Unexplained infertility is frequently caused by defective CatSper function preventing sperm from penetrating the egg coat

Samuel Young, Christian Schiffer, Alice Wagner, Jannika Patz, A. Potapenko, Leonie Herrmann, Verena Nordhoff, Tim Pock, Claudia Krallmann, Birgit Stallmeyer, Albrecht Röpke, Michelina Kierzek, Cristina Biagioni, Tao Wang, Lars Haalck, Dirk Deuster, Jan N. Hansen, Dagmar Wachten, Benjamin Risse, Hermann M. Behre, Stefan Schlatt, Sabine Kliesch, Frank Tüttelmann, Christoph Brenker, Timo StrünkermedRxiv 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The infertility of many couples seems to rest on an enigmatic dysfunction of the men’s sperm, rendering early diagnosis and evidence-based treatment by medically assisted reproduction impossible. Using a novel laboratory test, we assessed the function of the flagellar Ca 2+ channel CatSper in sperm of almost 2,300 men undergoing a fertility workup. Thereby, we identified a group of men with mutations in CATSPER genes affecting the function of the channel. Although standard semen and computer-assisted sperm analysis were unremarkable, the couples required intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to conceive a child. We show that their seemingly unexplained infertility and need for ICSI is, in fact, due to the failure of CatSper-deficient human sperm to hyperactivate and penetrate the egg coat. In summary, our study reveals that defective CatSper function represents the most common cause of unexplained male-factor infertility known thus far and that CatSper-related infertility can readily be diagnosed, enabling evidence-based treatment.

Introduction

In approximately one-third of infertile men, standard clinical evaluations—which assess sperm count, morphology, and basic motility—return normal results. This condition, termed "unexplained male infertility" (UMI), leaves clinicians and couples without a clear path forward, often leading to repeated, unsuccessful rounds of intrauterine insemination (IUI) or standard in vitro fertilization (IVF).

This research focuses on the CatSper channel, a sperm-specific calcium channel located in the flagellum (tail). While animal models have long suggested that CatSper is essential for fertility, its specific role in human UMI remained poorly understood and difficult to diagnose. This study demonstrates that CatSper dysfunction is a major hidden driver of human infertility and introduces a diagnostic tool to identify it early in the fertility workup.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach to screen a massive clinical cohort of 2,286 men undergoing fertility evaluations at the Centre of Reproductive Medicine and Andrology in Münster, Germany.

The CatSper-Activity-Test (CAI)

To identify functional defects, the team developed the CAI test. This diagnostic is based on the physiological observation that sperm motility is sensitive to extracellular calcium. In healthy sperm, the addition of progesterone opens the CatSper channel, accelerating the loss of motility in specific conditions. Sperm that fail to respond to progesterone are identified as having impaired CatSper function.

Advanced Imaging and Genetics

For patients who failed the CAI test, the researchers used high-speed imaging (up to 250 fps) and specialized "SpermQ" software to analyze 3D flagellar beat patterns. Genetic underlying causes were investigated using:

  • SNP-array analysis and MLPA to detect gene deletions.
  • Whole-exome sequencing to identify specific mutations within the CATSPER gene family.
  • Viscous media penetration tests to simulate the sperm's ability to navigate the protective egg coat (zona pellucida).

Key Insights

The "Stealth" Defect

CatSper-deficient sperm are "normozoospermic," meaning they appear healthy under standard microscopic examination. They can swim effectively in simple fluids; however, they are incapable of hyperactivation. Hyperactivation is the high-power, asymmetrical swimming style required to physically penetrate the egg's outer layer. Without a functional CatSper channel, the sperm cannot trigger this essential mechanical shift.

The study identified homozygous deletions of the CATSPER2 gene as the most frequent cause of this dysfunction. Interestingly, because CATSPER2 is located adjacent to the STRC gene (associated with hearing), some affected men also exhibit "Deafness-Infertility Syndrome." In these cases, mild hearing loss serves as a clinical marker for the underlying fertility issue.

Results and Clinical Impact

  • Prevalence: CatSper-related defects were found to account for 2.3% of unexplained infertility cases, making it the most common known cause of male-factor infertility in this category.
  • Functional Failure: In penetration assays, healthy sperm increased their penetration rate by 1.7-fold when stimulated with progesterone. In contrast, CatSper-deficient sperm showed zero response, confirming their inability to reach the oocyte.
  • Treatment Success: The study found that while these patients had a 0% success rate with standard IVF, those who transitioned to Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) achieved successful fertilization and live births. ICSI bypasses the need for the CatSper channel by injecting the sperm directly into the egg.

Conclusion

Defective CatSper function is a significant, previously hidden cause of male infertility. By implementing the CAI test alongside standard semen analysis, clinics can identify these cases early. This diagnostic shift allows couples to avoid the emotional and financial toll of failed IUI and IVF cycles, moving directly to evidence-based treatments like ICSI.

Summary updated

Abstract

The infertility of many couples seems to rest on an enigmatic dysfunction of the men’s sperm, rendering early diagnosis and evidence-based treatment by medically assisted reproduction impossible. Using a novel laboratory test, we assessed the function of the flagellar Ca 2+ channel CatSper in sperm of almost 2,300 men undergoing a fertility workup. Thereby, we identified a group of men with mutations in CATSPER genes affecting the function of the channel. Although standard semen and computer-assisted sperm analysis were unremarkable, the couples required intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to conceive a child. We show that their seemingly unexplained infertility and need for ICSI is, in fact, due to the failure of CatSper-deficient human sperm to hyperactivate and penetrate the egg coat. In summary, our study reveals that defective CatSper function represents the most common cause of unexplained male-factor infertility known thus far and that CatSper-related infertility can readily be diagnosed, enabling evidence-based treatment.
BibTeX
@misc{young2023unexplained,
  author = {Samuel Young and Christian Schiffer and Alice Wagner and Jannika Patz and A. Potapenko and Leonie Herrmann and Verena Nordhoff and Tim Pock and Claudia Krallmann and Birgit Stallmeyer and Albrecht Röpke and Michelina Kierzek and Cristina Biagioni and Tao Wang and Lars Haalck and Dirk Deuster and Jan N. Hansen and Dagmar Wachten and Benjamin Risse and Hermann M. Behre and Stefan Schlatt and Sabine Kliesch and Frank Tüttelmann and Christoph Brenker and Timo Strünker},
  title = {{Unexplained infertility is frequently caused by defective CatSper function preventing sperm from penetrating the egg coat}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.23.23286813},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure