Universal scaling for disordered viscoelastic matter II: Collapses, global behavior and spatio-temporal properties

Danilo B. Liarte, Stephen J. Thornton, Eric Schwen, Itai Cohen, Debanjan Chowdhury, James P. SethnaarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Disordered viscoelastic materials are ubiquitous and exhibit fascinating invariant scaling properties. In a companion article, we have presented comprehensive new results for the critical behavior of the dynamic susceptibility of disordered elastic systems near the onset of rigidity. Here we provide additional details of the derivation of the singular scaling forms of the longitudinal response near both jamming and rigidity percolation. We then discuss global aspects associated with these forms, and make scaling collapse plots for both undamped and overdamped dynamics in both the rigid and floppy phases. We also derive critical exponents, invariant scaling combinations and analytical formulas for universal scaling functions of several quantities such as transverse and density responses, elastic moduli, viscosities, and correlation functions. Finally, we discuss tentative experimental protocols to measure these behaviors in colloidal suspensions.

Introduction: The Onset of Rigidity

Understanding how disorder leads to rigidity is a fundamental challenge in condensed matter physics. This transition is typically described by two primary models: Jamming, where particles are compressed until they reach a rigid state, and Rigidity Percolation, where bonds are added to a network until it becomes stiff.

Phase diagram illustrating the floppy-to-rigid transition. The jamming point $J$ and the rigidity percolation boundary are shown in the $p_N, p_B$ plane.

While static properties like stiffness are well-documented, this paper focuses on the dynamic response—how these materials behave over time and across different frequencies. The authors bridge the gap between jamming and rigidity percolation by providing a unified mathematical framework that accounts for both spatial (wavelength) and temporal (frequency) dependencies.

Theoretical Framework and Methods

The study utilizes the Honeycomb-Triangular Lattice (HTL) Model, which can simulate both jamming and rigidity percolation by adjusting bond occupancy. To handle the complexity of disorder, the researchers applied the Coherent Potential Approximation (CPA), a form of effective-medium theory (EMT). This approach treats the disordered system as a homogeneous "effective" medium, allowing for tractable analytical solutions.

A central component of the work is the Scaling Ansatz. The authors proposed a mathematical template for the material's response and used EMT to determine specific universal functions and critical exponents.

Scaling Collapses and Key Results

To validate the theory, the authors performed "scaling collapses." By rescaling data points taken at various frequencies, wavelengths, and distances from the rigidity threshold, they demonstrated that the data "collapses" onto a single universal curve.

Scaling collapses of the longitudinal response. The data points from various regimes fall onto universal curves, validating the proposed scaling forms.

Key Insights:

  • Dynamic Loss from Disorder: Even in undamped systems (no internal friction), disorder causes energy dissipation. High-frequency waves scatter off the disordered structure, mimicking macroscopic viscosity.
  • Universality: Jamming and rigidity percolation belong to the same scaling family. They share functional forms but differ in their critical exponents ($\gamma, z, \nu, \phi$).
  • Global Behavior: The authors mapped power-law regimes in the frequency-wavevector plane, providing a "field guide" for how material response evolves across different scales.
  • Effective Diffusion: In overdamped systems, the theory predicts an effective diffusion constant that vanishes as the material approaches rigidity.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The paper provides a comprehensive roadmap for experimentalists, suggesting protocols using 3D-printed networks or colloidal suspensions. Future work aims to address low-frequency gaps in undamped systems, explore logarithmic corrections in two dimensions, and extend the framework to "active" disordered matter, such as biological tissues or self-propelled particles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Disordered viscoelastic materials are ubiquitous and exhibit fascinating invariant scaling properties. In a companion article, we have presented comprehensive new results for the critical behavior of the dynamic susceptibility of disordered elastic systems near the onset of rigidity. Here we provide additional details of the derivation of the singular scaling forms of the longitudinal response near both jamming and rigidity percolation. We then discuss global aspects associated with these forms, and make scaling collapse plots for both undamped and overdamped dynamics in both the rigid and floppy phases. We also derive critical exponents, invariant scaling combinations and analytical formulas for universal scaling functions of several quantities such as transverse and density responses, elastic moduli, viscosities, and correlation functions. Finally, we discuss tentative experimental protocols to measure these behaviors in colloidal suspensions.
BibTeX
@misc{liarte2022universal,
  author = {Danilo B. Liarte and Stephen J. Thornton and Eric Schwen and Itai Cohen and Debanjan Chowdhury and James P. Sethna},
  title = {{Universal scaling for disordered viscoelastic matter II: Collapses, global behavior and spatio-temporal properties}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2202.13933},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.13933},
}
Figure