure 2: Placebo test reporting the density of coefficients from 500 random assignments compared to the benchmark coefficient.

3. Mechanisms: Brain Gain and Knowledge Transfer

The presence of postdocs triggers a workforce restructuring. Data indicates that firms with workstations increase "SkillHiring" while decreasing "UnskillHiring." Postdocs act as a "vessel of knowledge transfer," bringing awareness of industrial frontiers that helps managers better forecast human capital needs. This is supported by observed increases in R&D expenditure, training investments, and patent counts.

Heterogeneity and Limitations

The positive effect of workstations is more pronounced in non-state-owned enterprises (non-SOEs). SOEs often face social mandates to maintain high employment, making them less flexible in adjusting labor for pure efficiency. Additionally, efficiency gains were higher for firms located near prestigious "Project 211" universities.

Interestingly, workstations led by "National Fellows" (top-tier academics) did not show a more pronounced improvement. This suggests that while high-level academics excel at pure research, they may be less focused on the operational optimization required to improve labor efficiency.

Conclusion

Postdoctoral workstations in Chinese firms act as a vital bridge for university-industry knowledge transfer. By facilitating "brain gain," these workstations help managers move closer to optimal staffing levels, reducing both wasteful over-hiring and costly under-investment. These improvements in labor efficiency ultimately translate into higher Total Factor Productivity (TFP) and increased firm value.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper investigates whether managers use knowledge transferred from university-industry collaboration when making investment decisions on labor. To establish causality, we use a difference-in-difference method based on the staggered establishment of postdoctoral workstations in Chinese firms. We find that postdoctoral workstations enable managers to improve labor investment efficiency and thus help mitigate over- and under-investment problems in labor, and the higher the operational quality of the workstation, the more significant the increase in investment efficiency. This finding is robust to utilizing the event study approach, placebo test, propensity score matching, instrumental variable, and entropy balancing. Brain gain and knowledge transfer effects between universities and industries are two plausible mechanisms. Furthermore, the main effect is more pronounced for firms located closer to prestigious universities, firms are non-state-owned enterprises, human-capital-intensive, have political connections, and without national fellows' lead. Our findings suggest that brain gain in firms does not merely increase or reduce labor investments <i>Per se</i>, but rather inspires managers to maintain optimal labor levels through knowledge transfer processes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022university,
  author = {Yiding Liu and Kefu Yi and Guanhua Huang},
  title = {{University-industry collaboration: The impact of postdoctoral workstations on labor investment efficiency}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.955935},
}
Figure