Human fertilization in vivo and in vitro requires the CatSper channel to initiate sperm hyperactivation

Samuel Young, Christian Schiffer, Alice Wagner, Jannika Patz, A. Potapenko, Leonie Herrmann, Verena Nordhoff, Tim Pock, Claudia Krallmann, Birgit Stallmeyer, Albrecht Röpke, Michelina Kierzek, Cristina Biagioni, Tao Wang, Lars Haalck, Dirk Deuster, Jan N. Hansen, Dagmar Wachten, Benjamin Risse, Hermann M. Behre, Stefan Schlatt, Sabine Kliesch, Frank Tüttelmann, Christoph Brenker, Timo StrünkerJournal of Clinical Investigation 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The infertility of many couples rests on an enigmatic dysfunction of the man's sperm. To gain insight into the underlying pathomechanisms, we assessed the function of the sperm-specific multisubunit CatSper-channel complex in the sperm of almost 2,300 men undergoing a fertility workup, using a simple motility-based test. We identified a group of men with normal semen parameters but defective CatSper function. These men or couples failed to conceive naturally and upon medically assisted reproduction via intrauterine insemination and in vitro fertilization. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was, ultimately, required to conceive a child. We revealed that the defective CatSper function was caused by variations in CATSPER genes. Moreover, we unveiled that CatSper-deficient human sperm were unable to undergo hyperactive motility and, therefore, failed to penetrate the egg coat. Thus, our study provides the experimental evidence that sperm hyperactivation is required for human fertilization, explaining the infertility of CatSper-deficient men and the need of ICSI for medically assisted reproduction. Finally, our study also revealed that defective CatSper function and ensuing failure to hyperactivate represents the most common cause of unexplained male infertility known thus far and that this sperm channelopathy can readily be diagnosed, enabling future evidence-based treatment of affected couples.

Introduction

Infertility affects millions of couples worldwide. For approximately one-third of infertile men, standard semen analysis—which evaluates sperm count, morphology, and basic motility—reveals no abnormalities. This "unexplained" or normozoospermic infertility leaves many couples without a clear diagnosis or effective treatment path, often leading to repeated failures in natural conception and standard assisted reproductive techniques like In Vitro Fertilization (IVF).

Researchers suspected the underlying cause was a failure in hyperactivation, a specialized swimming state required for sperm to penetrate the egg's protective outer layer, the zona pellucida. This study identifies the sperm-specific CatSper calcium channel as the essential molecular engine for this transition in humans and provides a diagnostic framework for identifying affected individuals.

Methods

To investigate CatSper function on a large scale, the team developed the CatSper-Activity-Test, a novel, low-cost diagnostic tool. This test leverages a unique physiological response: while normal sperm cease moving in calcium-free buffers, CatSper-deficient sperm continue to swim. By measuring motility changes in response to progesterone (a known CatSper activator), researchers calculated a "CatSper-Activity-Index" (CAI).

Motility-based test principle showing sperm response to calcium-free conditions and CatSper inhibition.

Beyond clinical screening, the study utilized high-resolution biophysical techniques, including sperm patch-clamping to measure ion currents and optochemistry with "caged" progesterone to observe millisecond-scale flagellar responses. Genetic analysis via whole-exome sequencing and SNP-arrays was performed to link functional defects to mutations in the CATSPER gene family.

Results

The study screened a massive cohort of 2,286 men undergoing fertility evaluations. The CatSper-Activity-Test identified nine men (C1–C9) with severe CatSper defects. These individuals possessed normal standard semen parameters but exhibited a near-zero CAI, clearly distinguishing them from the rest of the cohort.

CatSper-Activity-Index (CAI) across a cohort of 2,286 men, identifying nine patients (C1–C9) with severe defects.

Clinical follow-up revealed that these patients had a 0% success rate with natural conception, intrauterine insemination (IUI), and standard IVF. Video microscopy confirmed that their sperm could reach the egg but were unable to penetrate the zona pellucida. However, when these couples transitioned to Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI)—where a single sperm is injected directly into the egg—fertilization rates rose to approximately 60%, leading to successful live births. Genetic testing confirmed that eight of these men had deletions in CATSPER2, while one carried rare variants in CATSPERE.

Discussion and Conclusion

This research provides definitive evidence that CatSper-mediated hyperactivation is mandatory for human fertilization. Because CatSper is not required for sperm production or basic motility, its dysfunction represents a "hidden" channelopathy that escapes detection by standard clinical tests.

The study estimates that CatSper-related infertility is the most common known cause of unexplained male infertility, affecting roughly 2.3% of men in this group. Integrating the CatSper-Activity-Test into routine diagnostics could prevent couples from undergoing costly and emotionally draining failed IVF cycles, directing them immediately toward effective treatments like ICSI. Future research will explore the prevalence of partial CatSper impairment and the channel's role in sperm navigation within the complex environment of the human oviduct.

Summary updated

Abstract

The infertility of many couples rests on an enigmatic dysfunction of the man's sperm. To gain insight into the underlying pathomechanisms, we assessed the function of the sperm-specific multisubunit CatSper-channel complex in the sperm of almost 2,300 men undergoing a fertility workup, using a simple motility-based test. We identified a group of men with normal semen parameters but defective CatSper function. These men or couples failed to conceive naturally and upon medically assisted reproduction via intrauterine insemination and in vitro fertilization. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was, ultimately, required to conceive a child. We revealed that the defective CatSper function was caused by variations in CATSPER genes. Moreover, we unveiled that CatSper-deficient human sperm were unable to undergo hyperactive motility and, therefore, failed to penetrate the egg coat. Thus, our study provides the experimental evidence that sperm hyperactivation is required for human fertilization, explaining the infertility of CatSper-deficient men and the need of ICSI for medically assisted reproduction. Finally, our study also revealed that defective CatSper function and ensuing failure to hyperactivate represents the most common cause of unexplained male infertility known thus far and that this sperm channelopathy can readily be diagnosed, enabling future evidence-based treatment of affected couples.
BibTeX
@article{young2024human,
  author = {Samuel Young and Christian Schiffer and Alice Wagner and Jannika Patz and A. Potapenko and Leonie Herrmann and Verena Nordhoff and Tim Pock and Claudia Krallmann and Birgit Stallmeyer and Albrecht Röpke and Michelina Kierzek and Cristina Biagioni and Tao Wang and Lars Haalck and Dirk Deuster and Jan N. Hansen and Dagmar Wachten and Benjamin Risse and Hermann M. Behre and Stefan Schlatt and Sabine Kliesch and Frank Tüttelmann and Christoph Brenker and Timo Strünker},
  title = {{Human fertilization in vivo and in vitro requires the CatSper channel to initiate sperm hyperactivation}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Investigation},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1172/jci173564},
}
Figure