Universal Fermi-surface anisotropy renormalization for interacting Dirac fermions with long-range interactions

Jia Ning Leaw, Ho-Kin Tang, Maxim Trushin, Fakher F. Assaad, Shaffique AdamProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Recent experimental and numerical evidence suggests an intriguing universal relationship between the Fermi surface anisotropy of the noninteracting parent 2D electron gas and the strongly correlated composite Fermi liquid formed in a strong magnetic field close to half-filling. Using nonperturbative and numerically exact projective quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations alongside analytical techniques, we demonstrate that for Dirac fermions with long-range Coulomb interactions, there exists a universal square-root decrease of the Fermi-surface anisotropy ($\eta \approx \sqrt{\eta_0}$). This finding supports the proposal of a Dirac fermion ground state for the $\nu=1/2$ composite Fermi liquid and suggests a broader universality applicable to various anisotropic Dirac materials such as graphene and topological insulators.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, the Fermi surface—the boundary between occupied and unoccupied electron states—is a fundamental concept. While often idealized as isotropic (circular or spherical), real materials frequently exhibit anisotropy due to their underlying crystal lattice. A critical question is how electron-electron interactions modify this anisotropy: do they enhance the distortion or suppress it? Recent studies of composite Fermi liquids near half-filled Landau levels observed a surprising universal relationship where the interacting anisotropy ($\eta$) appeared to be the square root of the non-interacting anisotropy ($\eta_0$). This research investigates the origin of this behavior and its general applicability to 2D Dirac systems.

The Square-Root Universality

The central finding of this work is that for Dirac fermions coupled with long-range Coulomb interactions, the Fermi surface anisotropy is renormalized according to a universal "square-root" rule: $\eta \approx \sqrt{\eta_0}$. Remarkably, this relationship is largely independent of the interaction strength, suggesting a robust behavior rooted in the system's underlying physics.

Interacting anisotropy $\eta$ as a function of non-interacting anisotropy $\eta_0$ for various models and experimental data, showing the universal $\eta = \sqrt{\eta_0}$ relationship.

As shown in Figure 1, data from diverse sources—including QMC simulations on honeycomb and $\pi$-flux lattices, DMRG calculations, and experimental measurements of composite fermions—all converge on the $\eta = \sqrt{\eta_0}$ curve. This convergence across different physical systems and methodologies highlights the universal nature of the phenomenon.

Numerical Evidence and Model Comparison

To validate these findings, the authors employed projective Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations, a numerically exact method capable of handling strong correlations without the approximations required by perturbative theories. They tested two distinct lattice geometries to ensure the results were not model-specific: the honeycomb lattice and the $\pi$-flux model.

Momentum dependence of the interacting anisotropy in the $\pi$-flux model (top) and honeycomb lattice (bottom), demonstrating the renormalization towards the square-root limit.

Figure 2 illustrates the momentum dependence of the interacting anisotropy. In both models, the interacting anisotropy $\eta$ (represented by data points) is significantly reduced from the non-interacting value $\eta_0$ (dashed lines) and closely follows the predicted square-root behavior $\sqrt{\eta_0}$ (solid lines) as the momentum approaches the Dirac point.

Essential Ingredients: Chirality and Long-Range Interactions

The study identifies two necessary conditions for this universal renormalization:

  1. Dirac Chirality: The electrons must behave as Dirac fermions, where their pseudospin is locked to their momentum. Standard "Schrödinger" electrons do not exhibit this universal scaling; their renormalization typically depends on material-specific parameters like effective mass or dielectric constants.
  2. Long-Range Coulomb Interactions: The $1/r$ nature of the interaction is crucial. Simulations using short-range Hubbard interactions showed negligible change in anisotropy ($\eta \approx \eta_0$), indicating that the long-range tail of the Coulomb potential is the primary driver for reshaping the Fermi surface.

Implications and Future Outlook

These results provide strong theoretical support for the "Dirac composite fermion" hypothesis, which proposes that the composite Fermi liquid at $\nu=1/2$ is a Dirac fermion state. This explains why the square-root rule, derived here for general Dirac systems, was observed in quantum Hall experiments.

Beyond the quantum Hall effect, this universality should be observable in other anisotropic Dirac materials. Potential candidates for experimental verification include strained graphene, topological insulators, organic conductors, and magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene. Future work may explore the effects of screening in high-density systems, which could potentially suppress the long-range interactions and break the universality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent experimental [I. Jo <i>et al</i>., <i>Phys. Rev. Lett.</i> 119, 016402 (2017)] and numerical [M. Ippoliti, S. D. Geraedts, R. N. Bhatt, <i>Phys. Rev. B</i> 95, 201104 (2017)] evidence suggests an intriguing universal relationship between the Fermi surface anisotropy of the noninteracting parent 2-dimensional (2D) electron gas and the strongly correlated composite Fermi liquid formed in a strong magnetic field close to half-filling. Inspired by these observations, we explore more generally the question of anisotropy renormalization in interacting 2D Fermi systems. Using a recently developed [H. -K. Tang <i>et al</i>., <i>Science</i> 361, 570 (2018)] nonperturbative and numerically exact projective quantum Monte Carlo simulation as well as other numerical and analytic techniques, only for Dirac fermions with long-range Coulomb interactions do we find a universal square-root decrease of the Fermi-surface anisotropy. For the [Formula: see text] composite Fermi liquid, this result is surprising since a Dirac fermion ground state was only recently proposed as an alternative to the usual Halperin-Lee-Read state. Our proposed universality can be tested in several anisotropic Dirac materials including graphene, topological insulators, organic conductors, and magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{leaw2019universal,
  author = {Jia Ning Leaw and Ho-Kin Tang and Maxim Trushin and Fakher F. Assaad and Shaffique Adam},
  title = {{Universal Fermi-surface anisotropy renormalization for interacting Dirac fermions with long-range interactions}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1913096116},
}
Figure