Abstract
Nearly all dense suspensions undergo dramatic and abrupt thickening transitions in their flow behaviour when sheared at high stresses. Such transitions occur when the dominant interactions between the suspended particles shift from hydrodynamic to frictional. Here, we interpret abrupt shear thickening as a precursor to a rigidity transition and give a complete theory of the viscosity in terms of a universal crossover scaling function from the frictionless jamming point to a rigidity transition associated with friction, anisotropy, and shear. Strikingly, we find experimentally that for two different systems -- cornstarch in glycerol and silica spheres in glycerol -- the viscosity can be collapsed onto a single universal curve over a wide range of stresses and volume fractions. The collapse reveals two separate scaling regimes, due to a crossover between frictionless isotropic jamming and frictional shear jamming, with different critical exponents. The material-specific behaviour due to the microscale particle interactions is incorporated into a scaling variable governing the proximity to shear jamming that depends on both stress and volume fraction. This reformulation opens the door to importing the vast theoretical machinery developed to understand equilibrium critical phenomena to elucidate fundamental physical aspects of the shear thickening transition.
Introduction
Dense suspensions, such as the familiar "oobleck" mixture of cornstarch and water, exhibit a remarkable phenomenon known as shear thickening: a sharp increase in viscosity when subjected to high stress. This transition marks a shift from a lubricated state, where particles slide past one another, to a frictional state where they lock together. Despite its prevalence, a unified framework to predict this behavior across diverse materials—ranging from irregular organic granules to smooth synthetic spheres—has remained elusive. This study addresses that gap by treating shear thickening as a phase transition, applying the principles of equilibrium critical phenomena to the non-equilibrium flow of suspensions.
Theoretical Framework and Methods
The researchers utilized the Wyart-Cates (WC) model as a foundation, which describes viscosity as a function of the distance from a "jamming point." By recasting this model into a crossover scaling framework, they introduced a non-linear scaling variable, $x_{WC}$, which incorporates a material-specific anisotropy factor $C(\phi)$.
The core of the approach involves treating the transition as a crossover between two "fixed points":
- Frictionless Isotropic Jamming: Dominant at low stresses.
- Frictional Shear Jamming: Dominant at high stresses.
To test this framework, the team performed high-precision rheometry on two distinct systems: cornstarch in glycerol (organic, irregular, and polydisperse) and silica spheres in glycerol (synthetic, spherical, and charge-stabilized).
Experimental Results and Universal Scaling
The experimental data for both cornstarch and silica, spanning multiple orders of magnitude in stress $\sigma$ and volume fraction $\phi$, were successfully collapsed onto a single universal curve.
As shown in Figure 4, the raw viscosity curves (panels a and b) vary significantly with volume fraction. However, when plotted using the scaling function $\mathcal{F}_{WC}$ against the variable $x_{WC}$ (panels c and d), the data for both materials collapse onto a universal trajectory. This collapse reveals two distinct regimes:
- A low-stress regime governed by frictionless jamming with a scaling exponent of -2.
- A high-stress regime characterized by frictional shear jamming with a newly identified critical exponent $\delta \approx 1.5$.
Discussion and Conclusion
The success of this scaling approach demonstrates that the fundamental physics of jamming is universal. The apparent differences between materials like cornstarch and silica are captured by the anisotropy parameter $C(\phi)$, which accounts for how different particle geometries arrange themselves under flow. Once this material-specific factor is accounted for, the underlying transition follows the same mathematical laws for both systems.
This framework not only provides a predictive tool for the onset of Discontinuous Shear Thickening (DST) but also bridges the gap between soft matter rheology and statistical mechanics. By identifying universal scaling laws, this research transforms the study of complex fluids from empirical observation into a rigorous branch of critical phenomena, with applications ranging from industrial processing to the design of advanced protective materials.
Summary updated