Incorporating tunability into a universal scaling framework for shear thickening

Meera Ramaswamy, Itay Griniasty, James P. Sethna, Bulbul Chakraborty, Itai CohenarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Recently, we proposed a universal scaling framework that shows shear thickening in dense suspensions is governed by the crossover between two critical points: one associated with frictionless isotropic jamming and a second corresponding to frictional shear jamming. Here, we show that orthogonal perturbations to the flows, an effective method for tuning shear thickening, can also be folded into this universal scaling framework. Specifically, we show that the effect of adding in orthogonal shear perturbations (OSP) can be incorporated by simply altering the scaling variable to include a multiplicative term that decreases with the normalized OSP strain rate. These results demonstrate the broad applicability of our scaling framework, and illustrate how it can be modified to incorporate other complex flow fields.

Introduction: The Challenge of Shear Thickening

Dense suspensions, such as the common mixture of cornstarch and water known as "oobleck," exhibit a complex non-Newtonian behavior called shear thickening. As stress increases, these fluids become significantly more viscous. This transition occurs because particles, which glide past each other under low stress due to lubrication, begin to form frictional contacts and robust force chains at higher stresses. In extreme scenarios, the suspension can "jam," transitioning from a fluid to a solid-like state.

While it was known that applying a secondary, orthogonal flow—such as vibrating the fluid sideways—could "tune" this viscosity and break up force chains, a universal mathematical description of this effect was missing. This research integrates these complex, multi-directional flows into a single, universal scaling law applicable across a wide range of concentrations and stress levels.

Methodology: Integrating Orthogonal Perturbations

The researchers utilized an ARES G2 rheometer with a double-wall Couette geometry to study cornstarch suspended in glycerol across seven volume fractions ($\phi = 0.37$ to $0.52$). By rotating the outer cup, they established a primary steady shear, while simultaneously vibrating the inner part of the tool to create orthogonal shear perturbations (OSP) at frequencies ranging from 0.05 $s^{-1}$ to 100 $s^{-1}$.

The core innovation lies in the modification of a "Universal Scaling Framework." This framework treats shear thickening as a crossover between two critical points: frictionless jamming at low stress and frictional jamming at high stress. To incorporate the effect of OSP, the team introduced a new scaling variable, $\tilde{x}$, which includes a multiplicative term $g(\dot{\Gamma})$. This term quantifies the competition between the formation of force chains by primary shear and their disruption by orthogonal perturbations.

Universal Data Collapse

A key finding of this work is the "Universal Collapse" of experimental data. Despite the added complexity of two-dimensional flow, the data from dozens of experiments collapsed onto a single universal curve. This collapse demonstrates that the underlying physics of jamming remains consistent even when external perturbations are applied.

Figure 1: Viscosity measurements and universal scaling collapse. (a) Viscosity vs. stress for various volume fractions. (b) Viscosity vs. normalized strain rate for a fixed volume fraction. (c, d) Successful collapse of data onto universal scaling functions across multiple orders of magnitude.

The "dethickening" effect is observed to begin when the dimensionless strain rate $\dot{\Gamma} \approx 1$. At this point, the rate of orthogonal perturbation matches the rate of forward shear, effectively preventing the stabilization of frictional force chains. This reciprocity principle—where stress builds contacts and OSP destroys them—allows both effects to be captured by the same scaling logic.

Controlling the Jamming Phase Diagram

The researchers also mapped the impact of OSP on the material's state using a Jamming Phase Diagram. As the intensity of the "shake" (the normalized strain rate $\dot{\Gamma}$) increases, the region of the phase space where the fluid jams into a solid significantly shrinks.

Figure 2: Jamming Phase Diagram showing the transition between flowing and jammed states. As the normalized strain rate increases, the jammed region (red) recedes, demonstrating the tunability of the suspension's mechanical state.

This visualization confirms that Discontinuous Shear Thickening (DST)—the abrupt jump in viscosity—can be entirely suppressed if the OSP is sufficiently strong. By adjusting the OSP, researchers can effectively "dethicken" the material on the fly.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study provides a robust framework for controlling non-Newtonian fluids by folding tunability into universal scaling laws. While the current model successfully collapses data across seven orders of magnitude, future work will aim to gather data at higher stresses and volume fractions to further refine the universal constants. This framework holds significant promise for industrial applications, such as using acoustic vibrations to prevent clogs in concrete pumping or other dense suspension transport systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, we proposed a universal scaling framework that shows shear thickening in dense suspensions is governed by the crossover between two critical points: one associated with frictionless isotropic jamming and a second corresponding to frictional shear jamming. Here, we show that orthogonal perturbations to the flows, an effective method for tuning shear thickening, can also be folded into this universal scaling framework. Specifically, we show that the effect of adding in orthogonal shear perturbations (OSP) can be incorporated by simply altering the scaling variable to include a multiplicative term that decreases with the normalized OSP strain rate. These results demonstrate the broad applicability of our scaling framework, and illustrate how it can be modified to incorporate other complex flow fields.
BibTeX
@misc{ramaswamy2022incorporating,
  author = {Meera Ramaswamy and Itay Griniasty and James P. Sethna and Bulbul Chakraborty and Itai Cohen},
  title = {{Incorporating tunability into a universal scaling framework for shear thickening}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2205.02184},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.02184},
}
Figure