Uniform Generalization Bounds on Data-Dependent Hypothesis Sets via PAC-Bayesian Theory on Random Sets

Benjamin Dupuis, Paul Viallard, George Deligiannidis, Umut Simsekli

Abstract

We propose data-dependent uniform generalization bounds by approaching the problem from a PAC-Bayesian perspective. We first apply the PAC-Bayesian framework on 'random sets' in a rigorous way, where the training algorithm is assumed to output a data-dependent hypothesis set after observing the training data. This approach allows us to prove data-dependent bounds, which can be applicable in numerous contexts. To highlight the power of our approach, we consider two main applications. First, we propose a PAC-Bayesian formulation of the recently developed fractal-dimension-based generalization bounds. The derived results are shown to be tighter and they unify the existing results around one simple proof technique. Second, we prove uniform bounds over the trajectories of continuous Langevin dynamics and stochastic gradient Langevin dynamics. These results provide novel information about the generalization properties of noisy algorithms.

The Challenge of Data-Dependent Generalization

In classical learning theory, the goal is to bound the "generalization gap"—the difference between a model's performance on training data versus unseen data. Traditional tools like Rademacher complexity typically assume a fixed hypothesis set. However, modern deep learning models are so overparameterized that these fixed sets are often "vacuous," providing no meaningful guarantees because they are too large.

In practice, an algorithm does not explore every possible model; it follows a specific path dictated by the training data. To obtain tighter, more realistic bounds, we must analyze data-dependent hypothesis sets. The primary mathematical challenge is that data-dependence breaks the standard "symmetrization" techniques used in most proofs. This paper introduces a unified, mathematically rigorous framework to handle these sets using PAC-Bayesian theory on random sets.

Methods: PAC-Bayesian Theory on Random Sets

The authors bridge the gap by extending PAC-Bayesian theory—which usually places probability distributions over individual hypotheses—to random sets.

  1. Random Set Framework: Instead of a distribution over single models, they define a "prior" and "posterior" over sets of models. This allows for "disintegrated" PAC-Bayesian bounds that account for the statistical dependence between the training data and the set of hypotheses explored by the algorithm.
  2. Information-Theoretic (IT) Terms: They replace complex Mutual Information terms found in prior literature with a simpler Radon-Nikodym derivative. This measures how much the data-dependent "posterior" set deviates from a data-independent "prior" set.
  3. Stochastic Calculus for Langevin Dynamics: To bound the generalization of Continuous Langevin Dynamics (CLD) and Stochastic Gradient Langevin Dynamics (SGLD), they utilize Girsanov’s Theorem. This allows them to analytically express the "distance" between the trajectory of an optimizer running on real data versus a "prior" trajectory, such as Brownian motion.

Key Insights and Unification

Unifying Fractal-Dimension Bounds

A major contribution is the unification of fractal-geometry-based bounds. By treating the optimization path as a random set, the authors show that fractal-dimension bounds can be derived from a single proof technique. Their framework improves the convergence rates of these bounds from $n^{-1/3}$ to the standard $n^{-1/2}$, making them significantly tighter as the dataset size ($n$) increases.

Comparison of fractal-dimension-based generalization bounds showing that the proposed method achieves the smallest information-theoretic (IT) terms.

Uniform Bounds for Langevin Trajectories

The paper provides the first high-probability uniform bounds for CLD and SGLD. Unlike previous work that often provided point-wise bounds (guarantees for the final iterate $W_T$), these new bounds hold for the entire trajectory. This means the guarantee remains valid regardless of when the user decides to stop training. These results relate generalization error to the average gradient norm along the trajectory; a smoother optimization path (smaller average gradients) suggests more reliable generalization.

Comparison of generalization bounds for SGLD trajectories, highlighting the uniform nature (max over iterations) of the proposed bounds.

Conclusion and Future Directions

By treating the entire optimization trajectory as a single data-dependent hypothesis set, this work provides a powerful new lens for understanding generalization. The framework not only yields tighter upper bounds but also the first data-dependent lower bounds, defining the fundamental limits of these algorithms. Future work may involve relaxing the bounded loss assumption and exploring links to Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to measure generalization by the "shape" of training trajectories.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose data-dependent uniform generalization bounds by approaching the problem from a PAC-Bayesian perspective. We first apply the PAC-Bayesian framework on `random sets' in a rigorous way, where the training algorithm is assumed to output a data-dependent hypothesis set after observing the training data. This approach allows us to prove data-dependent bounds, which can be applicable in numerous contexts. To highlight the power of our approach, we consider two main applications. First, we propose a PAC-Bayesian formulation of the recently developed fractal-dimension-based generalization bounds. The derived results are shown to be tighter and they unify the existing results around one simple proof technique. Second, we prove uniform bounds over the trajectories of continuous Langevin dynamics and stochastic gradient Langevin dynamics. These results provide novel information about the generalization properties of noisy algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{dupuis2024uniform,
  author = {Benjamin Dupuis and Paul Viallard and George Deligiannidis and Umut Simsekli},
  title = {{Uniform Generalization Bounds on Data-Dependent Hypothesis Sets via PAC-Bayesian Theory on Random Sets}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2404.17442},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17442},
}
Figure